Parents will be able to choose whether their child is taught to read and write in French or German. (Photo: Shutterstock)

Parents will be able to choose whether their child is taught to read and write in French or German. (Photo: Shutterstock)

The choice between French and German to learn to read, write and do arithmetic is now a fact, with the vote on 3 December on the Alpha project, an educational reform that aims to change the way literacy is taught in basic education.

With the vote this Wednesday 3 December on Bill 8587 and therefore the Alpha project, a major change in basic education in Luxembourg will begin at the start of the next school year 2026/2027. Parents will be able to choose whether their children are taught to read and write in French or German. Trialled since 2022 in four pilot schools, the project is based on the idea that learning to read, write and do maths in a language close to the family environment can improve equality of opportunity.

“Studies carried out as part of the pilot programme have shown that children taught to read and write in their mother tongue or a familiar language show better results, greater motivation, greater well-being in class, as well as increased participation”, insisted the Minister for National Education, Claude MeischClaude Meisch (DP), this Wednesday in the Chamber of Deputies.

The government says it plans to make the necessary adjustments, such as training teachers, developing appropriate teaching materials, and organising classes so that all pupils - whatever their language of learning - take subjects other than language, reading or maths together. In-service teacher training is also a priority: six training courses have already been organised, three more will follow in 2025/2026, and 225 training courses are planned as part of the Alpha project.

The ADR against

“The children (who are literate in French, editor’s note) will remain in their classrooms: They will be grouped with others only for language, reading, writing and maths. For all other subjects, they will join their German-speaking classmates. Classes in science, sport, art and music will continue to be taught in Lëtzebuergesch, which remains the language of school communication. The choice of literacy language does not call into question compulsory multilingual teaching”, Mr Meisch had already stated last September.

French literacy will be rolled out across the board over six years. After the four pioneering communes of Differdange, Dudelange, Schifflange and Larochette, all basic schools in the country will now be offering literacy in French in cycle 2.1, i.e. the first year of primary school, for six-year-olds. “In the third term of the 2026-2027 school year, parents of a child in cycle 1.2 will be able to choose the language of literacy for the first time. This will take us to cycle 4.2, i.e. the end of basic schooling, in 2032.”

In the vote in the Chamber of Deputies on Wednesday, there were 52 yes votes, two abstentions - Piratepartei MPs - and the five ADR MPs voted against. Francine ClosenerFrancine Closener (LSAP), while supporting the fundamental concept of French literacy for struggling pupils, expressed “serious concerns about implementation, the lack of qualified staff, and the risk of segregation from European schools (...) The Alpha project alone cannot solve the problems of socio-economic inequality.” Unsurprisingly, Fred KeupFred Keup (ADR) reiterated his criticisms made since the launch of the project, believing that it “promotes ‘Francophonisation’ to the detriment of German and Luxembourgish, and (that it) risks creating parallel societies by separating pupils”. He also questioned the validity of the pilot schools, which he said were not representative.