More than half of the cases referred to the Luxembourg Consumers’ Union relate to housing. However, the nature of these disputes has changed, with an increasing focus on tenancy and co-ownership. (Photo: Shutterstock)

More than half of the cases referred to the Luxembourg Consumers’ Union relate to housing. However, the nature of these disputes has changed, with an increasing focus on tenancy and co-ownership. (Photo: Shutterstock)

The ULC dealt with 2,717 cases relating to housing and construction in 2025. Court rulings paint a fuller picture: repeated expert assessments, interminable proceedings and compensation claims sometimes rejected despite proven defects. This is the story of the hidden side of everyday disputes.

Thirteen years later, the retaining works were still there. So was the dispute. But the company that had taken the matter to court had gone into administration. In the meantime, an expert had been appointed, hearings had been held, and then the case had faded into obscurity. In 2024, the court did not rule on whether the works were defective. It simply noted that the case had lapsed. And the case was closed.

This unresolved case is the extreme manifestation of a much more commonplace reality. Behind leaking walls, unfinished building works, disputed rents and misunderstood service charges, landlords and tenants are trying to work out who should take action – and who should pay. Reports from the Luxembourg Consumers’ Union (ULC) help to gauge the scale of the problem. The decisions of the 15th Commercial Division of the District Court illustrates what happens to some of these disputes when no solution is found.

In 2025, the ULC dealt with 1,038 cases relating to construction and 1,679 relating to housing. That is 2,717 cases out of 5,104 relating to housing, or 53.2% of the total caseload of its litigation and information department. This proportion is no coincidence. It stood at 54.3% in 2022, then 53.6% in both 2023 and 2024. For four consecutive years, more than one in two cases opened by the ULC concerned construction or housing.

Conflicts that are changing in nature

The volume is also rising. The association recorded 2,510 cases in these two sectors in 2022, compared with 2,717 three years later – an increase of 8.2%. However, the nature of the disputes is changing. Construction cases have fallen by 5%, whilst those classified as housing cases have risen by 18.5%.

The most marked change has been in the rental sector. Cases and disputes relating to tenancy agreements, terminations, rent setting and service charges rose from 792 cases in 2022 to 1,108 in 2025. This represents an increase of 39.9% over three years and 20.3% in the last year alone.

The ULC sees this request as arising from a rental market under severe pressure. Its members contact it in particular regarding the enforcement of tenancy agreements, rent increases and service charge statements. The reform, which came into force in August 2024, also introduced new rules on the written form of the tenancy agreement, the sharing of estate agent’s fees and the return of the tenancy deposit.

Condominium ownership is the other major area of growth. When general disputes are combined with those specifically relating to common-expense statements, the total number rises from 196 in 2022 to 305 in 2025. This represents an increase of 55.6%.

Conversely, the number of cases relating to estate agents, contracts and property sales has fallen from 343 to 172. They have halved over the past three years. The ULC attributes this decline to the fall in transactions and the slowdown in off-plan sales. However, the statistics do not allow us to conclude that practices have improved: fewer sales also mean fewer opportunities for conflict.

The slowdown in new-build construction has not put an end to problems relating to building works. The category covering construction, renovation and building defects comprised 400 cases in 2022, 431 in 2023, 380 in 2024 and a further 417 in 2025. This category alone accounted for 40.2% of construction-related claims in the last financial year.

Payment: the moment of truth

The ULC describes the same recurring difficulties: failure to comply with works contracts, delays in completion, unfinished work and poor workmanship affecting the newly constructed main structure. Detailed statistics also show an increase in cases relating to electrical installations – up from 60 to 115 since 2022 – roofing, from 48 to 80, and heating, from 98 to 134. However, these figures do not allow for a precise distinction between new builds, renovations and the maintenance of existing properties.

Decisions published by the 15th court records add another layer of depth to these figures. An analysis of judgements available since 2023 has identified 19 decisions in which substandard workmanship or non-compliant work plays a central role. This body of case law is separate from the ULC’s records: there is no evidence to suggest that the cases heard had previously been referred to the association.

The defects described are very specific: water seeping into walls, waterproofing faults, cracks in a shopping centre, paving subsiding around a house, faulty external joinery, façade issues, unfinished plumbing or heating installations, and substandard work on a retaining wall.

In 10 of the 19 rulings, the dispute arises or comes to a head when a company claims payment for work carried out. The client counters by citing poor workmanship, delays, the project not being completed, or the cost of rectifying the defects. This defence is not always sufficient. Clients are ordered to pay when invoices have not been contested in time, when defects are not sufficiently documented, or when their claim for compensation is declared inadmissible.

A court-appointed expert is involved in 13 of the 19 cases. Their role is to identify the defects, investigate their cause, apportion liability and quantify the damages. However, the expert’s report does not necessarily bring the dispute to a close. It may be followed by a new action on the merits, a challenge to the report’s conclusions, or a request for a supplementary expert report.

Disorder does not guarantee compensation

The median time between the service of the summons in the main proceedings and the decision is nearly 20 months in the dataset studied. This figure underestimates the actual duration of proceedings when several years of expert assessments preceded the main proceedings. In a case involving water ingress, the first legal proceedings date back to 2019, and an expert assessment was still ordered in 2024. In another case, the expert assessment was ordered in 2020, the report submitted in 2024 and the judgement handed down in January 2026.

Above all, merely establishing that damage has occurred does not guarantee compensation. In a case concerning an office complex, the owner claimed €2.51m, of which €614,250 was for restoration costs and €1.88m for late payment penalties. The claim was dismissed, despite the technical findings included in the case file, on the grounds that the legal conditions required to charge the sums claimed had not been established.

A company that owned a flat affected by damp sought to have the sale set aside and to recover €1.56m. Its claim was also dismissed. In a case concerning external joinery, the owner claimed 90,037 euros, but the court awarded her €19,553.53, in line with the expert’s valuation. Conversely, in a case involving a garden built over an underground car park, the contractor and his insurer were ordered to pay €336,703.

These rulings distinguish between three distinct concepts that a landlord or tenant might instinctively confuse: the physical existence of the damage, the technical liability of a party involved, and the right to compensation. One must also have sued the correct company, acted within the time limits, established the contractual link and proved that each sum claimed arises from the alleged breach. This is the other side of the Luxembourg property market. Beyond prices, sales figures and the number of homes built, there is what happens after the keys have been handed over: disputed service charges, contested rents, unfinished building works, leaking walls and the years it takes to determine who will have to pay.