Capping the high-earners’ index could also slow down future increases in the minimum wage, according to the CSL. (Photo: Shutterstock)

Capping the high-earners’ index could also slow down future increases in the minimum wage, according to the CSL. (Photo: Shutterstock)

According to the CSL, simply maintaining the indexation of lower wages would not be enough to protect them from the effects of a cap. Such a cap could hinder future increases in the minimum wage. The organisation therefore disputes the ‘social’ nature of capping the index for higher incomes, a topic that is currently in vogue.

Capping the index for high earners to protect those on lower incomes: the idea may seem fair. It is even very much in keeping with the spirit of the times. In its study ‘Index – Why change a system that works for everyone?’, published in November 2026, the Chamber of Employees (CSL) sets out to demonstrate that it could, however, also penalise the lowest-paid workers.

His argument is based on a mechanism that is not readily apparent. The minimum social wage (SSM) rises in line with index brackets, which offset price rises. However, it is also reviewed every two years with a view to adjusting it in line with general wage trends.

To decide on this further increase in the minimum wage, we look at how wages have changed across the country, excluding the lowest and highest earnings – in this case, the lowest 20% and the highest 5% of earnings. If indexation is capped for some employees, their wages rise more slowly, unless they receive other increases to compensate. This lowers the average used in the calculation and may therefore reduce the next increase in the minimum wage.

Protected today, penalised tomorrow

At the very least, an employee could therefore continue to receive their 2.5% increments, whilst also receiving a smaller additional increase at the next SSM review.

To illustrate this effect, the CSL carried out a simulation based on 2022 wages. Employees earning up to twice the minimum wage would see a 2.5% increase across their entire pay. Those earning more would receive the same increase in euros as someone paid exactly twice the minimum wage. Their pay rise would therefore be less than 2.5%.

If no other increase were to offset this difference, the average wage used to calculate increases to the minimum wage would rise by just 2.04%, compared with 2.5% under full indexation. According to the CSL, this would reduce the additional increase that minimum-wage earners might subsequently receive. Their wages would not fall, but they would rise by a smaller amount at the next adjustment.

Challenging the promise of a more socially-minded index

The CSL’s political argument is clear: capping pay rises for the highest earners does not automatically improve the lot of others. The savings made would remain with the companies, with no provision for redistribution to employees below the threshold. These employees would gain nothing directly and could face a negative impact on future increases to the minimum wage.

The institution thus advocates maintaining full indexation. To reduce inequalities, it favours pay rises at the lower end of the pay scale, through the minimum wage and collective agreements. Its reasoning aims to counter the argument that a cap is presented as a social measure: a measure intended to protect low earners could ultimately hinder their progress.

When approached by Paperjam regarding this analysis and its implications for the minimum wage, the Ministry of Labour had not yet responded to our questions at the time of publication.