“By improving the attractiveness and returns on investment, it can encourage new establishments, stimulate investment by existing companies and broaden the tax base,” the UEL wrote, about the benefits of tax cuts. Photo: Shutterstock.

“By improving the attractiveness and returns on investment, it can encourage new establishments, stimulate investment by existing companies and broaden the tax base,” the UEL wrote, about the benefits of tax cuts. Photo: Shutterstock.

The employers' umbrella group says indexed wage costs must be paid regardless of profitability, while corporate income tax depends on taxable profits. The CSL's comparison of old rates with the 2025 tax base suggests a substantial advantage, but cannot measure what companies actually saved. The dispute comes as the government proposes another corporate-tax cut for 2027.

In a study published in November 2026, Luxembourg's Chamber of Employees (CSL) compared approximately €540m in wage-indexation costs for businesses in 2025 with a hypothetical €3.2bn corporate-tax advantage. The organisation argues that employers emphasise the expense of automatic pay rises while rarely drawing attention to the benefits of successive tax reductions.

“Compared with 2001, lower business taxes have substantially and consistently more than offset the costs of indexation, leaving an annual net gain of €2.6bn in 2025,” the CSL states in its report.

The Union des entreprises luxembourgeoises (UEL), the employers' umbrella organisation, challenges that comparison. “Indexation is a cost borne directly by all businesses, regardless of their profitability. Cuts in the corporate income tax rate, by contrast, initially reduce public revenue from a tax calculated on profits, while also generating additional tax revenue,” it told Paperjam in a written response on 18 November.

A company with no taxable profits may still have indexed wages to pay, but would receive no immediate saving from a lower tax rate on profits. The CSL's calculation takes an economy-wide view rather than measuring the gains and costs for individual businesses.

How the sum was calculated

The CSL uses rates of central corporate income tax, known as IRC, rather than the combined nominal corporate-tax rate. IRC stood at 30% between 1998 and 2001, fell to 22% in 2002 and reached 16% in 2025.

Applying the former 22% rate to the tax base selected for 2025 produces a hypothetical difference of €1.4bn compared with the current rate. Using 30% produces €3.2bn, from which the CSL deducts approximately €540m in indexation costs to arrive at its claimed €2.6bn net advantage.

Working backwards from the larger tax figure implies a taxable base of approximately €22.9bn. That is a reconstruction of the CSL's arithmetic, not an independently established administrative measure of taxable profits in 2025.

The study also gives a much larger indexation-cost estimate elsewhere: €1,138.3m. Asked by Paperjam to explain the discrepancy, CSL adviser Dylan Theis clarified that the smaller figure used in the tax comparison came to €544m more precisely. “Both figures include the increased spending from higher employer contributions caused by an indexation tranche; only the employers covered and the period concerned differ,” Theis wrote.

The €544m calculation excludes public administration, education, healthcare and social-work sectors. It measures costs attributed to businesses during 2025, following an indexation tranche that took effect in May. The €1,138.3m estimate covers a full year across all employers, including public employers.

The CSL acknowledges that the broader calculation may slightly overstate costs because national-accounts remuneration includes some payments that are not indexed. UEL, meanwhile, estimates that an indexation tranche costs businesses approximately €850m, although that figure cannot be treated as directly comparable with either CSL estimate without matching their coverage and time periods.

What tax receipts show

UEL argues that tax reductions may affect business activity as well as tax bills. “By improving the attractiveness and returns on investment, it can encourage new establishments, stimulate investment by existing companies and broaden the tax base,” the organisation wrote. It did not quantify the additional revenue that such effects might have generated.

UEL cites a decline in the combined nominal corporate-tax rate from 28.59% in 2010 to 23.87% in 2025. Unlike the CSL's central IRC figures, these rates include municipal business tax and the solidarity surcharge. Industrial federation Fedil declined to take a separate position, referring Paperjam's questions on taxation and indexation to UEL.

Official records show that collections from these three corporate-tax components rose from €2.11bn in 2010 to €5.60bn in 2025. The latter comprised €3.57bn in central corporate income tax, €1.76bn in municipal business tax and €268.7m in solidarity surcharge, according to the 2027 budget.

The increase in nominal receipts does not identify how much of the change resulted from tax-rate reductions over the intervening 15 years. For 2025, the budget attributes stronger-than-expected central corporate-tax receipts partly to higher advance payments, favourable economic conditions and financial-sector earnings. Financial and insurance activities accounted for 77% of IRC collections that year, which exceeded the original budget by €410m.

Another reduction planned

The government's draft 2027 budget proposes cutting the main central corporate income tax rate from 16% to 15%. UEL supports the further reduction, arguing that it would strengthen Luxembourg's international competitiveness and encourage investment.

The multiannual budget estimates that the measure would reduce revenue by €56m in 2027 and €70m annually by 2029 and 2030. Those forecasts exclude second-round economic effects and do not calculate what the old 22% or 30% rates would have raised in 2025.

Asked whether it could estimate what the former 22% and 30% corporate-tax rates would have raised in 2025, allowing for changes in business behaviour and taxable profits, the finance ministry told Paperjam that it did not have those figures. It referred the newspaper to the budget.

That budget estimates the revenue cost of the government's next proposed tax cut. But it provides no equivalent calculation establishing whether the reductions already made have outweighed employers' indexation costs by the €2.6bn claimed by the CSL.