(This article is based on an interview with Finance Minister Gilles Roth, discussions with market participants in our January Extra supplement and statements from both sides at Aca Insurance Day.)
The issue of relaxing professional secrecy in insurance is no longer a doctrinal debate. It has become a concrete competitiveness issue for a sector that increasingly relies on cloud infrastructures, massive data processing and transnational organisations. All the executives interviewed agree on one point: the current framework, forged in the 1990s, is no longer appropriate. Marc Lauer, Chairman of the Board of Directors of Foyer, sums up this discrepancy by pointing out that "we have a problem with professional secrecy, which was designed in the 1990s and no longer really works in a digital world". This now obsolete framework is weighing on the ability of Luxembourg insurers to keep pace with their European competitors, particularly in Ireland.
The impact first materialises in basic IT. "Most accounting tools are now telling us that they are moving to the cloud. We tell them that we don't have the right to do that, because it contains customer data", explains Marc Lauer. The systematic switch to cloud-only solutions, expected by 2026, creates a legal impasse: "In September-October 2026, this will be a reality: we will no longer have a solution if nothing changes between now and then."
At Axa Luxembourg, Octavie Dexant describes a daily operational brake. Professional secrecy, she says, "poses difficulties on a daily basis". The framework requires data processing to be kept to a minimum, despite the fact that the insurance business model is based precisely on the use of data. The stacking up with the RGPD reinforces the constraint. "When we want to digitise what interests the customer (...) we are faced with a large number of suppliers who tell us: 'Now it's the cloud.' And we reply: 'We can't', because we don't have the right." The major lock remains the encryption key: "Professional secrecy dictates that it shouldn't be on a cloud if the encryption key isn't with us."
An exception that costs a lot
Some developments in the software market are adding to the tension. "Microsoft will be 'cloud only' (...) With the current legal framework for the cloud, that means that none of us will be able to use them. At AXA, everything would be impossible for us. Beyond IT, the very organisation of international groups is being disrupted: "I don't have the right, for example, to communicate the names of clients (...) to my group. I don't report, I don't give out names. As a result, synergies, the fight against money laundering and a global view of risk are fragmented. Even the infrastructure has to be isolated: "We have Group Operations which (...) covers entities all over the world, except Luxembourg." The cost of this local exception is high: "It costs us two arms (...) for a single tool."
The stakes now go beyond mere technical compliance. "I think this is an issue that could cause us to miss the train a little compared to other markets," warns Octavie Dexant, estimating that the status quo would sooner or later push some international players to redeploy elsewhere.
At sector level, Christian Strasser, CEO of Lalux, confirms that the problem is shared and that it is mobilising the ACA: "We have (...) joint working groups - such as on the issue of professional secrecy. (...) We know there's a problem to be solved, so we set up a working group. The subject goes beyond individual interests: it is the whole place that is looking for a solution.
A structural handicap
The Aca Insurance Day amplified this signal. On stage, Marc Lauer reminded the audience that "in Luxembourg, we still have rules that date back to the last century. We regulate the use of data as if we were still in the era of horses and carriages, whereas our ambition is to go to the moon." In his view, professional secrecy is tantamount to building "additional castles and walls" around data, at a time when technology demands responsiveness and agility. Authorisation cycles that are too long are, in his view, becoming untenable.
Technology players share this diagnosis. Still in the same context, Christian Rola (Liberty Mutual) describes AI paralysed by the inaccessibility of data that is nonetheless essential: "As soon as we build an AI model, we come up against data that needs to be protected and that becomes inaccessible. It's a real stumbling block."
Filipe Pais (LuxProvide) confirms that "data confidentiality rules and professional secrecy block many use cases", forcing recourse to expensive or less effective alternative solutions.
In international non-life insurance, Julie Dubuisson, CEO of Convex Europe, even talks of a structural handicap: "Today, it's a real problem and a real competitive challenge." Professional secrecy in Luxembourg "doesn't exist anywhere else", she says. It disrupts commercial relations with foreign partners and can lead to the loss of deals when clauses added by a Luxembourg player are perceived as unnecessarily complex. She calls for "requirements to evolve downwards".
In the life sector, the main obstacle remains the impossibility of outsourcing certain functions: "Individual data (...) cannot leave Luxembourg", points out Alexandre Draznieks (Cardif Lux Vie). This prevents European groups from pooling their operations and benefiting from synergies: "We're a bit stuck (...) in a European movement where we're used to grouping certain functions."
An overture from the government
Faced with this accumulation of signals, the government recognises the need to act. Finance Minister Gilles Roth confirms that the country is moving towards an adjustment: "We are about to work on a pragmatic approach to insurance secrecy that protects the insured, but gives more flexibility to the insurer itself. But nothing has been finalised yet. As for the timetable, he is cautious: "To be on the safe side, I'd say within the next few months. The aim is to enable insurers "to sell insurance products while maintaining a certain confidentiality (...) with regard to medical data".
In the shadow of public discussions, however, some observers are warning against relaxing the rules too much, not least because of the criminal nature of professional secrecy. A breach, even without any tangible harm, could render the insurer liable, which explains the cautious attitude of players towards the cloud or outsourcing. Others are concerned about the risk of excessive relocation: an overly permissive framework could encourage certain groups to keep Luxembourg as their sole commercial front, to the detriment of the substance that has historically been the strength of the Luxembourg financial centre. Finally, the cross-sector implications are far from neutral: opening the door for insurance could lead to similar demands from PFS and other professions handling sensitive data.
Luxembourg must now arbitrate between innovation, sovereignty, competitiveness and protection. The future of professional secrecy in insurance will undoubtedly go beyond legal techniques alone: it will say how the financial centre chooses to position itself in a world where data has become the main tool for performance and regulation.



