While players in the steel sector support the measures proposed by the European Commission, they also say they do not go far enough. (Photo: Shutterstock)

While players in the steel sector support the measures proposed by the European Commission, they also say they do not go far enough. (Photo: Shutterstock)

Faced with sluggish European demand and massive global overcapacity, the European Commission is proposing drastic quotas and increased customs duties on steel products. This plan could offer a strategic respite, but it comes up against structural economic tensions identified by Eurofer, notably on energy costs and the industrial slowdown.

The European Commission's proposal to counter global overcapacity in the steel industry comes at a critical time. The plan unveiled aims to limit duty-free imports to 18.3 million tonnes a year (-47% compared to the 2024 quotas), double the out-of-quota duty to 50% and introduce a "Melt and Pour" clause to prevent any circumvention. This would replace the safeguard measure, which expires in June 2026.

Market conditions show why such intervention is now being urged. According to Eurofer's Economic and Steel Market Outlook 2025-2026, third quarter report, apparent steel consumption in the EU is expected to contract slightly (-0.2%) in 2025, before a modest recovery in 2026 (+3.1%).

18,000 direct jobs were lost in 2024 in a sector that now accounts for just 300,000 jobs in the EU. European production has collapsed to less than 130 million tonnes in seven years (from 156 million), while consumption has fallen from 153 to 128 million tonnes.

Imports retain a historically high share, accounting for 25% of consumption in 2025, despite a recent fall in import volumes. Eurofer also points out that European steel production is suffering from a weakened industrial environment (SWIP, the production index for steel-using sectors, is down) and high uncertainty linked to US tariffs and international trade disruptions.

Persistent structural limitations

These figures confirm that, for players like ArcelorMittal, imported competition is undermining margins against a backdrop of stagnant demand. The European Steel Association (Eurofer) is calling for swift action, arguing that the Commission's Clean Industrial Deal, despite its funding ambitions, does not provide concrete solutions to the imbalances in world trade, the shortcomings of the CBAM or energy costs. In particular, Eurofer criticises the fact that electricity prices in the EU remain much higher than those in the United States or China, which weighs heavily on production costs.

In this context, the proposal for quotas and reinforced rights may seem justified. It is intended to limit the influx of low-priced products and to give European producers the space to maintain their investments, particularly in decarbonisation. However, a number of reservations need to be examined.

Firstly, structural demand in Europe is weak - as long as manufacturing and user sectors remain constrained, excess global capacity will redirect some of the flows elsewhere. Secondly, increased out-of-quota duties could trigger trade retaliation or be challenged at the WTO, despite the guarantees put forward by the Commission in its roadmap. Thirdly, the measure alone does not solve the problem of structural costs - energy, access to scrap, regulatory constraints - which, according to Eurofer, continue to undermine competitiveness. Finally, the 'Melt and Pour' effect may limit some circumvention, but complex supply chains and downstream processing offer potential vectors for diversion.

Necessary support in the face of weakened competitiveness

ArcelorMittal, in its half-yearly report 2025, confirmed that global overcapacity and competition from low-cost imports are seriously undermining European steel, demand for which remains weak. The Group supports the European Commission's proposal to reduce quotas, introduce the "Melt and Pour" rule and increase customs duties, which are considered necessary to re-establish a level playing field. However, it warns that these measures will need to be accompanied by increased energy and financial support to enable the sector to decarbonise and avoid further losses of competitiveness to producers outside the EU.

Speaking about the new tariff quota proposal, Aditya Mittal, CEO of ArcelorMittal, said: “On behalf of all the employees of ArcelorMittal in Europe, I am sincerely relieved by the proposals that have been announced today to support the European steel industry. I would like to thank the Commission and the member states for understanding the criticality of the situation and acting appropriately and decisively. The European steel industry and manufacturing more broadly can have a much stronger future now, and today marks a step in that direction.”

Geert Van Poelvoorde, CEO of ArcelorMittal Europe, added: “We are also awaiting an announcement from the Commission regarding the revised Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) by the end of this year. We hope that the trade proposal unveiled today is an indication that our concerns will be reflected in the further measures to be announced in line with the Steel and Metals Action Plan. There is still a considerable way to go, to have the level playing field that European steelmakers need to compete.”

All in all, the Commission's plan is consistent with the economic pressure being felt by groups such as ArcelorMittal and is based on objective signals that the European market is contracting. It has the merit of creating a stricter framework for protection, but it will not be enough on its own to restore sustainable competitiveness. Its effectiveness will largely depend on swift implementation, solid international negotiations, the EU's ability to manage structural costs and an improvement in domestic demand in the years ahead.