Frontier workers, don't rush to your employer to ask for seconded employee status, there's a good chance he'll refuse. But the concept does exist and allows employees to work exclusively from their country of residence, while being affiliated to the social security system of their employer's country, in this case Luxembourg, for example.
When questioned by MP Sven Clement (Piratepartei) on the subject of "frontier workers working exclusively from France", the government points out in its parliamentary response published on Monday 5 January that secondment is not an automatic tool. It is, write the ministers for Labour,
Marc Spautz (CSV), Health and Social Security,
Martine Deprez (CSV), Finance,
Gilles Roth (CSV), and Foreign Affairs and Foreign Trade,
Xavier Bettel (DP), of "a derogation", as "a person must in principle be employed and affiliated to the social security system in the country in which they carry out their professional activity". And the principle is clear: employees are subject to the legislation "of the State in whose territory they carry out their professional activity".
For an employer to be able to second an employee to France while maintaining their affiliation in Luxembourg, several cumulative criteria must be met. The executive stresses that the company must "normally carry out its activities on Luxembourg territory", that the work must be carried out "on behalf of the seconding employer" and that the maximum duration is set at "two years". Above all, the government insists on a central point: "The person concerned must have been subject to Luxembourg law prior to the period of secondment." Failing that, the ministers point out, a French resident "cannot be seconded".
No figures revealed
The Centre commun de la sécurité sociale systematically checks these conditions. If it appears that the employee "was not covered by Luxembourg legislation prior to the secondment", the institution refuses the application and forwards the file to the French authorities so that they can proceed with the appropriate affiliation. The executive also states that the CCSS and Urssaf Lorraine work together to detect situations where an employee is "not affiliated in the right Member State". They do not, however, give any figures for the number of people affected by this derogation.
When irregularities are detected, the correction can be significant: the government mentions the possibility of "a disaffiliation (...) with retroactive effect" and, if necessary, "a new affiliation, also retroactive", in the State that is actually competent. This is a way of restoring consistency between the place of activity and the applicable scheme.
On the tax side, the ministers point out that "the current bilateral agreement already lays down the rules" between the two countries. The main issue therefore remains the strict application of the European rules on secondment, a system presented as circumscribed, temporary and intended for well-defined cases.



