According to the latest figures, Luxembourg has around 230 midwives. Photo: Shutterstock

According to the latest figures, Luxembourg has around 230 midwives. Photo: Shutterstock

Wage increases for hospital staff divide the healthcare professions. While the Association of Doctors and Dentists (AMMD) is denouncing a financial imbalance to the detriment of the health insurance system, midwives are taking up the cudgels to defend what they consider to be vital recognition.

A kerfuffle among white coats. In a press release, Luxembourg’s midwives association (Association luxembourgeoise des sages-femmes, ALSF) has expressed its “deep concern” after the position taken by the Association of Doctors and Dentists (AMMD), on 17 July, against the interim protocol agreement concluded between the unions and the Luxembourg Hospital Federation (FHL). At issue, say the doctors: “a linear increase in salaries, accompanied by retroactive bonuses, which represents a significant financial burden for hospitals--and therefore, indirectly, for health insurance.”

“These additional expenses,” warned the AMMD last week, “significantly worsen the ‘structural’ deficit of the CNS, without providing any tangible improvements for patients: neither better access to necessary examinations or treatments, nor a reduction in waiting times, particularly in emergency departments.”

“Not a privilege, a necessity”

Such arguments have offended the ALSF. “Calling into question the pay rises granted to hospital staff, which include midwives, is not only unjustified, but also detrimental to the smooth running of the healthcare system,” says the association of midwives, chaired since 2023 by Anna-Cristina Rings-Alborino.

“In a context marked by a growing shortage of staff, an increasingly heavy workload and constant pressure on staff, financial recognition for healthcare professions is not a privilege, but a necessity. Recognition of our role is an essential condition for guaranteeing the quality, safety and continuity of care,” continues the ALSF. “The measures set out in the memorandum of understanding [...] do not constitute excessive benefits,” says the association, but are “the fruit of responsible negotiations, aimed at maintaining the attractiveness and viability of the healthcare professions.”

“Confrontational logic”

Here is the unique point of rapprochement between the ALSF and the AMMD: “The current negotiations with the CNS are proving complicated for self-employed healthcare professionals,” writes the ALSF, which believes that “discussions on increasing the value of procedures performed by self-employed midwives are slow, opaque and unconstructive, and no significant progress has been made for some time. The current nomenclature is inadequate, and reform is more than necessary, not only for the midwives concerned, but above all for the women, newborn babies and families who benefit from this care. We too are regularly told that there is a lack of funding.”

However, continues the ALSF, “this should in no way be used as an argument against raising the salaries of hospital staff, which was just as urgent and necessary.” The midwives’ association regrets “a logic of confrontation between professions, when inter-professional solidarity should be at the heart of any reform of the healthcare system.”

Physiotherapists are also up in arms

This “solidarity,” however, is undermined by other statements from the Luxembourg Association of Physiotherapists (Association luxembourgeoise des kinésithérapeutes, ALK), whose president Patrick Obertin, in office since 2017, explained on RTL: “It’s absolutely not a question of jealousy towards nurses who receive a pay rise or towards those working in hospitals who see their salaries adjusted. Quite simply, if there’s no money, then there’s no money for anyone.”

For its part, the midwives’ association is calling on the ministry of health and social security “to take a position without delay, in order to clarify the situation and reassure the professionals concerned.”

This article was originally published in French.