For Noémie Sadler, “we need to professionalise the position of chair of the CCHR, as it is currently a voluntary post.” Photo: Guy Wolff/Maison Moderne

For Noémie Sadler, “we need to professionalise the position of chair of the CCHR, as it is currently a voluntary post.” Photo: Guy Wolff/Maison Moderne

Recently criticised by ADR MP Tom Weidig and defended by prime minister Luc Frieden (CSV), the president of the Consultative Commission on Human Rights, Noémie Sadler, reminds us of the importance of professionalising the CCHR.

Ioanna Schimizzi: At the end of September, MP Tom Weidig (ADR) published a Facebook post in which he described you, among other things, as “an enemy of freedom of expression and democracy.” How did you react to this attack?

Noémie Sadler: I didn’t take it as a personal attack, I took it as an attack on the CCHR. He was reacting to something I said in an interview about the petition calling for LGBT issues to be ‘excluded from the education of minors.’

What exactly was Weidig criticising you for?

He said that we wanted to ban people from making petitions, from freedom of expression, when that was not the case. Everyone can express themselves within the limits of mutual respect for others. In our view, this petition risked violating certain fundamental rights, but everyone is entitled to their own opinion. Its message was contradictory, and freedom of expression is a two-way street.

How did you feel about MP Sam TansonSam Tanson (déi Gréng) taking up the subject as part of a parliamentary question?

It’s rare for the subject to become political and for us to be defended. We can see that the mechanisms of democracy to protect fundamental rights and institutions are working. Other politicians have come to our defence too, some of the opposition. We at the CCHR really appreciated this gesture.

Prime minister Luc FriedenLuc Frieden (CSV) responded by defending the CCHR and reminding us of the bill to link it to the Chamber of Deputies. What did you think of the content?

It was neither new nor revolutionary. More critical voices would say it could have gone further. The answer was what was needed, without going any further--at least it was reassuring.

So this raises the question of professionalising CCHR?

Yes, we’re hoping for a bill next year.

So you want to professionalise the position of president and have the CCHR attached to the Chamber of Deputies?

We are attached to the Ministry of State. We are a completely independent body, but being attached to the Chamber of Deputies would confirm our independence. The Ombudsman and Okaju [ombudsman for children and youths, editor’s note] are already attached to it, so it would bring the institutions into line. The position of president is currently a voluntary one--I’m a full-time lawyer. Professionalising it would allow us to obtain a budget to set up a salary.

You also recently published a press release on housing for beneficiaries of international protection (BPI).

We had learned that the Eich reception centre, run by the National Reception Office (Office national de l’accueil, ONA), was to close. Refugees who obtain the status are obliged to leave ONA structures within a specific timeframe, and risk becoming homeless because they are unable to find accommodation.

Should the system be reviewed?

Yes, because once refugee status has been granted, the BPI are left to their own devices. There are gaps in social support, mainly due to a lack of resources.

What can you do about this?

At CCHR, we have no power to take action. Our job is to sound the alarm and hopefully get things moving at a political level.

This article was written in French for the December 2024 issue of Paperjam magazine, published on 20 November. The content is produced exclusively for the magazine. It is published on the website as a contribution to the full Paperjam archive. Click here to subscribe to the magazine.

Is your company a member of the Paperjam Business Club? You can request a subscription in your name. Let us know via club@paperjam.lu