Is it a good idea to link wage indexation to income? Answers with Vincent Hein, director of the Idea Foundation, and William Telkes, chief economist at Spuerkeess. (Photo: Romain Gamba/101 Studios; montage: Paperjam)

Is it a good idea to link wage indexation to income? Answers with Vincent Hein, director of the Idea Foundation, and William Telkes, chief economist at Spuerkeess. (Photo: Romain Gamba/101 Studios; montage: Paperjam)

A cornerstone of Luxembourg’s social model, automatic indexation aims to preserve purchasing power in the face of inflation. Universal in principle, it nevertheless raises a central question: does it really protect all households in the same way?

In Luxembourg, automatic wage indexation occupies a singular place in the economic debate. A vestige of an old social compromise, it continues to be presented as a bulwark against inflation and a factor of social stability. But this mechanism, often defended as inherently fair, raises a less consensual question: does indexation really benefit everyone equally?

The mechanism is simple in its operation. Each month, Statec monitors price trends for a representative basket of goods and services, weighted according to the real weight of each item in household spending (housing, transport and food weigh more heavily than education or culture, for example). When the cumulative increase exceeds a set threshold, an index band is triggered. Salaries and pensions then automatically increase by 2.5%.

The aim is clear: to offset observed inflation. “It’s about rebalancing real household wages. In principle, the aim is not to create a purchasing power surplus, but rather to preserve the level of purchasing power,” points out Spuerkeess chief economist William TelkesWilliam Telkes. The system is designed to ensure that all rightsholders benefit from the same proportional increase, regardless of income.

Equality in principle

But this equality of treatment does not mean equality of effect. Let’s take a simple example. A salary band of 2.5% represents around €87 gross per month for a salary of €3,500, compared with €250 for a salary of €10,000. In percentage terms, the effort is identical. In absolute terms, the impact is not.

This is precisely where the debate opens up. As Idea Foundation director Vincent HeinVincent Hein points out, the proportion of income devoted to consumption falls as income rises. “The bonus received through indexation will enable households with high incomes to increase their consumption or save more. Conversely, a fictitious household consuming 100% of its income according to the average shopping basket calculated by Statec would only be compensated for inflation and neither its purchasing power nor its ability to save would increase.”

The wealthier classes consume more in absolute terms, and a loss of their purchasing power could have consequences for the economy.
William Telkes

William Telkes, chief economist, Spuerkeess

In other words, the higher your income, the more your purchasing power is supported by indexation. The model thus appears horizontally egalitarian, but vertically asymmetric in its real economic effects.

“Indexation guarantees social peace”

Faced with this observation, the question of more targeted indexation according to income deserves to be asked. While, from a social point of view, such an approach would undeniably appear fairer, its economic implications are more complex.

“From the point of view of the economy as a whole, we would limit changes in the cost of labour, but companies that take on more employees on modest incomes are also often those for which the share of wages in the cost structure is the highest,” Vincent Hein analyses. “It would change little or nothing for them. We are thinking, for example, of the retail sector, the hotel and catering industry and certain construction trades.”

“We must not forget that the more affluent classes consume more in absolute terms, and a loss of their purchasing power could have consequences for the economy,” William Telkes continues. Before warning: “I’m never very much in favour of segmenting the population. Applying the same rules to everyone also contributes to social balance.”

The Statec also points out that the indexation mechanism is designed to be generalised, without targeting, but that corrective measures already exist via taxation and aid measures aimed at lower-income households.

For the Ministry of the Economy, maintaining the current system remains a priority. “Indexation guarantees social peace, a low strike rate, the stabilisation of real wages and the country’s attractiveness to foreign labour.” However, the government acknowledges that during periods of high inflation, the system can pose short-term challenges.

“In the event of runaway inflation, such as during the energy crisis of 2022–2023, the index brackets can follow each other in quick succession and create a significant pay gap vis-à-vis other countries competing with Luxembourg,” the statistics institute says. Hence the recourse to the tripartite to negotiate, if necessary, a temporary modulation of the mechanism.

In the short term, the economic effects would probably be limited: better margins for certain companies, a slight acceleration in recruitment.
Vincent Hein

Vincent Hein, director, Fondation Idea

Beyond the Luxembourg model

In this context, another way of operating is still possible. “Luxembourg could operate without automatic indexation,” Statec admits. This perspective is also confirmed by international comparisons. A study published in 2014 by the Observatoire de la Compétitivité, comparing Luxembourg and Belgium—which have an automatic indexation mechanism—with France and Germany, which do not, shows that in the long term, salaries end up following price trends in all cases. Even in the absence of institutionalised indexation, adjustments are then made via wage bargaining.

“In the short term, the economic effects would probably be limited: better margins for some companies, a slight acceleration in recruitment. On the other hand, the social and political risks would be very real in the absence of a clearly explained project,” the director of the Idea Foundation notes.

For its part, the government believes that the general development of the Luxembourg economy has not so far been hindered by automatic wage indexation. However, it says it will continue to keep a close eye on wage and price trends, and is ready to intervene if necessary to preserve the competitiveness of businesses and the purchasing power of households.