“Addressing climate risk is the only way to deliver a competitive and resilient insurance sector amid escalating climate losses. Without decisive action, the Commission’s ‘sustainable competitiveness’ agenda is devoid of any meaning,” argued Julia Symon, head of research and advocacy at Finance Watch, in a press statement on Tuesday 11 February 2025. Photo: Caroline Lessire / Finance Watch

“Addressing climate risk is the only way to deliver a competitive and resilient insurance sector amid escalating climate losses. Without decisive action, the Commission’s ‘sustainable competitiveness’ agenda is devoid of any meaning,” argued Julia Symon, head of research and advocacy at Finance Watch, in a press statement on Tuesday 11 February 2025. Photo: Caroline Lessire / Finance Watch

A coalition of finance experts and advocacy groups urged the European Commission to adopt Eiopa’s recommendations on insurers’ fossil fuel exposure, warning that failure to act could destabilise the financial system and leave taxpayers bearing the cost.

A coalition of 22 civil society organisations and financial experts, led by Brussels-based Finance Watch, has urged the European Commission to implement capital requirements for insurers’ fossil fuel exposures. In a joint letter addressed to the financial services and the savings and investments union commissioner, Maria Luís Albuquerque, and seen by Paperjam, the group calls for a targeted review of Solvency II in line with recommendations issued by the European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (Eiopa) on 7 November 2024.

Eiopa’s recommendations outlined measures to mitigate the transition risks associated with fossil fuel investments held by insurers. The authority proposed raising capital requirements on stocks exposed to transition risks by up to 17% in additive terms, increasing insurers’ overall capital obligations. For bonds, Eiopa recommended a capital charge of up to 40% in multiplicative terms in addition to existing capital requirements, instead of applying rating downgrades or leaving regulations unchanged.

However, the organisations believe it is ‘highly unlikely’ that the European Commission’s 2025 work programme will include these recommendations. Despite Eiopa’s findings, the commission will almost certainly not include a review of Solvency II. The letter from Finance Watch and its co-signatories emphasised the necessity of addressing Eiopa’s conclusions, urging the commission to commit to a review in 2025. They stressed that aligning regulatory measures with empirical evidence was critical for financial stability and in line with the commitments made by member states.

The letter also highlighted that the failure to adjust Solvency II regulations would undermine public trust in insurance companies and EU financial oversight. It warned that underpricing fossil fuel-related transition risks could distort insurers’ investment decisions, leading to excessive exposure to fossil fuel assets. This, in turn, could exacerbate financial instability and increase the likelihood of an unmanaged economic transition.

The Financial Stability Board, in its report published on 16 January 2025, recognised that failing to account for climate-related financial risks could have systemic implications far beyond the current weight of fossil fuel investments in insurers’ portfolios. Additionally, the network for greening the financial system has recently tripled its estimated economic damage projections from climate change, indicating that climate risks remain significantly underestimated.

Julia Symon, head of research and advocacy at Finance Watch, stated that Eiopa’s recommendations were backed by empirical evidence, creating both a foundation and an obligation for regulators to act. She warned that ignoring these risks would weaken the competitiveness and resilience of the insurance sector at a time of escalating climate-related losses.

Marika Carlucci, senior EU policy officer at ShareAction, criticised the European Commission’s inaction, stating that fossil fuel investments presented extreme risks that left insurers vulnerable. She described the failure to implement Eiopa’s recommendations as reckless, arguing that it exposed insurers, taxpayers and the broader financial system to growing climate-related threats.

The group argued in the letter that any delay in regulatory action will increase insurers’ exposure to financial instability, with the ultimate cost being borne by policyholders and taxpayers.