The big Black Friday shopping extravaganza promises to draw crowds to the shops. Without, however, unanimous approval. (Photo: Shutterstock)

The big Black Friday shopping extravaganza promises to draw crowds to the shops. Without, however, unanimous approval. (Photo: Shutterstock)

A sales driver for a stressed retail sector or a consumerist aberration to be shunned at all costs? The editorial team is far from unanimous about Black Friday. Two of our journalists weigh up their arguments ahead of the 2025 event being held on 28 November.

Behind the clichés, a win-win date

FOR. - It's all a bit of a sham... Although it may seem like a great online celebration (last year in the United States, more consumers filled their shopping baskets behind a screen than by joining a queue at the checkout), Black Friday is actually a godsend for physical retail, especially in town centres, which we know has been losing momentum since the pandemic brought it to a halt and accelerated the adoption of new behaviours. It would be utter nonsense to denigrate one of the year's rare peaks in footfall. All the more so in such a tense economic climate. The figures are useful: in Luxembourg, 18.1% of residents are said to be "at risk of poverty" and almost one in seven employees is "working poor". For these households, access to a washing machine or a computer at a bargain price is not a whim or a compulsive purchase. It is quite simply a necessity.

For professionals, the fourth Friday in November (and everything that surrounds it) is also a management tool. Increasingly resorting to the Black Friday loss leader at the beginning of November, and no longer just on a single day (this is known as "Black Week", or even "Black November"), they are giving themselves the opportunity to smooth out autumn sales before Christmas, rather than betting their end-of-year sales on two or three weeks in December, give or take.

A counter-intuitive instrument at first sight, the appointment can even serve as an ally in the energy transition. The City of Luxembourg, for example, reimburses 50% of the purchase price of certain energy-saving appliances (up to 100 euros). When you add up the cash grants and rebates, replacing an old fridge that uses up a lot of electricity becomes a realistic project. So yes, the debate is there. So do the excesses. But in an open economy, surrounded by three countries that play the game shamelessly, Luxembourg has no interest in denying itself. Black Friday is not a panacea. It is a pragmatic lever that benefits everyone, retailers and consumers alike.

Behind the discounts, a model that is cracking

CONTRE. - Black Friday may be presented as a "win-win" moment, but the environmental impact tells a different story. This day creates a sudden influx of production, shipments and returns, all concentrated in a very short space of time. Nothing to do with controlling emissions or using resources wisely. The event is based on a logic of accelerated purchasing, which clearly runs counter to the objectives of sustainability declared everywhere else.

On the subject of bargains, enthusiasm quickly fades. The European Consumer Centre points out that many promotions are based on drip pricing, with charges added only at the time of payment. The "2 items left" or "7 people consulted this product" are more marketing reflexes than reality. And every year, fake sites appear a few days before Black Friday, with prices that are too attractive to be honest. Even the comparison platforms don't necessarily show all the offers or their ranking criteria. The result: the discount looks clear on the screen, but the consumer is already having to navigate between traps, filters and blurred areas to make sure it's a really good price.

Social issues are also part of the debate. On Friday 28 November, union action is being organised at La Cloche d'Or to protest against working conditions at a major fast fashion retailer. The date is not chosen at random: Black Friday concentrates the tensions of a model where the increase in workload does not necessarily translate into an improvement in the day-to-day lives of the teams. The contrast between the commercial intensity of the day and the reality experienced by those who make it possible is striking. This reveals another limitation of the event: behind the euphoria of the figures, the human issues remain under pressure.