In 2024, global warming exceeded the 1.5°C threshold for the first time. This does not mean that the Paris Agreement has officially failed: its target is measured over several decades. But the signal sent by the global thermometer leaves little room for interpretation. Global CO2 emissions emissions from fossil fuels are estimated to reach a record high of 38.1 billion tonnes in 2025. Without stronger climate policies, the planet is heading for warming of around 3.2°C by the end of the century, with an estimated range of between 2.2°C and 3.5°C. The carbon budget, which in 2015 still offered a 50% chance of limiting warming to 1.5°C, is almost exhausted.
This is the assessment made by Dirk Broeders and Francesco Paolo Mongelli in a working paper published by the European Central Bank on Tuesday. The conclusions are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the ECB’s position. Their assessment can be summed up in a single sentence: the Paris Agreement has changed the global trajectory, but not enough to meet the targets it set for itself.
Adopted on 12 December 2015, the agreement now commits 194 parties to a common goal: to keep the global temperature rise ‘well below 2°C’ and to continue efforts to limit it to 1.5°C. It also establishes a cycle of reviews of national commitments every five years, sets out a global adaptation goal and seeks to channel financial flows towards a low-carbon economy.
This framework is still in place. It has provided governments, businesses and investors with a common benchmark for their climate strategies, transition plans and risk assessments. More than 140 countries continue to have a carbon neutrality target. The authors regard this anchoring function as one of the key achievements of the Paris Agreement.
Inadequate targets and policies that have not been implemented
However, the agreement lacks a sufficiently binding mechanism to ensure that the commitments announced will actually be honoured. The first global stocktake, concluded at COP28 in 2023, found that national contributions remained inconsistent with a 1.5°C pathway. It also highlighted two distinct shortcomings: the announced targets are not ambitious enough, and the policies being implemented do not always even enable these targets to be met.
Global emissions have therefore not yet begun the decisive decline that was expected. However, their rate of growth has slowed significantly. It stands at around 0.3% per year over the last decade, compared with 1.9% between 2005 and 2014. In other words, the rate of increase is now less than a fifth of that observed during the previous decade.
This shift cannot be attributed solely to the Paris Agreement. It is also the result of national policies, innovation and the widespread adoption of clean technologies. However, the authors believe that international cooperation has altered the baseline trajectory: without Paris, the world would likely be in a more dangerous situation.
The cost of solar power has fallen by 90%
The most visible transformation has been in the electricity sector. Renewable energy sources accounted for around 30% of global electricity generation in 2025, compared with 23% ten years earlier. In the European Union, wind and solar power together generated more electricity than fossil fuels in 2025. More than 90% of new capacity installed in the EU between 2023 and 2025 came from renewable energy sources.
The cost of solar photovoltaic power, meanwhile, has fallen by nearly 90% since 2010. Battery storage, which was still marginal at the time of COP21, has grown significantly. According to estimates cited in the study, the roll-out of renewable energy between 2015 and 2025 is estimated to have prevented between 7 and 10 billion tonnes of CO2. This represents the equivalent of 20% to 30% of global emissions in a single year, spread over a decade.
However, these improvements do not offset the deterioration in physical indicators. The average concentration of CO2 in the atmosphere reached 422.8 parts per million in 2024. Sea levels are now rising by around 4.7 millimetres per year, more than twice the rate measured in the 1990s. The heat accumulated in the oceans set a new record in 2025, for the ninth consecutive year.
The economic cost is already becoming apparent in Europe. Extreme weather and climate events have caused losses of around €822bn in the European Union between 1980 and 2024, at 2024 prices. A quarter of this figure – more than €208bn – was incurred in the last four years of the period. Less than 20% of the cumulative losses were insured, according to the European Environment Agency. In terms of both population and land area, the losses recorded in Luxembourg are among the highest in Europe.
Non-linear damage, which is set to get worse and worse
For the authors, the main risk no longer lies solely in a gradual increase in damage. Climate change can trigger non-linear disruptions: the irreversible melting of ice sheets, the collapse of large ecosystems or the weakening of natural carbon sinks. Uncertainty therefore does not justify a wait-and-see approach. On the contrary, it reinforces the need to act before certain options disappear.
This approach also changes the economic calculus. An early and orderly transition acts as a form of insurance. Delayed action concentrates costs, necessitates more drastic adjustments and simultaneously increases physical, budgetary and financial risks. It may ultimately lead to a point where prevention becomes too costly or politically impossible, even before the geophysical threshold is crossed.
The necessary measures are largely well known. The study advocates a carbon price that is closer to its true cost to society. This is estimated at between $51 and $185 per tonne of CO2, whereas the average global carbon tax is only around $5. Any increase should, however, be accompanied by redistribution mechanisms to protect the most vulnerable households and countries.
The authors also recommend accelerating the roll-out of electricity grids, storage facilities and renewable energy sources, making better use of European private savings, developing blended finance schemes combining public and private capital, and phasing out the supply of fossil fuels. Carbon capture and storage technologies can complement emissions reductions, but they currently account for only around 0.1% of global greenhouse gas emissions.
What remains of Paris is therefore neither a set course nor an empty promise. The agreement set the direction, established a common language and helped to make certain industrial and financial solutions possible. It did not resolve the central problem: transforming voluntary commitments into national decisions that are sufficiently swift, predictable and sustainable.


