Guy Castegnaro is the founder and managing partner of Castegnaro Ius Laboris Luxembourg. (Photo: Matic Zorman/archives)

Guy Castegnaro is the founder and managing partner of Castegnaro Ius Laboris Luxembourg. (Photo: Matic Zorman/archives)

Throughout the last two weeks of July, Paperjam is running a series on major changes in human resources. To kick off this series, Guy Castegnaro, founder and managing partner of Castegnaro Ius Laboris Luxembourg, analyses the practical implications of the European directive on pay transparency and explains what will change for both employers and employees.

Could you remind us where the concept of pay transparency comes from and what its purpose is?

Guy CastegnaroGuy Castegnaro – “The European Pay Transparency Directive aims to ensure equal pay for women and men for the same work, or work of equal value. The principle is simple: you cannot challenge a pay gap that you cannot see. If an employee believes they are a victim of pay discrimination, they must be able to access objective information on pay levels and the criteria used by the employer. The aim is therefore to make pay gaps visible so that, where necessary, employees can assert their rights.

Luxembourg should have transposed this directive by 7 June, but has not yet done so. As with other European legislation, this delay leaves the country vulnerable to proceedings by the European Commission if transposition is further delayed.

However, the scale of the phenomenon in Luxembourg needs to be put into perspective. According to Eurostat, the pay gap stood at -0.9 per cent in 2023, in women’s favour. This figure needs to be qualified, particularly when taking part-time work into account, but Luxembourg remains the best-performing country in the European Union on this indicator.

Does the size of the company make a difference? Who is actually affected?

“In Luxembourg, companies with fewer than 100 employees will not be subject to the reporting requirements set out in the directive, unless the legislature decides to extend this obligation.

However, it is important not to confuse reporting with the implementation of the directive. Companies with fewer than 100 employees remain subject to all other obligations regarding pay transparency. The main difference lies in monitoring: without a reporting obligation, it will be more difficult for the authorities to detect any breaches.

In the event of a dispute, however, the size of the company is irrelevant. The judge will assess the facts and evidence presented by the parties to determine whether or not discrimination has taken place.

Each Member State may set its own penalties. Do we already know what penalties might be imposed in Luxembourg on companies that fail to comply with this directive?

“We do not yet know for certain, as the bill has not yet been tabled. However, the directive requires Member States to provide for effective, proportionate and dissuasive sanctions. In particular, we can expect the powers of the Inspectorate of Labour and Mines (ITM) to be strengthened, with administrative fines, as has already been done in other areas of labour law.

In addition to administrative sanctions, a company also faces civil liability. An employee who believes they have been the victim of discrimination may seek full compensation for their loss in court, whether this takes the form of back pay, compensation for non-pecuniary damage or the adjustment of their remuneration to bring it into line with the law.

The directive also allows Member States to exclude companies found to be in breach from public procurement contracts. For the companies concerned, this can be a particularly severe penalty. Finally, the reputational risk should not be overlooked. In a market such as Luxembourg, a conviction for pay discrimination can have a lasting impact on an employer’s reputation.

From the employees’ perspective, what new rights does this directive actually bring?

“We need to distinguish between two stages: before recruitment, and once the employee has taken up their post. Before recruitment, the main change is that the candidate must be informed of the proposed remuneration – or at least the salary range – before being hired. At the same time, the employer will no longer be able to ask the candidate about their current or previous salary in order to make an offer based on that information.

Once in post, the employee will be entitled to new rights to information. They will be able to find out the criteria used to determine pay and pay rises, and may request, in writing, details of their own pay level and the average pay levels – broken down by gender – for employees performing work of an identical nature or of equal value. The employer must respond within two months. Any salary confidentiality clauses that may be included in employment contracts will, for their part, be deemed null and void.

You said that money remains a taboo subject. Is this specific to Luxembourg, or is it the same in neighbouring countries?

“I think this is largely a European phenomenon. Unlike in the United States, where it is more natural to talk about one’s financial success, salary remains a very personal matter in Europe, and particularly in continental Europe. People rarely talk about how much they earn, and even less about what others earn. It is, above all, a cultural issue.

Do you expect a wave of legal disputes when all this comes into force? There will no doubt be salaries that are difficult to justify in some companies.

“That is a possibility. The reporting requirements and the new rights of access to information will give employees more information to help them identify and document any pay gaps.”

This is a relatively standard procedure under employment law. The employee must first present evidence suggesting that discrimination has taken place. Once this threshold has been met, the burden of proof is reversed: it is then up to the employer to demonstrate that the difference in pay is based on objective and non-discriminatory criteria.

It remains to be seen whether this will lead to an increase in legal disputes. Unlike psychological harassment, where the facts are often difficult to establish, disputes in this area will be based on objective data.

Does this mean the end of individual pay negotiations, or will experience and personal negotiation still play a part?

“No. The directive does not require identical salaries, but rather greater transparency regarding pay bands and the criteria on which they are based. Individual negotiations will continue, but they must take place within this framework. Experience, rare expertise and performance will remain legitimate criteria for differentiation. It is on the basis of these objective factors that pay negotiations will now be conducted.

What if someone feels they deserve more than the top end of their pay scale?

“In this case, the main issue is one of promotion. If an employee reaches the upper limit of their pay band and believes that their experience or performance warrants a higher salary, they will, in principle, need to move to a higher job grade, with a new pay band.

This is already how many organisations operate. In law firms, for example, each career level (junior associate, associate, senior associate or partner) corresponds to a salary band. If the objective criteria for promotion are met, the employee moves up a category and salary negotiations then take place within that new band.

The directive is based on gender inequality. But it also risks highlighting disparities between two men, for example between a long-serving employee and a new recruit. Does it go beyond its original objective?

“Legally speaking, no. The directive has a specific aim: to ensure equal pay for women and men.

In practice, however, its impact will be more far-reaching. Once the pay criteria have been published, the pay bands are known and certain data is available, other pay gaps will also become apparent, whether they involve two men, two women or employees in comparable roles.

These situations will not fall directly within the scope of the directive, but they will inevitably give rise to requests for clarification, negotiations and, in some cases, legal disputes based on other principles of employment law. In my view, this is one of the main side effects of this legislation.

However, companies will retain a certain degree of flexibility. The directive primarily regulates fixed remuneration. Discretionary bonuses will continue to serve as a means of differentiation, particularly when it comes to attracting or retaining certain types of talent.

As a practitioner, are there any aspects of the directive that you find unclear, or that could be improved?

“Yes, several. The first concerns the concept of ‘categories of workers’, which remains rather vague. Yet it is on this basis that pay bands will be defined. This issue is likely to form the basis of a significant proportion of future disputes.

The definition of remuneration also raises questions. Should only the basic salary be taken into account, or should share options, benefits in kind and discretionary bonuses also be included? The directive does not make this clear.

There is also a significant administrative burden for companies subject to the new reporting requirements, particularly those that only just exceed the threshold of 100 employees.

Finally, the directive does not really define what it means by a ‘reasonable’ pay range at the time of recruitment. A company could therefore publish a range so broad that it would lose much of its purpose. These, in my view, are the main areas of uncertainty. It will be up to the Luxembourg legislature to clarify some of these points during transposition in order to minimise difficulties in implementation.”