“An operational hurdle has just been cleared,” says Investre’s founder, Georges Bock, referring to the FAQs published on Friday by the CSSF regarding transfer agents. (Photo: Guy Wolff/Archives)

“An operational hurdle has just been cleared,” says Investre’s founder, Georges Bock, referring to the FAQs published on Friday by the CSSF regarding transfer agents. (Photo: Guy Wolff/Archives)

The CSSF has authorised funds to combine traditional and tokenised units with multiple registry agents, according to the FAQs published by the regulator on Friday. At the same time, Investre has been granted authorisation to combine the roles of registrar and custodian. For its founder, Georges Bock, this has removed a major operational hurdle.

The technology already made it possible to record fund units on a blockchain. The real obstacle lay elsewhere: in the highly traditional way in which their administration was organised. In a nine-page document, the CSSF has just provided Luxembourg’s stakeholders with a framework to overcome this.

Published on Friday 2 October, the first version of the Commission de Surveillance du Secteur Financier’s FAQs on tokenisation confirms, first and foremost, that a Luxembourg collective investment scheme may issue units natively on a distributed ledger technology (DLT) infrastructure. These units may be registered or dematerialised. The technology used does not, therefore, determine their legal form on its own.

The most significant clarification, however, concerns intermediaries. Even where dematerialised units are placed under the responsibility of a supervisory agent, the fund must retain an administrator to perform the role of registrar. The two roles do not involve the same tasks.

The control agent is responsible for the issue account and the integrity of entries on the DLT. The registrar remains responsible, in particular, for the register of investors, the processing of subscription and redemption orders, settlements and communication with clients. A single company may perform both functions provided it holds the necessary authorisations.

A regulated coexistence

This distinction could have added an extra layer to the system. The CSSF has, at the same time, opened up another possibility: a fund offering both traditional units and tokenised units may appoint several entities to act as registrar. One may handle the traditional units and the other those issued on the blockchain.

This coexistence remains subject to certain conditions. The division of tasks must not hinder the coordination or overall supervision of the scheme. Service providers and their roles must be identified in the tender documents. Above all, the fund must maintain a consolidated view of all units issued, which is necessary for calculating the net asset value, making distributions and issuing capital calls. Responsibility for this consolidation may lie with the fund manager or one of its directors.

For Georges BockGeorges Bock, founder and CEO of Investre, believes this development marks a break with the market’s traditional structure. “For the first time, they have opened the door to two transfer agents within a single investment fund,” he says. Until now, he explains, a project could become stalled if the long-standing transfer agent (TA) lacked the necessary technology or was unwilling to cooperate with a new operator.

However, the FAQ does not recognise a general right to increase the number of agents. It accepts this arrangement where traditional and tokenised units coexist, subject to a clear division of responsibilities, the management of additional risks and the maintenance of a consolidated view of the fund.

Investre is already ready for this new space

Investre intends to fill the gap thus created. The Luxembourg-based company has announced that it has received authorisation from the CSSF to act as a registrar, as provided for in Article 25 of the Law of 5 April 1993 on the financial sector. This authorisation enables it to act as a register and to communicate with investors in accordance with CSSF Circular 22/811. According to its press release, the company already held the first authorisation as a supervisory agent granted by the CSSF under Luxembourg legislation on dematerialised securities. It can now offer both services within a single supervised entity.

In the first model, Investre maintains the register of registered shares on the blockchain. The entry on the blockchain therefore constitutes the register itself, rather than a digital copy that needs to be reconciled with an external register. In the second model, shares are issued in dematerialised form: the company acts both as the issuing account control agent and as the registrar for processing transactions and communicating with investors.

Investre will also be able to work alongside an existing service provider. The latter will be able to continue managing the traditional units, whilst Investre will take charge of the tokenised units. “If the transfer agent says, ‘I don’t want to deal with tokenised units’, there can be two transfer agents,” explains Georges Bock. “They said, ‘We’re prepared to accept two transfert agents if one is responsible for the tokenised units and the other for the non-tokenised ones’.”

A break with 35 years of practice

The commercial challenge goes beyond the creation of new, entirely digital funds. It primarily concerns large existing organisations, which can now tokenise a class of units or a sub-fund without immediately having to overhaul their entire administration. “Funds are free to choose a new service provider if their existing one is not up to date, or if it is unwilling to move towards a tokenised model,” says the executive.

The CSSF nevertheless requires applicants to submit their operational model before commencing business. Notification as a supervisory agent must be made at least two months in advance; this period only begins once the application has been deemed complete. The use of technology service providers, for example to develop or administer smart contracts, remains possible but falls within the scope of Dora. The CSSF considers it ‘highly likely’ that the activity of a control agent constitutes a critical or important function.

The FAQ therefore does not turn tokenisation into a testing ground free from the usual rules. On the contrary, it integrates it into the regulated administration of funds, with clearly defined responsibilities for the register, orders, settlements, communication and IT resilience.

This new phase in Luxembourg’s tokenisation journey is less about creating a novel financial instrument and more about removing an operational hurdle. Promoters no longer necessarily have to wait for their long-standing agent to adopt blockchain technology in order to trial a tokenised share class. Investre, for its part, holds the authorisation required to offer this alternative.

For investors, the success of this model could be measured precisely by its invisibility. “Tokenisation will only be successful if the customer doesn’t notice it,” says Georges Bock. Just as with a telephone network, he adds, users will not be interested in the infrastructure as long as the service remains fast, available and cost-effective. The CSSF has just clarified who will be held accountable when it fails to function.