Nalin Patel (left), lead analyst, EMEA private capital, and Navina Rajan (right), senior analyst, EMEA private capital, share insights from a Pitchbook report published on 6 May 2024. Photo: Pitchbook, Montage: Maison Moderne

Nalin Patel (left), lead analyst, EMEA private capital, and Navina Rajan (right), senior analyst, EMEA private capital, share insights from a Pitchbook report published on 6 May 2024. Photo: Pitchbook, Montage: Maison Moderne

Pitchbook’s 3Q23 performance report displayed initial signs of pickup in the performance of private equity funds. However, the situation with the lagging venture capital industry continues to be difficult.

Data firm Pitchbook released on 6 May 2024 the aggregated performance of several private assets as of 3Q23.

Private equity: performance on a sustainable path?

The one-year horizon internal rate of return (IRR) for private equities (PE) rose to 10.4% in 3Q23, up from +6.5% in 2Q24 while 3-year, 5-year and 10-year horizon IRRs achieved a performance of 19%, 17% and 16%, respectively.

The one-year horizon performance has gradually improved since reaching a trough at -1.5 % in 4Q22. One must go back to 2009 to observe a string of negative returns with a trough at -26.9% in 1Q09. Nalin Patel, lead analyst, EMEA private capital at Pitchbook thinks that the “pickup in return could be sustained” as interest rate increases “paused.” It remains to be seen whether that pace can be maintained as Delano noted that the performance momentum on a quarter-on-quarter (QOQ) basis lost steam, with a preliminary performance at -0.4% for 4Q23 over 3Q23.

The sector has been hit by a “lack of liquidity across the PE landscape and sparse exits amid challenging market conditions,” noted Patel. Indeed, PEs are known to “heavily” rely on leverage when the “cost of borrowing was rising in major PE markets over the past few years.” These observations persisted until 4Q23 and are still prevalent today with few IPOs on the block.

Venture capital: rough markets, still

The one-year horizon internal rate of return (IRR) for venture capital (VC) continued its decline (-7.7%) in 3Q23, a slight improvement over 2Q23 (-8.2%) and the trough of -17.2% in 4Q22. However, the string of negative QOQ negative performance that started in 1Q22 continued in the preliminary QOQ performance in 4Q23 (-1.6%).

The 3-year, 5-year and 10-year horizon IRRs achieved a performance of 12.5%, 14.8% and 14.2%, respectively, all lower than the performance for PEs over same period.

Navina Rajan, senior analyst, EMEA private capital at Pitchbook, noted that the “exit market, which is of vital importance to fund returns, has continued to show little indication of recovery in Europe and North America.”  She observed that “valuations and counts continue to be muted YOY,” weighing on VCs, which she considers as “the weakest part of the ecosystem.”

VCs may not yet attractive enough

Rajan is optimistic as she thinks that 2023 may have seen the trough in valuation. However, she commented that the high interest rate environment has made other private market strategies “more favourable and the appetite for longer-duration, illiquid investments lower.”

To finish on a positive note, Rajan observed in 3Q23 greater signs of recovery in Europe over the US (-4.0% vs -10.3%), a development also observed in 2Q23.

This article was published for the Delano Finance newsletter, the weekly source for financial news in Luxembourg. Subscribe using this link.