"The reduction in the level of error is a positive development, but there are still too many irregularities in EU budget spending," said Tony Murphy, the Court's president. "This is due to persistent weaknesses in the supervisory and accountability structures. As the long-term EU budget post-2027 takes shape, policymakers must learn from our findings to ensure the sustainability and transparency of future EU budgets.
The European Court of Auditors welcomes a significant improvement in the management of EU finances, but warns that vigilance is still required. In its 2024 annual report, the Luxembourg-based institution validates the reliability of the accounts and the regularity of revenue, but gives an unfavourable opinion on expenditure and a "qualified" opinion on the Recovery and Resilience Facility, the heart of the post-Covid recovery plan.
While the estimated error rate falls to 3.6% from 5.6% a year earlier, it remains above the 2% materiality level that distinguishes isolated irregularities from systemic problems. The European auditors point to the same weaknesses as in previous years: errors concentrated in cohesion and agricultural policies, where the rules are the most complex and controls the most burdensome. Most of the discrepancies identified relate to ineligible costs, non-compliant public contracts or administrative failings in the Member States. The Court stresses that these errors are not the result of fraud, but of non-compliance with the EU's financial rules. However, nineteen cases have been referred to the European Anti-Fraud Office, six of which are under investigation, and seven to the European Public Prosecutor's Office.
The debt burden exceeds €30 billion
The situation of the recovery plan, financed by the common debt, illustrates the caution of the diagnosis. Of the 28 payments examined, six did not meet the criteria set. Some milestones and targets were poorly defined, making it difficult to assess performance. The Court recognises the specific nature of this instrument, which is based on the achievement of objectives rather than on the reimbursement of actual expenditure, but stresses the control limitations of a system that is still in its infancy. In 2024, the Facility accounted for almost €60 billion in payments, around a quarter of the Union's total expenditure.
Overall budget implementation remains under control, but tense. Payments will reach €247 billion in 2024, including €191 billion from the traditional budget. Outstanding commitments amount to 507 billion euros, a high volume that reflects the slow absorption of funds under the 2021-2027 framework. At the same time, the common debt resulting from the NextGenerationEU plan is increasing: it has already reached 578 billion euros and should exceed 900 billion in 2027. The projected interest burden over the period 2021-2027 now exceeds €30 billion, more than double the initial forecasts, due to the persistently high level of interest rates.
For the Court, these figures confirm a twofold reality: the European Union is making progress towards more rigorous management, but its finances are becoming more complex and more fragile as the debt takes hold. The auditors call on the Commission to improve the traceability of payments, enhance the quality of performance data and anticipate future debt costs. They also recommend simplifying the rules to reduce errors without weakening controls.
Luxembourg, the seat of the Court since 1977, is both an observer and a country concerned. The country has a stable management profile, with a low error rate and moderate absorption of European funds, but it shares the common difficulties of administrative implementation.
