Sylvain Barrette: We have seen a significant rally in US equities after its large initial knee-jerk reaction following US president Donald Trump’s “Liberation Day” announcement of higher tariffs on 2 April 2025. The subsequent rally is often credited to US retail investors. Is there something for European authorities to learn?
Mahmood Pradhan: Europe starts with a low equity culture for retail [investors]. [European] banks are full of retail savings. It's a deep cultural thing. Why do European citizens keep so much money in banks instead of investing it in retail equity products like exchange-traded funds?
There are two reasons. One is that many European countries have the pillar one pension system. They don’t feel like they need to invest--and that makes them risk-averse. In the US, you don’t have pillar one, so you need a 401K [retirement account].
How can that be solved?
I think the problem is the banking system in Europe. That’s the real problem, as banks in Europe don’t face sufficient competition.
In other parts of the world, when interest rates rise, banks must compete. In the US, for example, a lot of money went into market funds tied to US short-term treasury bills. You don’t have the same culture here. Your bank will not offer you a product that is very closely related to the European Central Bank policy rate. As the ECB policy rates were moving up, deposit rates lagged quite a lot in Europe. They weren’t facing the competition.
Your comment sounds as if there is an institutional framework that is not favouring active investment behaviour, and it starts with…
Bank accounts. The ample savings are in the wrong place. They’re in banks. Now, to explain this further, how can that system be sustained in a normal situation? You would [need] banks consolidating to take advantage of economies of scale. There’s a strong resistance to any cross-border mergers in Europe; you’ve seen it with Unicredit and Commerzbank. There is even resistance within countries for banks to consolidate.
There’s a strange thing. Everyone talks about national champions, but no one says we need a European champion.
Second, cross-border banking flows are lower now than they were before the euro area crisis. Financial integration in banking is going the other way.
Bank of America in the US has something like 60m customers. There are huge economies of scale when that bank wants to market new products. Also, there are synergies because you’ve got a [large] customer base. In terms of customers, there are two or three or four or five large banks in Europe. There’s a strange thing. Everyone talks about national champions, but no one says we need a European champion.
Why are funds not flying in Europe as in the US?
I believe ETFs, in the next few years, will see a very big growth area in Europe… from the current low base. They appeal to people because they’re low cost. You can pick your risk spectrum with thematic, active and passive ETFs.
Do ETFs appeal more to the younger generation than the older one?
This is one of the rationales why the [European] Commission is pushing more financial education and financial literacy. The goal is to get people to understand, not necessarily complex financial instruments, but just to understand that there are alternatives to bank deposits.
Buying an ETF online requires a little bit more familiarity [than subscribing to a mutual fund], and maybe younger people are going to learn that faster. Digitalisation needs to become more user-friendly.
The lack of access to professional research for free or at a decent price is a major difficulty for individuals looking for expert comments before buying individual bonds in Europe. Research is there. It’s just that it's expensive. Isn’t it?
I think this is a scale economy. If you have very large financial institutions that have retail customers, they can centralise and provide quite a lot of research. If you’re looking for bonds across Europe, what yields are, and so on, for retail investors, you will need very large financial institutions.
My problem with Mifid II--from a policy perspective--is that it would disadvantage the small countries. I wouldn’t expect Goldman or JP Morgan--or whoever--to give detailed research on Latvia or on equity stocks in that country. They can’t afford it.



