When intelligence becomes artificial, what continues to define the value of talent?
Aline Giersch – “When intelligence becomes artificial, what makes the difference is no longer just the quality of knowledge, but also the quality of perception. Today, a talented person is someone with a curious, critical mind, capable of understanding the person they’re talking to in depth, of sensing a situation, and of making sense of things where an algorithm sees only a string of data.
At a time when everything is accelerating and becoming automated, a talented individual has the courage to question, to make decisions and to take responsibility. Their intuition and creativity open up new perspectives. Their empathy enables them to better understand both their colleagues and their clients. It is these distinguishing qualities that shape our teams and make us an employer and partner of choice.
What mistake do companies keep making when it comes to attracting or retaining talent?
“The most common mistake is to believe that what attracts people is also what keeps them. Thinking that fine words alone are enough to build loyalty is an illusion. Today, companies are investing in their employer brand, recruitment, andonboarding, look after their image, and make an acceptable offer in order to be accepted. But if the day-to-day running of the business lacks managerial oversight, feedback, recognition – then talent comes, but then leaves. A brand doesn’t retain people; an experience does.
Talented people stay because of a genuine, consistent, human and authentic experience. A salary package may attract them, and benefits may win them over. However, nothing can replace the day-to-day experience, which must be consistent with the brand’s recruitment message. Our employees want transparency; they want to understand the challenges and receive genuine recognition for the work they’ve done. This is where employee loyalty is forged: in what we do, not in what we promise!
What decision relating to talent would be likely to be unpopular but necessary at the moment?
“We could mention: limiting remote working to encourage collaboration, or imposing total transparency on pay scales. But in my view, the main issue isn’t a new wellbeing programme or a revamped corporate charter. The real challenge, in my view, is understanding that the quality of management is the primary driver of staff retention. Despite growing awareness within the company and well-established rules, turning a blind eye to toxic behaviour from senior staff or high-performing employees is still far too common.
Everything else is therefore merely cosmetic. Re-educating highly productive employees who display inappropriate behaviour should be a matter of course; however, it is often easier to ignore reality than to face it. This is where managerial courage comes into its own. Far too many companies still lose staff, not because of market competition, but because their day-to-day experience falls short of their expectations. Decisions – or the lack thereof – truly do change career trajectories.”
This article was originally written in French, then translated and edited into English for the Paperjam website.




