Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022 has sent energy prices soaring. And it has probably also affected the interest rates banks charge businesses seeking loans, according to two economists at the European Central Bank. (Photo: Shutterstock)

Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022 has sent energy prices soaring. And it has probably also affected the interest rates banks charge businesses seeking loans, according to two economists at the European Central Bank. (Photo: Shutterstock)

The energy crisis has not only disrupted business costs; it has also changed the way banks assess their customers. A study by the European Central Bank, published on Monday, shows that companies most dependent on gas and electricity are now borrowing less, at higher interest rates and under stricter conditions. This change could bring about a lasting transformation in corporate financing.

Banks are no longer just looking at balance sheets. They are also starting to look at energy bills. When gas and electricity prices soared following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, most economists expected the hardest-hit businesses to turn en masse to their banks to cushion the blow. A rise in production costs generally requires more cash flow, and therefore more credit.

However, the study published by Niels Framroze Møller and Johannes Poeschl for the European Central Bank paints a very different picture. By analysing data on all loans granted to Danish manufacturing firms, cross-referenced with their detailed accounts and energy expenditure, the researchers show that the firms most dependent on energy actually saw their use of credit slow sharply from spring 2022 onwards. The value of this database lies in its ability to compare two similar firms, both financed by the same bank, but which differ only in their exposure to energy costs. The authors are thus able to isolate the effect of the energy shock from other economic factors.

The result is clear-cut. From the second quarter of 2022 onwards, credit growth for the most energy-intensive firms falls 8.75 percentage points short of that of comparable firms with lower energy exposure. When applied to the Danish manufacturing sector as a whole, this effect represents around €221m in loans that were not granted, equivalent to a reduction of approximately 5.5% in the outstanding loan balance that would have been observed had the energy shock not occurred.

The researchers then set out to understand what lay behind this decline.

First hypothesis: the banks have abruptly cut off the flow of credit. The figures show that this is not the case. Bank lending to the manufacturing sector has, on the whole, continued to grow since the start of the war. Financial institutions have not stopped financing businesses. However, they are now making a clearer distinction between businesses based on their vulnerability to energy prices.

A cautious approach to cash management

The second surprise is that the slowdown in lending stems primarily from the businesses themselves. Nearly three-quarters of the observed decline can be attributed to reduced use of existing credit facilities. The most energy-intensive businesses are no longer drawing as heavily on their financing facilities as they did before the crisis. They are postponing investments, delaying certain expenditure and seeking to preserve their cash flow in a climate where no one knows how high gas or electricity prices will rise. New loans account for only a small proportion of the overall decline in credit.

The study shows, however, that banks, too, have changed their behaviour. The most exposed firms are securing new loans on less favourable terms, with higher interest rates, shorter maturities and greater collateral requirements. Above all, the researchers demonstrate that this disparity persists even after controlling for the usual differences between firms: size, profitability, debt levels, productivity and the quality of the banking relationship. In other words, two firms with the same financial profile will no longer be treated in the same way if one is much more dependent on energy prices than the other.

A new risk premium has emerged

For the authors, this means that a new risk premium has emerged in lending policies. Until now, a bank has mainly charged for the risk of its customer defaulting. From now on, it is also beginning to charge for the risk that an energy shock could suddenly impair the customer’s ability to repay.

The reasoning is simple. A business for which energy accounts for a small proportion of its costs can absorb a rise in prices without jeopardising its business model. Conversely, when a significant proportion of costs depends on gas or electricity, a surge in prices can wipe out profit margins in a matter of weeks, undermine cash flow and increase the risk of default. Banks are now beginning to price in this risk.

The study also shows that not all businesses are reacting in the same way. Those companies considered to be the most financially sound before the crisis are cutting back most sharply on their use of credit, preferring to postpone their investments rather than take on debt in an environment that has become highly uncertain. Companies already deemed to be higher risk are continuing to borrow to a greater extent, but they are facing a more pronounced rise in the cost of their financing. The credit crunch is therefore the result of both a fall in demand from the most cautious companies and a tightening of the conditions imposed on the most vulnerable borrowers.

The researchers then tested their findings from various angles. The effect persists when they change the definition of energy intensity, when they alter the sample of firms, or when they take into account other factors likely to influence credit. It is even more pronounced for firms in the most energy-intensive categories, which reinforces their conclusion: it is indeed dependence on energy costs that explains the tightening of financing conditions.

Looking beyond the single episode in 2022, the ECB believes that this development could herald a more profound transformation of banking analysis. Energy is probably the first example of an external risk being directly factored into credit pricing. In future, the same logic could extend to geopolitical tensions, supply disruptions, critical raw materials or even climate risks. For businesses, the energy transition would then no longer be solely a matter of competitiveness or environmental obligations, but would also become a key factor in their access to finance.