Financial assistance intended to cover the costs of caring for a dependent person must not be used to artificially increase their rent. If a social housing provider has made this mistake, it must recalculate its figures and rectify the tenant’s situation.
The government makes this clear in its response to a parliamentary question from the MP Marc Goergen (Piraten). He asked him about the differences in how income is treated when calculating rents for affordable housing.
Ministers for Housing Claude Meisch, Health and Social Security
Martine Deprez, as well as the Family
Max Hahn do not allow each local authority or organisation to set its own criteria freely. “No, everyone is bound by the law,” they reply. Section 56 of the Act of 7 August 2023 on affordable housing provides that, in principle, the calculation of income takes into account all income falling within the scope of Section 10 of the Income Tax Act. To this are added the elements expressly provided for in the regulations applicable to housing.
The government’s response, however, draws a clear line regarding long-term care insurance. Its benefits ‘are not to be regarded as freely disposable income’. They serve a specific purpose: to fund or offset the support and care provided to a dependent person. The cash benefits provided for under Article 354 of the Social Security Code may, in particular, be paid where such services are provided, subject to certain conditions, by a carer.
No procedure is in place to rectify the situation
This clarification addresses concerns that these amounts might be added to a household’s resources, thereby leading to an increase in its affordable rent. The parliamentary question suggests that such practices may already have been observed, without, however, specifying how many households or which landlords might be affected. The government states that it wishes to prevent differences in treatment between tenants depending on the landlord or local authority. It cites training, circulars, direct discussions with sector stakeholders and structured dialogue as means of harmonising the application of the rules.
The response also sets out the procedure to follow when an error is discovered. The government points out that it does not itself act as a social housing provider. Responsibility for correcting the error therefore lies with the organisation that set the rent. As soon as a landlord identifies a calculation error, they must inform the tenant, recalculate the amount and adjust subsequent rent payments to account for any overcharge or, conversely, any undercharge. The three ministers thus confirm that a retrospective adjustment to the rent is possible.
This adjustment can therefore work both ways. A household to which care-related benefits have been wrongly charged may recover any excess amounts paid. However, the mechanism also allows the landlord to claim any under-charged amount following a calculation error.
The response does not establish a national monitoring procedure or a single point of contact responsible for identifying the cases in question. Nor does it specify the time period to which retroactive regularisation may apply. It does, however, require a common interpretation amongst landlords: a care-related benefit retains its intended purpose and cannot be treated as a resource that can be freely used to pay for accommodation.



