The amounts give an idea of the scale of the Luxembourg social model - a system where redistribution is not just a budget item, but an entire architecture of transfers. (Photo: Shutterstock)

The amounts give an idea of the scale of the Luxembourg social model - a system where redistribution is not just a budget item, but an entire architecture of transfers. (Photo: Shutterstock)

We'd like to think that all we need is a table to understand the welfare state: in one column, what each household pays to the state; in the other, what it receives in return. A simple, almost moral calculation. But in Luxembourg, as just about everywhere else, this calculation is if not impossible, at least very complicated.

This is shown, almost in spite of itself, by a parliamentary response from the Finance Minister, Gilles Roth Gilles Roth (DP), addressed to MP Marc GoergenMarc Goergen (Piraten). In 2022, a single household paid an average of €5,800 in income tax, a single-parent household just as much, and a married couple almost €17,600. But the medians--between €400 and €6,300 depending on the tax class--tell a different story: there is no such thing as an "average taxpayer".

On the other hand, public spending goes in all directions: a pupil costs the community almost €25,000 a year to the community, a seat at crèche costs €10,000, and a person insured by the CNS spends an average of €4,600 on care each year. For a dependent person, the State spends €34,000 at home and €89,000 in an institution. And family support is a mosaic of figures and realities: €5,000 family allowance per child, €29,000 parental leave, €2,100 energy or cost-of-living allowance per household.

But adding up these amounts makes no sense. They are aimed at different groups, subject to different, sometimes exclusive, criteria, as the minister points out in his reply. The Luxembourg welfare state is a network of partial solidarities, not a homogenous whole. Even tax credits escape any stable average: €573 per household in 2022, or €1,019 if the temporary energy credit is included.

And behind the visible aid, there are services that are almost never quantified: the Grand Ducal Police and its 2,500 officers, the CGDIS and its thousands of professional or volunteer firefighters. These are costs shared between the State and the municipalities, which are difficult to translate into euros per citizen.

And yet, the 2026 budget attempts to put figures on this elusive solidarity. Almost half of State spending - 46% to be precise - is social transfers, i.e. benefits, subsidies, aid and contributions to the social security system. In other words, one out of every two euros spent by the Luxembourg State goes directly towards financing national solidarity.

In detail, the Caisse pour l'avenir des enfants alone accounts for €1.6bn, including more than €1.1bn for family allowances alone. The National Solidarity Fund, which pays the cost-of-living allowance and the energy allowance, among other things, has a budget of around €270m, with a further €120m this year to compensate for inflation and energy costs. Added to this are specific measures: €12m to improve support for the elderly, and targeted adjustments for low-income households.

These amounts give an idea of the scale of the Luxembourg social model - a system where redistribution is not just a budget item, but an entire architecture of transfers. According to Eurostat, social benefits (excluding pensions) reduce the poverty rate in Luxembourg by 27%, one of the highest levels in Europe. A figure that says, in its own way, how much solidarity costs - and how much it brings in.

At this point, the calculation becomes blurred. And that's precisely where the Idea Foundation invites us to shift our gaze. This think tank, close to the Chamber of Commerce, reminds us that the generosity of Luxembourg's social model is part of the country's collective commitment--but that it rests on a fragile foundation. Long-term funding depends on sustained economic growth, stable employment and a demographic balance that remains favourable. However, the ageing population, rising healthcare and dependency costs, or the rise in cross-border workers could soon reshuffle the cards, the foundation reminded the state in its note, when the new coalition took office.

"The welfare state is one of Luxembourg's competitive assets, but its sustainability can no longer be taken for granted," stresses the Idea Foundation. Behind the figures, there is a silent budgetary equation: that of competitiveness financing solidarity.

Maybe the real calculation of the welfare state is not in the national accounts, but in a country's ability to maintain this implicit pact: a state that redistributes massively, citizens who continue to believe in it. Luxembourg spends a lot on its citizens, but is never able to say how much its model is 'worth'. Here, the welfare state is not calculated: it is observed.