The responsibility for valuation lies with the fund’s board and its management company, rather than the depositary bank, explained Dzemal Tomic, senior vice president & head of institutional banking at Spuerkeess in an interview.  Photo: Spuerkeess

The responsibility for valuation lies with the fund’s board and its management company, rather than the depositary bank, explained Dzemal Tomic, senior vice president & head of institutional banking at Spuerkeess in an interview.  Photo: Spuerkeess

The rapid expansion of private markets is increasing pressure on asset managers to justify valuations that are often based on models rather than market prices. Spuerkeess executive Dzemal Tomic examines the risks, safeguards and grey areas surrounding private assets.

“By definition, private asset valuations rely on theoretical models rather than continuously traded market prices, creating an inevitable gap with reality,” said Dzemal Tomic, senior vice president & head of institutional banking at Spuerkeess. The Luxembourg bank acts as a service provider for both internal and third-party funds representing nearly €100bn in assets under management, with around 35% allocated to private assets—mainly private debt—and 65% to UCITS-type assets.

Early signs of valuation stress

Valuations are closely tied to the risk of panic redemptions. “Institutional investors don’t want the first investors exiting to do so at an overly generous valuation,” said Tomic.

However, regulatory frameworks such as the Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive (AIFMD) impose legal liabilities on managers if valuations materially diverge from reality.

Institutional investors don’t want the first investors exiting to do so at an overly generous valuation.

Dzemal Tomic, senior vice president & head of institutional banking , Spuerkeess

Tomic argued that warning signs of incorrect valuations in private debt can generally be identified early. For instance, it occurs when borrowers struggle to service debt following missed interest payments or breach covenants. He noted that current default rates in European private debt funds remain relatively low—typically below 2%—compared with roughly 9% in the US.

While private debt offers earlier warning indicators, private equity valuations tend to be more opaque. The valuation risks in PE  are more difficult to detect, as weaker quarterly cash flows may simply reflect temporary or seasonal factors.

Private debt funds also allow for limited valuation flexibility “around — and typically less than—  2%,” according to Tomic. However, if a valuation later proves inaccurate and results in a NAV error above the authorized threshold, reimbursement mechanisms must be triggered, potentially creating significant operational consequences for the asset manager.

Private debt valuation practices under scrutiny

Valuation remains a complex and often non-transparent aspect of the private debt industry. In Europe, particularly in hubs like Luxembourg, Tomic stressed that the responsibility for valuation lies with the fund’s board and its management company, rather than the depositary bank.

There are criticisms in the market about whether asset managers are the right counterparties to carry out these valuations, and whether conflicts of interest may arise. Indeed, there are concerns that they could be inclined to present valuations in a more favourable light than warranted.

Tomic said depositary banks such as Spuerkeess are responsible for ensuring pricing policies are consistently applied and that management companies have appropriate valuation processes in place. He also noted that some asset managers outsource valuations to third parties that still rely on data provided by the manager itself.

NAVs are less critical for closed-end structures

Tomic argued that valuation is less vital for closed-end funds than for open-end funds because there are no redemptions; investors exit only upon asset sales. Therefore, he added that values remain theoretical until realized. In these structures, valuations primarily serve fee calculation and reporting purposes.

Accurate NAV may be also relevant for transactions in secondary markets. However, secondary-market transactions remain limited in Europe and primarily involve sophisticated institutional investors. As a result, Tomic suggested that sophisticated investors in secondary markets rely less on official NAVs and more on their own assessment of underlying asset quality.