Nicolas Thieltgen, Managing Partner. (Photo: Brucher Thieltgen & Partners)

Nicolas Thieltgen, Managing Partner. (Photo: Brucher Thieltgen & Partners)

Between risks, internal expectations and group constraints, CLOs must rethink how they work with their lawyers, building relationships grounded in trust, agility and strategic empathy.

Why can relationships between Chief Legal Officers (CLOs) and external lawyers prove complex?

Because they are often more political than you might think. These relationships are not built in a theoretical vacuum, but in an ecosystem where the expectations of head office, constraints on the ground, compliance issues and internal governance dynamics intermingle. The CLO may find herself/himself having to call on a firm that she/he has not chosen, and whose processes and contacts she/he has no control over. And in Luxembourg, the context adds a further layer of complexity: many CLOs operate within structures that are part of international groups. As a result, they may have little room for manoeuvre when it comes to choosing and managing their relationship with lawyers. This can lead to a lack of fluidity and even a loss of trust.

Added to this are the classic misunderstandings: deadlines deemed too long, lack of transparency on invoicing, the feeling that the lawyer does not understand the current priorities. These are irritants that can be mitigated if the relationship is built from the outset on a clear foundation, with shared tools, well-defined expectations and a mutual willingness to adjust.

Complex but essential?

Yes, absolutely. In Luxembourg, legal departments are often relatively small in number. The CLO does not always have an in-house multidisciplinary team at his side. He therefore needs to be able to rely on external advice not only to deal with complex issues, but also to cope with peaks in activity, manage urgent situations or cover a constantly changing regulatory perimeter.

For lawyers, this relationship is not incidental. In fact, it is central to the firm’s sustainable development strategy. A client with whom a relationship of trust is established is a client who comes back, who consults in advance, and who calls on the lawyer not only as a legal technician, but also as a sparring partner in his decisions.

Is this a relationship that needs to be reinvented?

Yes, in many cases. Historically, the lawyer-client relationship has often been structured in a top-down, almost transactional way: a question asked, an answer drafted, a fee note sent. This model is now showing its limitations. The CLO expects his lawyer to know him, to anticipate his needs and to understand his internal constraints – including budgetary constraints.

This means moving away from a strictly reactive approach and building an alliance. This starts with regular exchanges, not just on the occasion of an issue or a crisis. It also involves better integration of the firm into the client’s legal processes, which requires time, method and mutual commitment.

What are the foundations of an effective partnership?

The main foundation is the quality of information flows. Simple follow-up meetings, even brief ones, help us to stay aligned. A clear, shared dashboard helps you to prioritise and see where you stand. Above all, you need to know who to talk to: too much friction arises because a request is sent to the wrong person, and then goes unanswered or is not dealt with within a reasonable time. It is therefore useful, from the outset, to identify the right points of contact on both sides: Who can give instructions? Who can be contacted in an emergency? Who is the right contact person for a request? This requires organisation and coordination, especially at the level of the lawyer and his teams.

What about emergency situations?

Urgency always reveals the quality of a relationship. An easily accessible hotline to an experienced lawyer can make all the difference. This could be a priority e-mail address or a messaging channel. The key is to ensure real availability. The CLO expects rapid responses, even provisional ones, and to feel that the team is mobilised.

The lawyer's independence must go hand in hand with a genuine understanding of the client. Lawyers do not advise, in absolute terms.

Nicolas Thieltgen, Managing Partner, Brucher Thieltgen & Partners

What specific tools do you recommend?

Secure extranets, Teams channels, Slack or other collaborative platforms. The important thing is not to multiply the tools. One, well used, is better than three partially adopted. And always with a clear framework in terms of confidentiality, RGPD compliance and traceability.

Should the relationship also include an exchange of knowledge?

Yes, in both directions. The CLO expects the lawyer to keep him proactively informed of regulatory developments, to alert him to legal trends, and even to offer targeted training for his in-house teams. But conversely, the CLO is on the front line. They pick up on small signals, changes in tone from the regulator and tensions in their sector. Sharing this with the lawyer enables him to adapt his analysis, better adjust his recommendations and focus his monitoring.

How do you combine the lawyer’s independence with this strategic proximity?

This is a key question. Independence is non-negotiable: it is one of the cornerstones of our professional ethics. In particular, it guarantees the CLO that she/he will get a clear-eyed, non-indulgent view, and that in the event of a crisis or internal tension, she/he will be able to rely on a reliable interlocutor.

But this independence must go hand in hand with a genuine understanding of the client. Lawyers do not advise in absolutes: they must take account of the realities on the ground, internal power struggles and economic timetables. Independence then becomes strategic support, not isolation. I refer to this as strategic empathy.

Strategic empathy?

Empathy here does not mean complacency or emotion. It’s about being able to adjust: understanding the pressure the CLO is under, his real room for manoeuvre, his operational constraints. Good legal advice is not just about formal or technical correctness. It has to be applicable, readable and respond to a concrete problem.

This may sometimes mean showing less of its doctrine (which it masters rather than expounds), and a little more pragmatism.

Conclusion: what is the ideal relationship between a CLO and a lawyer?

It’s a relationship based on trust, regular exchanges and mutual understanding. It’s not a delegation of tasks, but an active collaboration. When it’s well constructed, this relationship becomes a lever for legal performance, a factor for peace of mind, and even a strategic differentiator for the company.

It requires time, commitment and sometimes adjustment. But the return on investment is real, for both parties: in clarity, efficiency and legal robustness.

---

Brucher Thieltgen & Partners

Nicolas Thieltgen

nicolas.thieltgen@brucherlaw.lu.

+352 26 02 71.