OAI Director Pierre Hurt advocates for architects and consulting engineers to remain independent so they can defend their clients’ interests without pressure from their shareholders. (Photo: OAI)

OAI Director Pierre Hurt advocates for architects and consulting engineers to remain independent so they can defend their clients’ interests without pressure from their shareholders. (Photo: OAI)

Can an architect freely advise a client if a construction company owns a stake in their practice? This is the risk the Order of Architects and Consulting Engineers (OAI) is seeking to prevent. In an open letter to the Minister of the Economy and members of parliament, the OAI calls for stronger safeguards to ensure independence under Draft Bill No. 7932. Pierre Hurt, the organisation’s director, explains why this issue also matters to private individuals building their own homes.

You are warning about the risk of a loss of independence. Have clients in Luxembourg already suffered as a result?

Pierre Hurt:Pierre Hurt: “To date, we have no cases of clients being harmed that we can point to. However, since the OAI was established, we have had a framework in place that requires our members to remain independent. When a practice sets up in Luxembourg, we examine, among other things, who owns its share capital. Those responsible for the practice must also undertake to work independently and comply with the professional and ethical rules laid down by law.

The fact that no problems have been documented does not mean these safeguards are unnecessary. For a profession that serves the public interest, rules and effective means of enforcing them are essential. Without a regulatory framework, anything goes…

For someone building a house, what is at stake in practical terms?

“When a private individual hires an architect to design their home and oversee the construction work, they must be able to rely on a professional who defends their project and their interests. The architect designs the project with the site and the client’s needs in mind. They provide advice, propose solutions and monitor their implementation.

Building a home is one of the biggest investments a person will make in their lifetime. Clients need to know that the advice they receive is given in complete independence.
Pierre Hurt  

Pierre Hurt  , director, OAI

However, if the company whose work the architect is supposed to inspect owns a stake in the architect’s practice, this creates a conflict of interest. The same applies to a building materials supplier: the professional must be able to compare products freely, without being influenced by the party selling them. This is the kind of situation in which someone becomes both judge and party that we need to avoid.

You say you want to protect clients. But aren’t your demands also intended to protect existing practices from new competitors?

“Luxembourg is an open market in which many practices from neighbouring countries operate. We are not asking for the market to be closed, and it certainly is not closed today. Nor are we opposed to investors acquiring stakes in architectural practices. We are asking that a majority of the share capital remain in the hands of professionals who are authorised to practise and subject to professional ethical rules. Other investors could hold up to 49%, provided their involvement does not create a conflict of interest.

Employees of a practice or people working in other liberal professions could, for example, acquire shares. What we want to prevent at all costs is a situation in which a party acquires a stake in a practice to influence its decisions for the benefit of its own business activities. A company whose work the architect or engineer is required to inspect should not be allowed to become a shareholder in that professional’s practice.

What specific safeguards are you calling for?

“First, an absolute majority of the share capital must be held by professionals authorised to practise independently. Having a degree is not enough; they must also be subject to the obligations governing the profession.

Second, the other shareholders must themselves be entirely independent of business activities that could give rise to a conflict of interest. This requirement must also apply to those who manage or administer the company.

We are calling for sellers of construction materials and technical equipment to be explicitly listed among the activities deemed incompatible.
Pierre Hurt  

Pierre Hurt  , director, OAI

Finally, we are calling for sellers of building materials and technical equipment to be explicitly included among the activities deemed incompatible with ownership. The question is simple: how can you recommend a product freely if you also have a financial interest in selling it?

An architect may own their own practice yet depend on a single major property developer. In your view, isn’t their independence already fragile in that situation?

“We cannot prohibit a professional working in a liberal profession from having an important client, or even a single client. However, we must distinguish this commercial relationship from ownership of the practice. The practice must remain a separate entity, with its own management and staff. In particular, we check that the property developer does not own shares in it. The developer’s client is normally informed of the situation as well: transparency is essential.

We must also consider the scope of the architect’s assignment. In most property development projects, the architect’s involvement ends once planning permission has been obtained. They are therefore not responsible for supervising the construction work afterwards.

This raises another important issue: in Luxembourg, architects are not systematically commissioned to provide a full range of services. The situation differs from that of a private individual who entrusts an architect with both designing their home and supervising its construction. Economic dependence on a major client can exist, but that is no reason to abandon rules governing share ownership. On the contrary, a clear framework is needed.

Why do you think your proposals have not all been incorporated into the draft bill?

“One possible explanation, in my view, is the concern that imposing restrictions could lead to legal challenges at European level. However, we believe that specific rules are justified for professions that perform a public-interest function. We have, in particular, cited Belgium as an example, as it reformed its regulatory framework in 2024.

Our proposals leave the door open to investors while excluding those whose business activities could compromise a practice’s independence. To understand the precise reasons why certain amendments were not adopted, however, the ministry would need to be asked directly. (Smiles.)

Several other companies can sit behind a single corporate entity. How can you establish who actually owns a practice?

“You have to trace the entire chain of ownership. Looking only at the first shareholder is not enough; otherwise, it would be far too easy to circumvent the rules by inserting another company into the ownership structure. That is why the words ‘directly or indirectly’ are important. We must be able to verify who holds shares at every level and who ultimately sits behind the structure.

Tools already exist, including company registers and information on beneficial owners. The financial sector already carries out these types of checks. We need to ensure that we have the means to apply the same approach to our professions.

If the law is passed without all the safeguards you have requested, what will you do?

“We support this reform, which contains many positive developments. However, we still need to strengthen the foundations on which the entire structure rests: professional independence. At the time of this interview, there is ongoing discussion about the requirement for an absolute majority of the share capital and the need to go beyond qualifications alone. Safeguards concerning other shareholders and sellers of building materials also remain essential.

Ultimately, construction affects far more than the property owner alone: a building has consequences for its occupants, its neighbours, the environment and our living environment.
Pierre Hurt

Pierre Hurt, director, OAI

The law will subsequently be supplemented by a code of professional ethics, which will allow certain rules to be clarified. We want a coherent set of rules backed by effective monitoring and enforcement mechanisms.

Ultimately, construction affects far more than the property owner alone: a building has consequences for its occupants, its neighbours, the environment and our living environment. Architects and consulting engineers must be able to take all these issues and interests into account without the ownership structure of their practice exposing them to influence or pressure that prevents them from fulfilling their essential role.

I will repeat this as my concluding point: the independence of OAI members is essential to ensuring a sustainable living environment!”