Why “play” cards when you can become a card-playing machine instead? Photo: Shutterstock

Why “play” cards when you can become a card-playing machine instead? Photo: Shutterstock

Our society is being transformed before our very eyes by new technologies and digital infrastructures, but what is the effect on us… as people?

Months ago, I decided to take a Twitter hiatus--wanting to avoid bad Russia/Ukraine takes--and, as a replacement activity for those braindead moments on the train or in the WC, I started playing euchre on my phone.

Euchre is a card game from my native American Midwest, a trick-taking game in the vein of hearts, whist, bridge, etc. In euchre, the first part of each round is devoted to choosing a trump suit, a process that beginners quickly get the hang of: if you have a good hand, make your choice; if not, pass the call on to the next player; and if you’re not sure… then pass. Calling trump is no guarantee of winning, so this conservative strategy has no downside.

As your gameplay matures, however, you increasingly realise that passing isn’t as low-risk as it seems. By abstaining from the risk, you incur another one: that somebody else will make the call. And of course, your opponents will choose a trump suit according to their own best chances, certainly not to yours.

Makes things complicated. Makes things interesting.

Anyway, having found a free online version of the game, I began playing round after round after round against three robots named Bill, Mike and Lisa. The website was bare-bones and offered nothing by way of statistics, so after maybe 25 games I became curious: What was my win percentage? Was it improving? How effective were my risk appetite adjustments?

I started keeping track of wins/losses in a notebook, but almost immediately gave it up. Despite my lingering curiosity, I made a decision: I would try to play the game in the true sense of “play,” i.e. not to transmogrify it into a skill that, via data-gathering and analysis, could be understood and augmented.

After all (I reasoned), I’m a journalist with a bad memory and a disgust for mathematics. Was this really a skill worth augmenting? A boozy evening of euchre with friends is fun; winning games of euchre on the toilet against robots is fun, too… but more the way popping a pimple is fun.

Yet the fact remains: my mind went straight to a data-and-analytics place. I was all set to collect data, extract insights, apply the appropriate updates to my strategy and then repeat the process continuously and forever until I was Euchre Emperor of the World. It was a kneejerk reaction. But why?

Because that’s what you do

Our society is being technologised before our very eyes: edtech, fintech, climatech, healthtech, cleantech, agritech, foodtech, crimetech, sportstech, etc., etc., etc. And we aren’t just talking hardware updates. This is a societywide frenzy of reinvention. We’ve hit a phase in which the infrastructure of basically everything can be altered by the likes of artificial intelligence, the internet of things, supercomputers, social media, distributed ledgers… by digitalisation and automatisation, broadly speaking.

I don’t mean infrastructure only in the sense of public works and construction systems, though these are implied too (smart roads; smart buildings; energy grids run with AI; etc.) I mean the infrastructure of everything. What is a classroom? What is a bank? What is an electrician? Virtual meeting spaces, cryptocurrencies and smart buildings complicate, respectively, all these questions. One notices a certain giddiness in the race to redefine long-held norms by digital means.

Newfangled technologies operate in their own disparate ways, but certain underlying principles unite them, including their core unit of power: data. Data is what computers can parse at superhuman speeds, which is why the technofrenzy is built around the mining and deployment thereof. Data has always existed, of course, but never as a substratum readable by a master programme that can search it, evaluate it, understand it and produce an output of some kind.

Examples of new classes of output would be cryptocurrencies and deepfakes, but there is naturally a deeper picture: the world that creates, sells, maintains and uses modern technologies cannot be the world of old. Our jobs are evolving, our roles within society are evolving. “Just google it” has become an ordinary phrase that, innocuously enough, invokes the maturing computer/human dynamic: technology renders us a service, e.g. to search zillions of webpages instantly, so that we can play an executive rather than a menial role.

This, indeed, is where the experts say we’re headed: away from menial chores. The scare that technology--let’s call them robots--will steal our jobs is over. Instead, robots are here to automate repetitive tasks, shifting the human domain into that which they cannot execute, i.e. the strategic, the ethical, the emotional, the managerial, the creative, etc.

A new definition of “human being” is therefore in circulation: to be human is to be a non-robot. Our species is now considered to be above any “pointless” task that modern technology can automate.

Thus, the computer age: the human domain has become one of problem-solving, of lateral thinking, of realising and accelerating and maintaining technological progress.

Trendy

This is the role I had unthinkingly embodied with my card-playing, that of a strategic decisionmaker who knew how technology could serve him. Bill, Mike and Lisa would help me create datasets at a speed that humans couldn’t (and without judging my experiments), which would enable me to implement a kind of learning algorithm on myself. Ideally, the platform could have assisted with all this, but it didn’t matter; I knew what to do.

The whole scene, I argue, is evidence of cultural runoff from the societywide technofrenzy. We think in terms of machines, in terms of system augmentation, in terms of progress. We know that datasets contain information, the capture and analysis of which will result in value, and we apply this methodology everywhere and to everything, relentlessly. For businessfolk, it means opportunity, competitive edge, money; for researchers, new ways to gather knowledge; for students, learning search skills instead of memorising dates; for me, improving my ability to win a card game.

Our mentality could also, increasingly, be described as one of master in a master/slave relationship with technology. There are obvious benefits to this, like making robots do dangerous tasks, using technology to cure diseases, etc. But as a general mentality, defining ourselves in this robot/non-robot dichotomy feels trendy and myopic. Negative definitions are always limiting: who is to say that repetitive tasks have no place in the human experience? Perhaps meaning can be found in rhythmic activities, perhaps minds can be stimulated by scenarios other than bending technology and its outputs to our every whim.

Because, indeed, playing online euchre needn’t be about augmenting a skill. There is value in occupying part of the brain with repetitive gameplay while the rest of it contemplates other problems, listens to music or simply switches off.

Progress, progress, pprrooggrreess

Progress is in human nature, surely, but the tenor of progress nowadays is unmistakably linked to, or mixed up with, digital technology (which itself is undoubtedly linked to corporate interests). The technofrenzy provides us with the vocabulary we use to discuss advancement and improvement, the most telling of which is the master of all buzzwords, innovation. The older meaning of innovate is to introduce a new technology to the marketplace, but nowadays it’s widely used as a loose synonym for succeed, in particular by dint of good problem-solving. So… new tech equals success.

Anyway, the tree I’m trying to bark up is that not all technology is progress and not all progress is technological. Sure, sometimes relentless progress by digital means is an absolute must, like in a medical research lab. But not always. Either way, our world is saturated with narratives of technological progress and it is seeping into our brains and making us do silly things.

To that lattermost point: after hundreds of games of euchre I still don’t know how effective my strategic adjustments were, but I have since grown bored of it and downloaded a hearts app, which has a built-in statistics page… and I check it every day.