“Firms operating in capital-intensive sectors, often among the largest polluters, are more likely to respond to higher borrowing costs by delaying their switching time,” said Pablo Garcia Sanchez, in a Luxembourg Central Bank (BCL) working paper published on Thursday 11 July 2024. Photo: Shutterstock

“Firms operating in capital-intensive sectors, often among the largest polluters, are more likely to respond to higher borrowing costs by delaying their switching time,” said Pablo Garcia Sanchez, in a Luxembourg Central Bank (BCL) working paper published on Thursday 11 July 2024. Photo: Shutterstock

A study by Pablo Garcia Sanchez from the Luxembourg Central Bank reveals that higher borrowing costs for polluting firms may delay their transition to green technologies, challenging the effectiveness of sustainable investment.

Higher borrowing costs can have mixed effects on the transition to green practices, particularly in capital-intensive, polluting sectors, concluded a working paper by Pablo Garcia Sanchez from the Luxembourg Central Bank (BCL). Sanchez cited Bloomberg Intelligence, which projected that sustainable investment saw environmental, social and governance assets reach $30trn in 2022 and is expected to exceed $40trn by 2030.

According to Sanchez, the core principle of sustainable investment is straightforward: diverting funds from polluting firms (brown firms) to greener enterprises raises the borrowing costs for the brown firms, theoretically motivating them to adopt greener practices. This principle hinges on two conditions though--sustainable investors must successfully raise the cost of capital for brown firms and these firms must subsequently become greener.

Challenges to sustainable investment

However, recent empirical findings challenge the effectiveness of this approach, indicating that the most polluting firms tend to become even more polluting in response to higher capital costs. Empirical evidence supports the first condition, with sustainable investors indeed increasing capital costs for brown firms. Additionally, these firms are often forced to deleverage when their lenders commit to decarbonising their portfolios, suggesting limited options for alternative capital sources. However, the second condition appears more problematic. Evidence suggests that the most polluting firms tend to increase their polluting activities in response to higher borrowing costs, potentially undermining the goals of sustainable investing.

Sanchez formalised these empirical findings through a stylised model. This model examines how brown firms decide the optimal time to transition from old, polluting technologies to new, clean alternatives. The results revealed non-monotonic effects of raising capital costs on the optimal switching times for these firms.

Optimal investment strategy

Sanchez’s model provides further insights into this phenomenon by considering the optimal investment strategy of a polluting firm aiming to become sustainable. The model breaks down the transition decision into two components: a running term representing the ongoing cost of accumulating green capital and a terminal term representing the cost of fully abandoning polluting methods. For instance, in concrete manufacturing, the terminal term could reflect the costs of switching from traditional portland cement to eco-friendly alternatives, including labour productivity losses and stranded assets. Prior investments in low-carbon technology could reduce these costs.

Competing effects on transition timing

The model identified two competing effects of higher capital costs on the optimal switching time. On one hand, higher costs increase running expenses, encouraging earlier adoption of green measures. This aligns with the strategy of sustainable investors who increase the cost of capital for brown firms while reducing it for green firms, theoretically motivating brown firms to improve their environmental impact. On the other hand, higher borrowing costs slow the pace of green capital accumulation, potentially delaying the transition to environmentally sustainable methods. This is consistent with basic corporate finance principles, where firms facing higher borrowing costs might prioritise short-term profits from polluting methods over long-term investments in green alternatives, argued Sanchez.

Sector-specific responses

The study’s results indicated that the effects of higher capital costs on switching times are influenced by firm characteristics. For example, firms in capital-intensive sectors, which require significant investments to replace brown machinery and infrastructure, are more likely to delay their transition in response to higher borrowing costs. Conversely, firms that are nearly ready to switch to cleaner methods might accelerate their transition when faced with higher capital costs.

Sanchez’s research extended to consider the accumulation of abatement capital to offset environmental degradation, confirming that higher financing costs for brown firms might lead to prolonged reliance on polluting methods. The extended model also highlighted that firms in hard-to-abate sectors are particularly inclined to delay their green transition in response to increased borrowing costs.

In conclusion, while sustainable investment aims to drive the green transition by raising capital costs for brown firms, the study by Sanchez underscores the complexity of this approach. The model indicates that higher borrowing costs might not always lead to greener practices and could, in some cases, delay the transition to sustainable methods. This nuanced understanding is crucial for policymakers and investors seeking to effectively promote environmental sustainability through financial mechanisms.