Of all the measures announced in the Resilienzpak – energy price subsidies and targeted support for businesses and households – it is the economic tax credit, applicable from 1 June to 31 December 2026, after which it will be replaced by an indexation of the income tax scale in 2027, which will place the greatest strain on public finances. That is €190m out of the €432.5m announced. The temporary tax credit is technically an adjustment to the tax scale in all but name.
Why wasn’t the scale adjusted directly? For legal technical reasons. Such an adjustment generally falls within the scope of the Budget Act. This Act will be tabled in early autumn and will adjust the tax scale for 2027. The aim of this adjustment is to neutralise the phenomenon of ‘deadweight progression’. In other words: to prevent the 2.5% gross pay rise resulting from the index from being absorbed by an increase in the average tax rate, as the taxpayer moves into a higher tax bracket. This phenomenon particularly affects middle-class employees.
A shield that is too wide
If the director of the Idea Foundation, Vincent Hein, does not criticise the policy objective; he believes that the chosen mechanism will be unable to provide priority support to those households most vulnerable to soaring energy prices. In his view, this “costly” measure – the effects of which will not cease in 2027 – he believes it is “unlikely that the government will reverse the subsidy levels for the 2028 election year or subsequent years” – should have been better targeted.
Why? Because “the propensity to consume energy is significantly higher among households at the lower end of the income scale, given the proportion of fixed expenses (including energy), which makes them significantly more vulnerable to price rises”. In his view, the current temporary tax credit appears to ignore a major statistical reality: the lowest-income households spend nearly 60% of their income on these fixed costs, compared with just 33% for those on median incomes. Conclusion: despite their vulnerability, households at the bottom of the income scale will benefit less from the measure, both in relative and absolute terms, compared to the middle class. In concrete terms, the benefit for low-income households will barely reach €150, whilst households with a median income – i.e. €55,000 – will gain around €380.
Vincent Hein regrets that the negotiators did not opt for a more finely tuned scheme. In this case, a more progressive tax credit, with a cap (similar to the 2022–2023 energy tax credit), would probably have better met social protection objectives whilst safeguarding public finances. As it stands, the Resilienzpak appears more like a generalised support measure than a targeted shield for households facing energy poverty, he concludes.
Energy subsidies that lack discernment
For Frédéric Meys, an energy policy specialist at Idea, the capping of energy prices – 5 euro cents per litre of fuel through a 1% reduction in excise duty from 1 July to 31 December 2026, a subsidy on the price of electricity of 4 euro cents per kWh, a subsidy on the price of heating oil of 15 euro cents per litre and a subsidy on gas of 15 euro cents per cubic metre from 1 August to 31 December 2026 – sends the wrong signal regarding support for fossil fuels. A wrong signal costing €60m.
Whilst he welcomes the fact that electricity remains three times more heavily subsidised per unit of energy than fossil fuels for heating, and around eight times more than transport fuels, this blanket reduction in excise duties “without distinction” benefits “fuel tourism”. In other words, “a majority of the budgetary cost of the measure ‘leaks’ across borders, whilst subsidising large consumers more than small ones”. Secondly, the fall in excise duty revenue erodes the resources that fund support for the energy transition.
Is it worth the risk? For the economist, the cost-benefit ratio in terms of protecting purchasing power is unfavourable. “Aid that is almost entirely means-tested benefits everyone, including well-off households and, in the case of fuel, non-residents. More targeted measures – such as an energy voucher or energy tax credit reserved for low-income households, or adjustments to VAT on certain goods and services in line with the energy transition – might have achieved a comparable impact on vulnerable groups at a lower cost to the budget,” he believes. In his view, rather than near-universal support for energy prices, more targeted measures such as an energy voucher or energy tax credit reserved for low-income households, or adjustments to VAT could have achieved a comparable effect at a lower cost to the budget.



