At the request of the déi Gréng party, the Institutions Committee discussed the issue of citizen participation on 2 February. The discussion centred on the research paper “La Participation citoyenne peut-elle être institutionnalisée?” (Can citizen participation be institutionalised?). A document written by members of the Chamber of Deputies’ scientific unit in partnership with the University of Luxembourg. Citizen participation, Joëlle Welfring sees only advantages in it. And she would like to see it institutionalised, to build on the various experiments conducted by the Biergerkommitee Lëtzebuerg 2050 set up in 2021 on land organisation and resource management and the Klima-Biergerrot. An institutionalisation not envisaged by the Frieden government.
You are a fervent supporter of extending citizen participation in the political process. Why?
Joëlle Welfring. —“For me, democracy is and will remain a constantly evolving process. And we must always ask ourselves whether the mechanisms as they exist are still valid today. We must remain humble, always asking questions and seeing the limits. And the MEPs agree—with the exception of the ADR, which is no friend of democracy—[on the fact] that what we have at present is not perfect. We need to take action and citizen participation is a good tool.
Wouldn’t putting citizen forums opposite the Chamber of Deputies create conflicts of legitimacy? In other words, in the event of disagreement, who should have the last word?
“Decisions will always be taken by the government with the approval of the Chamber, which holds legislative power. We have to see citizens’ forums as a complement, whose intervention must take place upstream or be started in parallel with the legislative process, to take into account the ideas that citizens and residents can bring to the major societal debates. In the context of pension reform, which we’ll be talking about again, this could be a plus. We could even start a process now that would allow us to go deeper.
The reluctance of the parties to extend the right to vote is in complete contradiction with the stated desire to attract talent.
The right to vote as it stands excludes residents who do not have Luxembourg nationality. The reluctance of the coalition parties to extend the right to vote is completely at odds with their stated desire to attract talent. Talent that is prevented from getting involved in society. Closing the door to participation to them is inconsistent.
For you, therefore, citizen participation is both a decision-making tool for MPs and a tool for integration.
“Yes. The Chamber of Deputies does not reflect the make-up of society, it excludes young people and non-nationals. And when faced with major societal issues that will influence the lives of generations to come, it’s important to listen to everyone.
How can we ensure that this does not become a place where discussions are held without ever reaching a result, as is the case with public petitions that have so far never led to a concrete draft or proposed law?
“It would be simplistic to think that petitions are never acted upon. It’s a useful and interesting tool, because it allows us to follow up on certain issues. That’s what happened with the recent examination of two petitions concerning LGBTQ+ rights.
You have to give people a voice without causing frustration. It’s a tricky thing.
Follow-up is something that’s important to me. And one of the things I learned from this morning’s debate is that if we want people to have confidence in our political system and not get frustrated by their involvement, the objective of citizen participation must be clear. We must not promise that everything that is said will be put in place. Proposals will be taken, will be studied and, as far as possible, will be implemented. And if this is not possible, we will have to explain why. We need to give people a voice without creating frustration. That’s a tricky thing. We also need to provide a good framework for the process, first of all administratively, and also provide access to experts so that discussions don’t start from scratch. People need to be supervised in the best possible way.
What follow-up do you expect from this morning’s discussion?
“For me and for déi Gréng, this is a central issue that should not be limited to a single party. It’s a cross-party issue that Parliament must take up. Given that the government does not wish to move in this direction, the Chamber of Deputies must take the initiative to encourage citizen participation. This is no longer the time for conceptual discussions, we need to make clear choices and come up with a draft law to transform the various experiments into sustainable tools.”



