The European Commission is facilitating government action in response to the crisis, but its plan does not set any construction targets nor does it guarantee the creation of any additional housing. (Photo: Paperjam/archive)

The European Commission is facilitating government action in response to the crisis, but its plan does not set any construction targets nor does it guarantee the creation of any additional housing. (Photo: Paperjam/archive)

With its plan for affordable housing, the European Commission recognises that the market alone cannot guarantee the right to housing. But whilst it provides the authorities with the means to regulate the market and encourage construction, it overlooks the root causes of the crisis. A missed opportunity.

Housing has been elevated to a priority by the von der Leyen II Commission. For the first time, a commissioner has been specifically assigned to this issue: the Dane Dan Jørgensen, who also holds the combined energy portfolio. His roadmap is to “address the urgency of the affordable housing crisis in Europe”. His work has focused on regulating short-term lets and supporting local authorities.

After nearly two years of preparation, he has just presented his plan alongside the Commission’s vice-president, Teresa Ribera, a sign of the political importance of the issue; he has just presented his plan to promote access to affordable, sustainable and high-quality housing, with the aim of providing a common response within the European framework to the housing crisis.

Unveiled on 9 September, its proposal for an “affordable housing law” takes the form of a European regulation accompanied by a recommendation focusing on supply. The stated ambition is ambitious: to help member states and local authorities maintain affordable housing in areas where pressure on the housing market is greatest. However, the measure is far more cautious than its title suggests. Brussels is not creating a genuine European housing policy, but is primarily providing public authorities with a legal framework to take action without contravening the rules of the single market.

In practical terms – and this will be a first – national, regional or local authorities will be able to identify “areas experiencing housing stress” using a common methodology. To objectively measure this “local pressure”, the text refers to the ratio of house prices to incomes, how this ratio has changed over the last ten years, the state of supply and demand, and demographic trends. Once local pressure has been established, the authorities will be able to regulate certain practices that remove properties from the residential market: short-term lettings, second homes, properties that have been vacant for a long time, or purchases intended for use other than as a main residence.

Making towns and cities safer rather than regulating the market

The progress is essentially legal in nature. Several European cities have already attempted to limit the expansion of holiday rentals or the purchase of second homes. They have regularly come up against the Services Directive, the free movement of capital or legal challenges brought by property owners and platforms. This new regulation is intended to provide them with a clearer framework for action. A local authority wishing to take action will have to demonstrate the existence of local pressure, establish that the activity in question contributes significantly to the problem, and prove that a less restrictive solution would not achieve the same result.

For short-term lettings, the adverse effect must have been observed for at least three years. The measures must be targeted, proportionate, non-discriminatory, regularly reviewed and, in principle, limited to five years.

Brussels thus recognises that the protection of housing may justify restrictions on economic freedoms. Politically, this change is significant. However, the numerous conditions imposed could also discourage the least well-resourced local authorities. Gathering data, establishing a causal link and demonstrating the proportionality of a measure require administrative and legal capacities that not all local authorities possess.

The Commission is therefore safeguarding the right to take action, without obliging anyone to do so. A state or local authority that refuses to regulate holiday lettings, second homes or vacant properties will be free to continue taking no action.

A recommendation with no obligation as to the outcome

The second part of the proposal addresses the supply side. The Commission recommends that Member States draw up plans to speed up housing construction, make land available, simplify planning procedures and shorten authorisation times. It also encourages the renovation and conversion of existing buildings and the use of industrialised construction methods. These guidelines address a genuine problem, but they are not legally binding: no specific construction targets have been set, and no obligation to achieve specific results has been imposed on governments.

Nor does the proposal establish a European fund specifically earmarked for financing the large-scale construction of affordable housing. Member states are primarily encouraged to make better use of the funding already available and the opportunities offered by European rules on state aid.

The contrast is telling: the conditions that local authorities wishing to restrict certain uses must meet are set out in binding regulations, whilst measures designed to encourage further development are largely based on incentives.

The blind spots in the proposal

Above all, Brussels overlooks several structural drivers of the crisis. Land prices are not directly addressed, nor are the hoarding of building plots or the capture of capital gains on property. There is no common mechanism to tackle the concentration of property ownership in the hands of large investors. Rent levels are also excluded from the scheme. Putting accommodation previously used for tourist purposes back onto the market could increase the supply of rental accommodation, but there is no guarantee that these properties will become affordable for the households that need them.

The financialisation of housing remains another blind spot. The regulation focuses primarily on the use of properties, and much less on their ownership and the role of property funds or companies. It even explicitly seeks to safeguard legal certainty and the legitimate expectations of investors.

Luxembourg is largely unaffected

In a country such as Luxembourg, where the crisis stems as much from the cost of land, the slowness of procedures and the relative scarcity of social housing as it does from vacant properties or short-term lettings, the scope of the legislation is therefore likely to be limited. The future regulation could help local authorities to better justify certain interventions. However, it will not provide them with the land, the funding or the administrative capacity needed to produce affordable housing quickly.

The Commission is thus taking a political step by acknowledging that the market alone cannot guarantee the right to housing. However, it stops short of drawing all the necessary conclusions. It sets limits on restrictions, encourages construction and preserves national competences. It does not address the underlying issues of land prices, speculation, rent levels and insufficient public investment. Nor does it answer this key question: who will build the affordable housing that is lacking, on what land and with what resources?