In its latest annual opinion, the Fondation idea devotes part of its report to contributions on the theme of the environment. In particular, economist Michel-Edouard Ruben details the impact that the ecological transition could have on the country's economy and its public finances.
“Whilst the ecological transition was once presented and considered as a painless path that would generate a double dividend, it is now increasingly recognised that the major socio-economic transformations it entails are shocks that will not be cost-free and will often require sacrifices before they produce benefits,” Ruben says in his contribution. At the end of 2023, in a study on the subject, the national statistics institute Statec pointed out that “estimates of the impact of the energy transition on GDP range from -1.3% to +3.8% in 2050.”
In other words, the benefits of the ecological transition will arrive--but later. In the meantime, it is likely to have a negative impact on the performance of the Luxembourg economy. This is likely to be the case in particular with carbon pricing and emissions standards, which could “increase the stock of stranded capital,” says the economist. “Stranded capital” refers to assets that can no longer be profitably exploited. This, for example, could be the case for oil infrastructure.
Another negative impact mentioned by the economist is the impact on the competitiveness of Luxembourg and its businesses compared with other regions that have chosen to be less virtuous in terms of decarbonisation. By way of example, the Fondation Idea mentions: “It may be that the exits of Blackrock and Vanguard from the Net-Zero Asset Managers Initiative, the fact that the major US banks have left the Net-Zero Banking Alliance and the announcement by the US Federal Reserve that it was withdrawing from the Network for Greening the Financial System will not be without effect on the Luxembourg financial centre.”
Ruben points to other potential impacts, such as a fuelling of price rises that would precipitate a rise in interest rates or higher energy and production costs. The labour market is also likely to suffer a number of inconveniences, including disorganisation due to a shortage of skilled labour to fill green jobs, and lower productivity gains due to the “reallocation of production from companies that are less environmentally friendly but highly productive to companies that are ecologically virtuous but less productive,” he says, also mentioning a probable “financial instability” due to “a depreciation of carbon assets held by the financial sector.” This would have an impact on credit risk and liquidity.
Encouraging through aid that weighs on public finances
Public finances will not be spared by the low-carbon transition either. First, because tourism at the pump is set to fall in such a transition, which “will cause an erosion of tax revenues based on fuel sales, particularly to non-residents.” Social and sustainable aid, such as the CO2 tax credit, the Klimabonus or the free transport policy, will also weigh on public finances. Businesses will also undoubtedly need greater support, especially those for whom decarbonisation represents investments that are not economically viable. The government will also need to allocate investment to renovating public buildings or developing mobility infrastructure, not to mention spending on adapting to climate change and compensating for natural disasters.
So should we give up?
Such are the arguments that “climate sceptics,” or those reluctant to change, can use to put the importance of leading an ecological transition into perspective. A few days ago, Jos Noesen, an independent educator and former project manager for the education ministry, published an analysis on the Improof platform on “the reasons for our reluctance to preserve our planet.” For Noesen, one of the reasons concerns the economy--and, implicitly, politics.
“In addition to this intransigence, economists are incapable, despite their undeniable skills in economics, of transposing the impacts of climate change into economic loss. They calculate them in the same way as traditional financial risks, without taking account of the unpredictability of losses. Finance Watch, a public interest association, notes ‘a serious disconnect between climate research and the economic models that shape economic and financial policies.’ All this leads to unrealistic impact estimates that are expressed in talk of staying with the way things are and without changing working methods without taking account of realities,” he explains..
One thing is certain: whilst embarking on a green(er) path will require investment that is admittedly difficult to put a figure on, doing nothing will also have a cost. “Estimating the costs of a transition to a low-carbon economy is difficult because of the radical uncertainty and cascading effects that accompany climate disruption,” stresses Ruben, Inaction in the face of climate change could lead to a loss of between 10% and 23% of global GDP, says the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).



