Euro area unemployment is close to a record low and is expected to fall further over the next three years, but that is not translating into faster pay growth. Normally, when the pool of available workers shrinks, employees gain bargaining power and companies come under pressure to offer bigger pay rises to attract and retain staff. This time, the pattern is proving less straightforward.
Economists at the European Central Bank argued in a blog post published on 9 March 2026 that the puzzle makes more sense once factors beyond headline unemployment are taken into account. That broader view matters for investors and policymakers alike. While a tight jobs market would usually signal stronger wage settlements, the analysis indicates that labour supply in the euro area has remained more elastic than the jobless rate suggests, even as labour demand has cooled without leading to large-scale lay-offs.
More workers
The clearest explanation lies in where the euro area has found workers. Over the past three years, about six million additional jobs were created, yet only about 500,000 of those were filled from the pool of unemployed people, the analysis found. More than three million jobs were taken by people immigrating into the euro area, while about 2.5 million were filled by previously inactive nationals, 60% of them women.
That marks a sharp change from the years before the pandemic. Foreign workers accounted for about 53% of employment creation in recent years, up from 29% between 2015 and 2019. Previously inactive nationals contributed 43%, compared with 9% in 2015-19. By contrast, unemployed workers had been the main source of new hires before the pandemic, contributing 63% in the years 2015-2019.
Older workers have also stayed in the labour market for longer. Since the third quarter of 2022, the participation rate for people aged 55-74 has risen by nearly 1.7 percentage points, leaving more than 1.5 million additional older workers active in the labour force. That followed an earlier rise of 3.2 percentage points in 2016-2019, underlining that this is not merely a post-pandemic distortion.
The implication is that labour supply has been deeper than the unemployment figures imply. That has helped ease labour market tightness and moderate wage pressures even while joblessness has remained unusually low. Looking further ahead, the authors caution that ageing could still shrink the euro area labour force by around 11 million by 2035 unless immigration and higher participation continue.
Hidden slack still exists
The blog post also points to a reserve army of workers outside standard unemployment data. Nearly seven million people in the euro area are classed as “marginally attached”, meaning they are broadly willing to work but are either unavailable or not actively looking. On top of that, around five million workers are underemployed and would prefer longer hours. Converting those extra desired hours into full-time equivalents would amount to roughly two million additional workers.
For wage dynamics, that matters because firms do not need to draw only from the unemployed. They can also recruit from people just outside the labour force or expand hours among those already employed. In practical terms, the labour market has more spare capacity than the unemployment rate alone would suggest.
Fewer job switches
Another clue comes from how often workers move between jobs. In a truly tight labour market, employers are often forced to poach staff from competitors by offering better pay and conditions. Historically, between four million and seven million employees switch jobs each year in the euro area, or about 3% to 5% of the workforce. But recent quarterly data from the ECB’s Consumer Expectations Survey indicate that this momentum is fading.
The age profile of the workforce helps explain why. Older workers tend to face lower unemployment, remain longer in the same job and see weaker wage growth than younger cohorts. Average tenure rises from about two years for younger workers to 20 years for older ones. Over the past three years, unemployment among older workers stood at 4.5%, below 6% for prime-age workers and roughly 14.6% for younger workers. Annual job-to-job transitions fall from around 6.5% for younger workers to 2% for older ones, while wage growth is also weakest among older staff.
As Europe’s workforce ages, that structural change could itself help restrain wage pressure. Workers with long tenure are less likely to be dismissed, less likely to move and less likely to bargain aggressively for higher pay. That leaves the labour market looking less intense than the headline jobless rate alone would suggest.
Companies are hiring less
The demand side tells much the same story. Softer demand for labour does not always show up in higher unemployment, because companies often respond to slower growth by cutting vacancies rather than headcount. The economists suggest that this has been happening since mid-2022, with job openings declining without a material increase in lay-offs.
The result is fewer vacancies for each unemployed worker, reducing competition among employers for staff and easing pressure on wage settlements. The contrast with the Covid-19 shock is revealing. In a severe downturn, unemployment rises quickly as companies cut jobs. In a milder slowdown, they are more likely to curb hiring or leave posts unfilled, rather than dismiss workers.
Hours worked reinforce that picture. More than 80% of companies adjust to swings in demand by changing employees’ hours. During the 2013-2019 business cycle, hours worked by euro area employees rose by around five hours per quarter from trough to peak, equivalent to 2.2 million full-time jobs. Although hours worked per employee fell sharply during the pandemic, they still remain below pre-pandemic levels and have only recently begun to recover, suggesting that labour hoarding is starting to fade.
Why this matters for inflation
The broader message is that low unemployment no longer provides a complete guide to wage inflation. Migration, stronger participation among women and older workers, hidden labour reserves, lower job churn and weaker hiring appetite have all made the euro area labour market less tight than the headline unemployment rate suggests.
For central bankers, that offers a cleaner explanation for why wage growth can moderate even while unemployment stays near record lows. For markets, it suggests that sticky pay growth may not be as inevitable as the headline jobs data imply. And for workers, it is a reminder that a low unemployment rate does not automatically translate into stronger bargaining power when the supply of labour is quietly expanding and firms are becoming more cautious about hiring.



