Every summer, the school lists come out and, with them, the start of a headache for families. With the start of the new school year fast approaching, the supplies department at Auchan Cloche d'Or is always busy. "We've had two waves," explains one employee. "First in mid-July, with parents who wanted a bit of peace and quiet before the holidays, then now, with those who are making last-minute arrangements." Around him, the hesitant trolleys tell the same story: parents scanning the labels, list in hand, looking for the best compromise between price and quality. "We're looking for products that will last the year, but without breaking the bank," sums up a mother who has come with her daughter.
Because behind every ruler, notebook or glue stick, it is indeed families' budgets that are getting heavier. According to Statec, a teenager would already cost an average of €26.3 a month for school supplies in 2022, with more than 80% of this going on traditional supplies (excluding tablets). An estimate that is undoubtedly out of date today, with inflation, and which does not take into account additional expenses, such as canteen or school fees, which can be substantial depending on the school.
While Belgium has already resumed classes on 25 August and France on 1 September, the official start of the school year in Luxembourg is set for 15 September (with some exceptions, such as the Lycée Vauban, which reopened its doors last Thursday). This gives families a few extra days to wrap up their shopping and find out where the schoolbag will cost the least.
To see things more clearly, Paperjam put itself in the shoes of a parent faced with his or her back-to-school list. Fifteen basic supplies were collected on Friday 5 September in three of the country's leading hypermarkets: Auchan Cloche d'Or, Cactus Belle Étoile and E. Leclerc in Foetz.

The comparison was carried out in three major hypermarkets in the Grande Région: Auchan Cloche d'Or in Gasperich (Luxembourg City), Cactus Belle Étoile in Bertrange and E. Leclerc in the Foetz commercial zone (Mondercange). Screenshot: Maison Moderne
The methodology
The selection is based on precise criteria: same brands (Bic, Uhu, Maped, Clairefontaine, Pelikan) when available, standardised formats (96-page large-square notebook, 8.2g glue stick, box of 12 coloured pencils, etc.).).
As with any comparison, the exercise has its limits. From one shop to another, the references are not always identical. Some chains have different offers, while others did not have the exact product at the time of the survey. In these cases, we have used the closest alternative to ensure a consistent comparison.
The main differences found:
- Bic highlighters: Cactus only offered a pack of 8, compared to 5 elsewhere;
- Bic Kids coloured pencils: different range at Auchan compared to Cactus and Leclerc;
- Colle Uhu: 8 sticks at Cactus, 9 at Leclerc, 10 at Auchan;
- Staedtler 17cm scissors: not available at Leclerc, replaced by Maped 16cm;
- Pelikan erasers: only sold in packs of 2 at Auchan compared with 3 at Cactus and Leclerc;
- Clairefontaine duplicate copies: packs of 50 sheets at Cactus, compared with 100 elsewhere;
- Maped pencil sharpener: absent at Cactus, replaced by the nearest model.
A basket, three hypermarkets
At first glance, the receipts already reveal discrepancies. But don't be fooled by appearances: from one chain to another, the batches and formats are not identical. To ensure a fair comparison, we have reduced prices to the unit, even though in practice families will always pay for the whole set at the checkout. Example: a box of 12 pencils at €3.60 has been calculated as 30 centimes per pencil, so that it can be compared with a pack of 16 or a different brand.
Once the calculation is done, the trend is confirmed: Leclerc offers the cheapest basket. Auchan follows closely, while Cactus closes the gap. Some of the differences are just a few centimes, but others are significant: Clairefontaine notebooks, four-colour pens and highlighters, for example, are twice as expensive at Cactus than at its competitors.
Three strategies can be seen beyond prices. Cactus is clearly focusing on the top end of the market. Leclerc is focusing on value for money. As for Auchan, it stands out for the breadth of its offer, with almost 4,000 references in its supplies section.
Discount as a back-up, not a solution
If Leclerc is winning the battle with the superstores on pricing, can we do even better in the discount sector? Yes and no. At Lidl, there are no school supplies on the horizon: after several visits to the shelves, a sales assistant confirms that the chain does not sell this type of product. At both Aldi and Action, a few items occasionally appear in an "office" aisle, but without a logical assortment or regular restocking.
The fact remains that the prices on offer defy all competition: four highlighters for less than a euro, sixteen pencils for 69 centimes... These are all unbeatable deals for grabbing some basics, but insufficient to equip a student from head to toe.
Another way to save money is with private labels. Developed by each retailer (Auchan, Cora, Carrefour, Delhaize, Cactus, Colruyt, etc.), they are marketed under the shop's own label and offer an alternative to the big brands, often at much lower prices.
During our visit to Auchan Cloche d'Or, we compared our "classic" basket with a similar basket made up solely of Auchan brand products. As with the rest of the comparison, prices were calculated on a per-unit basis. For this exercise, only 10 of the 15 items on the initial list were selected. The result is clear: the basket is more than half as expensive as that made up of major brands.
What about quality? On certain items, the difference can be felt with materials that are sometimes less robust, but in terms of wallet, the difference is undeniable. This is an option to bear in mind before filling your trolley with only well-known references. At the start of the new school year, the best savings don't always lie in the choice of store... but sometimes simply in the choice of brand.
This article was originally published in French.









