Luxembourg “will continue its efforts to further strengthen the effectiveness of its institutions and the quality of its legal framework,” said Justice Minister Elisabeth Margue in a statement issued by the justice ministry. Photo: Paperjam archives

Luxembourg “will continue its efforts to further strengthen the effectiveness of its institutions and the quality of its legal framework,” said Justice Minister Elisabeth Margue in a statement issued by the justice ministry. Photo: Paperjam archives

Luxembourg's courts are widely seen as independent, but EU figures point to slower case processing, particularly in administrative justice. The European Commission has urged further progress on digital proceedings and access to official documents. A new transparency law has since been passed, although Brussels will assess how it works in practice only in 2027.

Justice Minister Elisabeth Margue presented Luxembourg's progress on digital justice, judicial recruitment and access to official documents to her EU counterparts in Brussels on Thursday, 19 November. “Luxembourg remains fully committed to implementing the recommendations set out in the Rule of Law Report and will continue its efforts to further strengthen the effectiveness of its institutions and the quality of its legal framework,” she said in a statement issued by the justice ministry after the meeting.

A European Commission report published on 17 July had recorded very high perceived judicial independence, but made two formal recommendations: develop digital proceedings further and complete the reform of access to official documents. Its court statistics revealed particular pressure on administrative justice.

Administrative courts under pressure

The estimated time needed to resolve an administrative case at first instance rose from 479 days in 2023 to 720 in 2024, according to the EU Justice Scoreboard figures cited in the report. The clearance rate, comparing resolved cases with incoming cases, fell from 98% to 60%.

These “disposition times” are estimates derived from caseloads, not the actual duration of every completed case. The equivalent first-instance figure for contested civil and commercial cases also rose, from 221 to 251 days.

The Commission offered a qualification: “Consequently, the backlog has increased slightly, but it remains among the lowest in the EU.” It continued to describe Luxembourg's justice system as generally efficient. More than six in ten administrative cases concerned migration or asylum; a specialist tribunal intended to address the caseload was still a proposal in July.

The judiciary nevertheless enjoyed strong public and business confidence. In 2026, 78% of the population and 75% of companies rated judicial independence fairly or very good. Separately, 79% of companies said they were confident their investments were protected by law and courts, down from 89% in 2025. These surveys capture perceptions, not a direct measure of judicial performance.

Staffing and digital courts

The report acknowledged increased recruitment of magistrates — 42 by the end of 2025, compared with 28 a year earlier — while noting continuing difficulties in filling vacancies, particularly at the Court of Appeal.

The Commission recognised the management committee set up in December 2025 to coordinate judicial digitalisation, alongside work on electronic case files. But fragmented IT systems, limited technical staff and implementation delays still restricted access to digital filing and case tracking. It called for further efforts across civil, criminal and administrative proceedings.

In its 19 November communiqué, the justice ministry said Margue had highlighted the deployment of new digital tools in judicial and administrative courts, alongside work on the responsible use of artificial intelligence. The ministry provided no figures showing whether these initiatives had improved court-processing times.

A transparency law, but no EU verdict

The law of 24 July 2026 expressly recognised professional journalists' access to administrative documents held by public bodies. It broadened the definition of a document, required authorities to help applicants identify records and introduced acknowledgements specifying estimated processing times, along with safeguards for challenging refusals.

Limits remained — journalists received no general right to priority handling, and ordinary statutory deadlines were not generally shortened. Authorities also retained discretion over releasing unprotected passages from partly exempt documents, despite criticism from the Council of State during the legislative process.

The Commission has not declared its recommendation fulfilled. In a separate written reply to Paperjam, a Commission spokesperson said: “The assessment of whether the challenges identified in the 2026 Rule of Law Report have been fully addressed will be made in the context of the preparation of the 2027 Rule of Law Report, including how the new framework operates in practice.”

Media oversight and corruption risks

The report also examined plans to replace audiovisual regulator ALIA with a broader independent media authority. ALIA welcomed the expanded remit but raised concerns about governance and whether staff and funding would suffice. The proposed reform would also strengthen recognition of the Press Council's self-regulatory role. The Commission described public broadcaster Radio 100,7 as operating independently and recorded concerns raised by stakeholders about lawsuits designed to discourage public participation.

Luxembourg was among countries with comparatively low perceived corruption, but a national assessment of risks had begun in January 2026. “Public procurement remains a high-risk area, which is covered by the national evaluation of corruption risks,” the Commission said. A survey found that 31% of Luxembourg companies believed corruption had prevented them from winning a public tender in the preceding three years — a perception, not proof of misconduct in 31% of tenders.

The report also recorded changes to parliament's transparency register and stronger oversight of public funds allocated to political groups and independent MPs. It described civic space as open, while noting that proposals to strengthen the independence of the Consultative Commission for Human Rights were still under discussion in July.

At Thursday's dialogue, Margue also highlighted youth protection reform, corruption prevention and work on implementing European Court of Human Rights judgments. The ministry provided no updated court-processing figures, leaving the effect of newer measures on the deterioration in the Commission's underlying 2024 data unestablished.