Since February 2022, the Ministry of Finance has granted more than 950 authorisations to unfreeze assets and issued more than 210 refusals in connection with the European sanctions against Russia. (Photo: Archives Paperjam)

Since February 2022, the Ministry of Finance has granted more than 950 authorisations to unfreeze assets and issued more than 210 refusals in connection with the European sanctions against Russia. (Photo: Archives Paperjam)

More than 1,300 requests to unfreeze assets, more than 950 authorisations and more than 210 refusals since February 2022: the enforcement of European sanctions is keeping the Ministry of Finance’s departments busy and giving rise to appeals. A court ruling overturning a refusal to unfreeze assets illustrates the disagreements over the possibilities for the return of frozen assets.

Freezing assets, reviewing exemptions, defending refusals in court: the implementation of European sanctions against Russia continues in the offices of the Ministry of Finance and in Luxembourg’s courts. Since February 2022, the Ministry has received more than 1,300 applications to unfreeze assets. It has granted more than 950 authorisations and issued more than 210 refusals, it says.

The other applications are either currently being processed, have been withdrawn by the applicants, or fall into another category. Furthermore, rejections may also lead to appeals, which entail additional work, as illustrated by judgement 49856 handed down by the Administrative Court on 30 October.

Assets frozen through a custodian

In this case, a Russian company, identified by Reporter as Gazprombank, was seeking the return of securities and funds on behalf of itself and its clients. These assets had been frozen because they were held through the National Settlement Depository (NSD), Russia’s central securities depository, at a Luxembourg-based institution, Clearstream in this instance. The NSD’s inclusion on the European sanctions list on 3 June 2022 had led to their freezing. At the time of the contested ministerial refusal, dated 26 September 2023, neither the applicant company nor its clients were themselves included on the list of persons and entities subject to the freezing regime invoked.

The dispute centred, in particular, on the interpretation of an exemption provided for in Article 6 of European Regulation 269/2014. This provision allows, subject to certain conditions, for the release of funds to fulfil an obligation entered into before the entity concerned was included on the sanctions list.

The Ministry took the view that a transfer of securities did not constitute a payment covered by this exemption. The court rejected this restrictive interpretation: the return of securities may also constitute a payment. It therefore quashed the Ministry’s refusal. The judgement does not call into question the sanctions against the NSD. It sets out the conditions under which its clients’ assets may be returned: the transaction must not benefit, directly or indirectly, any sanctioned person, and any commissions paid to the Russian custodian must remain frozen.

A cancellation does not mean the funds are released

As far as the Ministry of Finance is concerned, this ruling by the administrative court, whilst settling a point of law, does not bring the matter to a close. Far from it. “The annulment of a decision to refuse does not automatically lead to the release of the assets,” emphasises the Ministry, which states that it is analysing the judgement and its implications, without specifying whether it will appeal. The court did not, in fact, order the return of the assets itself. The case must be re-examined in the light of the court’s findings and the applicable European framework. In particular, the complainants’ situation must be assessed in relation to the sanctions framework, which has changed significantly over the past three years.

Initially spared by the EU, the Gazprom group has since been caught up in the sanctions. “Each application has its own specific circumstances, which mean a one-size-fits-all approach is not possible,” the Ministry emphasises. It also points out that exemptions must not be used as a pretext for circumventing the restrictive measures, which constitutes a criminal offence. This general reminder does not constitute an accusation against the applicant.

The total amount of funds frozen in Luxembourg in connection with the Russia/Ukraine sanctions regime stood at €5.115bn at the end of June 2026. The ministry declined to specify the amount of funds that had been unfrozen.