Vincent Romiguière, head of HR operations, and Emmanuel Gabriel, talent attraction & acquisition lead at PwC Luxembourg. (Photo: PwC Luxembourg)

Vincent Romiguière, head of HR operations, and Emmanuel Gabriel, talent attraction & acquisition lead at PwC Luxembourg. (Photo: PwC Luxembourg)

Throughout the last two weeks of July, Paperjam is running a series on major changes in human resources. In this fourth instalment, Vincent Romiguière, head of HR operations, and Emmanuel Gabriel, talent attraction & acquisition lead at PwC Luxembourg, scrutinise the key HR indicators and explain how to use them without falling into the traps of misinterpretation.

1. Staff turnover rate

The staff turnover rate measures the proportion of employees who leave the company over a given period. It is much more than just a ratio; it serves as an indicator of workforce stability and an organisation’s ability to retain talent. When analysed by job role, length of service, hierarchical level or team, it also helps to identify the groups most at risk of leaving and to detect any organisational weaknesses.

“Within the Big Four, staff turnover rates may be higher than in other organisations, due to an operational structure and business model based on the regular renewal of talent, particularly at junior levels. It should be noted, however, that, as in other organisations, a rate of less than 5% is not considered healthy and that, above 20%, it becomes a challenge for the firm,” explain Vincent Romiguière, head of HR operations, and Emmanuel Gabriel, talent attraction & acquisition lead at PwC Luxembourg.

The advantages:

Easy to calculate and track over time, staff turnover provides a quick insight into workforce stability. It allows for comparisons between different teams, roles or business units, and often serves as an early warning sign when an unusual increase is observed. For HR managers, it serves above all as a starting point for conducting a more in-depth analysis of the reasons for staff leaving and the corrective measures to be considered.

Limitations:

However, the staff turnover rate alone does not allow us to draw definitive conclusions. A high turnover rate is not automatically a bad thing, just as a low turnover rate does not necessarily indicate organisational health. Its significance depends, in particular, on distinguishing between voluntary and involuntary departures, the profiles of those leaving, and the reasons behind these departures.

Experts at PwC Luxembourg therefore point out that staff turnover should be viewed as an indicator for further investigation rather than as a conclusion in itself. It is by cross-referencing it with qualitative data (drawn in particular from exit interviews or other HR KPIs) that it becomes a genuine decision-making tool.

But retaining staff is not enough. We must also ensure that the organisation remains sustainable on a day-to-day basis and that the teams can keep going in the long term.

2. Absenteeism rate

The absenteeism rate measures the proportion of scheduled working time not worked due to absences, whether these are due to illness, unforeseen absences or other reasons, depending on the scope defined. When interpreted correctly, it provides an insight into the actual availability of staff and serves as a valuable metric for assessing working conditions, the workload borne by staff and, more broadly, the working atmosphere within the organisation.

The advantages:

Easily accessible via HR tools, the absenteeism rate is a reliable indicator for monitoring changes in organisational health. Its main value lies in its ability to highlight early warning signs before they develop into more serious problems, such as disorganised teams, a rise in staff turnover or cases of burnout. PwC’s specialists point out that it directly links HR challenges to business continuity and operational performance.

Limitations:

Like most HR indicators, the absenteeism rate cannot be interpreted without taking its context into account. It is influenced by numerous external factors, such as outbreaks of disease, seasonality, reporting practices and the demographic structure of the workforce. An overall average can therefore mask very different situations depending on the job roles, sites or groups of people concerned. “It therefore requires a detailed, segmented analysis and must be interpreted without a blame-oriented approach, whilst also taking into account the opposite risk of presenteeism, which may remain hidden in the figures,” emphasise Vincent Romiguière and Emmanuel Gabriel.

Beyond physical presence, another question then becomes crucial: do staff still want to commit themselves fully to the collective project?

3. Staff engagement rate

The engagement rate measures the extent to which employees are committed to their work, their team and their organisation. Generally measured through internal surveys or feedback mechanisms, it provides a better understanding of how employees perceive their working environment, their management and the opportunities available to them. It therefore serves as a valuable barometer of the working atmosphere and an organisation’s ability to sustainably motivate its teams.

The advantages:

Unlike purely quantitative tools, the engagement rate adds a more qualitative dimension. It helps to identify drivers of motivation, gain a better understanding of the root causes of certain HR challenges, and inform managers’ thinking on the employee experience. When used over time, it also makes it possible to measure the impact of the measures put in place and to guide priorities in terms of management or talent development.

Limitations:

However, this barometer is based on individual perceptions and remains heavily influenced by the quality of the questionnaire, the level of participation and the context in which it is administered. A satisfactory average score may mask significant disparities between teams, job roles or areas of focus.

Vincent Romiguière and Emmanuel Gabriel emphasise a key point: an engagement survey is only meaningful if it leads to concrete action. Without feedback to staff or an improvement plan, such initiatives risk causing frustration and may even erode trust in the process.

When commitment is in place, another question arises: does the company really manage to retain, in the long term, the talent that is essential to its development?

4. Retention rate

The retention rate measures a company’s ability to retain, over the long term, employees whose skills, expertise or role are essential to its business. Unlike staff turnover, which looks at departures in general terms, this indicator focuses on strategic staff, the loss of whom could jeopardise business continuity, the transfer of knowledge or future growth prospects.

The advantages:

The main benefit of this metric is that it enables organisations to focus their efforts on their most critical talent. It helps to anticipate the risk of staff leaving, to guide development and succession planning, and to secure the key skills necessary for the organisation’s performance.

Limitations:

However, the retention rate is only meaningful if the company clearly defines the groups it considers to be strategic. Without transparent and agreed criteria, the data can be difficult to interpret and may give rise to a sense of unfairness amongst staff.

The respondents also believe that this indicator cannot be analysed in isolation. It must be viewed in the context of other data, such as engagement, internal mobility, performance and the quality of succession plans, in order to gain a more comprehensive picture of the company’s ability to retain its talent.

Retaining the right people is one thing. But you also need to be able to quickly attract the skills the organisation needs to support its growth and keep pace with changes in its business areas.

5. Recruitment time

The ‘time to hire’ measures the time elapsed between a candidate submitting their application and accepting the job offer. It serves as an indicator of the efficiency of the recruitment process, the responsiveness of the various stakeholders and, more broadly, the company’s attractiveness in an increasingly competitive labour market. When analysed by role, level of responsibility or geographical area, it also helps to identify the most challenging recruitment drives or the stages that are slowing down the process.

The advantages:

Easy to track and immediately actionable, ‘time to hire’ helps HR teams identify bottlenecks and measure the effectiveness of measures put in place to speed up recruitment. It also has strategic value, as it reflects a company’s ability to quickly fill the roles that are essential to its operations.

Limitations:

“Reducing recruitment lead times is not, however, an end in itself. An excessive focus on speed can be at the expense of the quality of the assessment, the candidate experience or the fit between the candidate’s profile and the company’s needs. Furthermore, timescales vary considerably depending on the role, the scarcity of the skills sought, or the seniority level of the positions. It must therefore be considered alongside indicators such as the quality of the hire or post-onboarding retention,” conclude Vincent Romiguière and Emmanuel Gabriel.