Even the text amended by the Minister for the Economy does not satisfy the Chamber of Commerce, which is calling for the power to verify or take action to ensure that the contribution due to it is correctly calculated. (Photo: Guy Wolff/Archives)

Even the text amended by the Minister for the Economy does not satisfy the Chamber of Commerce, which is calling for the power to verify or take action to ensure that the contribution due to it is correctly calculated. (Photo: Guy Wolff/Archives)

Holding companies will be able to apply to pay just 350 euros a year to the Chamber of Commerce on the basis of a self-declaration. The Chamber considers this system to be too unreliable. It is calling for scrutiny by the tax authorities, as well as the right to challenge in court the flat-rate payment granted to a company.

The Chamber of Commerce does not want to find out after the event that a company will pay it only 350 euros. It is asking to be informed of every decision taken by the tax authorities and to be able to challenge it before the administrative court. This demand is set out in its opinion of 20 November on the draft legislation intended to redefine holding companies and investment vehicles authorised to pay a flat-rate annual levy, regardless of their profits. Other companies normally pay 0.2 per cent of their trading profit, with sliding-scale rates for the highest amounts.

The Government is proposing to replace the statistical code currently in use with a definition set out directly in the law. Each business would declare itself to meet the criteria. The Direct Taxation Authority could then request further information or supporting documents from it.

This simple power of scrutiny “does not provide sufficient legal certainty”, according to the Chamber of Commerce. It is calling for the tax authorities to be expressly tasked with checking tax returns and issuing a decision. This decision would be notified not only to the company but also to the Chamber.

An application for immediate annulment

The opinion goes further. It proposes that both parties should be able to lodge ‘an application for immediate annulment before the administrative court’. The Chamber of Commerce could therefore challenge the tax authority’s decision to grant a holding company or investment vehicle the €350 benefit. It considers that the financial consequences of this classification justify this right of appeal.

For the transitional years 2027 and 2028, the institution is also calling for the power to make its own ‘audit decision’ regarding businesses newly applying for the flat-rate scheme. It could seek the advice of the Direct Taxation Authority and receive the information available to that authority.

This request follows the hasty withdrawal of an initial version of the bill. Tabled on 9 November, the original text removed the provision for certain data held by Statec to be passed on to the Chamber. The Ministry of the Economy withdrew it two days later and replaced it with Bill 8857. The new version retains this flow of information and extends it to the tax authorities. The Chamber of Commerce therefore considers this amendment insufficient. The institution that collects the membership fee is now demanding a role in the procedure that will determine which businesses will be eligible for the flat-rate scheme, including the right to take the matter before an administrative court. Even though its Head of Finance and Membership, Steve Breier, does not expect – according to d’Lëtzebuerger Land this week – a dramatic fall in revenue, this is by no means a ‘trivial’ matter.