The Vatican Bank and two Italian pension funds are preparing to sue Luxembourg-based Optimum Asset Management and its affiliates over alleged misconduct tied to a US-focused property fund that they claim led to losses exceeding €35m.
The planned legal action, disclosed in a 22 July filing at the US federal court in Delaware, was first reported by OffshoreAlert, a Miami-based investigative news outlet that publishes red-flag alerts, legal filings, indictments and regulatory actions. The report was shared with Paperjam.
The three investors--the Vatican Bank (officially the Istituto per le Opere di Religione), the labour consultants’ pension fund ENPACL, and the multi-profession welfare fund EPAP--are seeking legal redress from Optimum Asset Management (Luxembourg) SA, its affiliates, and its fund structure Optimum Evolution Fund SIF, including the sub-fund USA Property I.
Optimum describes itself as a boutique real estate investor and developer that seeks to optimise mispriced and mismanaged residential and commercial income-producing assets in established property markets such as Germany and the United States. Headquartered in Luxembourg, Optimum AM maintains representative offices in London, Berlin and Boston.
According to the filing, the Luxembourg-domiciled sub-fund focused exclusively on US real estate, with investments in properties located in New York, Florida and California via a series of special purpose vehicles. The applicants claim that between 2013 and 2023 they collectively invested €42.5m in the vehicle and have since incurred cumulative losses of over €35m--a drawdown of more than 80% of committed capital.
In the Delaware application, the investors allege “malfeasance and misconduct” in the operation of the fund and stated they intend to launch proceedings before the District Court (Tribunal d’Arrondissement) in Luxembourg “within a reasonable amount of time”.
The complaint accuses Optimum AM and related entities of “self-dealing, conversion, breach of fiduciary duty, and/or mismanagement”. The firms are also alleged to have misrepresented key facts, withheld material information, and used a “complex web of companies” to obscure events that significantly affected the valuation of the underlying properties and the distribution of returns.
A third-party investigation commissioned by the investors identified structural opacity and potential conflicts of interest within the sub-fund’s operations. The court filing further revealed that Ernst & Young, the fund’s independent auditor, was unable to complete its 2023 audit of certain investment properties due to the absence of reliable valuation data provided by Optimum AM.
Efforts to clarify the situation through formal inquiries made under Luxembourg’s shareholder rights regime in early 2024 were met with a “materially insufficient” response, according to the filing. The investors say Optimum AM acknowledged in its 24 June reply that it did not possess certain requested information concerning the structure, financing, and management of the assets.
Should the action proceed in Luxembourg courts, the case may become a key test of the grand duchy’s investor protection standards and regulatory oversight of specialised investment funds (SIFs)--structures designed for well-informed investors but often operating with limited public transparency, particularly in real estate and private asset strategies.
Paperjam has contacted both Optimum Asset Management and the Vatican Bank for comment.
![“Optimum [Asset Management] and its related entities engaged in self-dealing, conversion, breach of fiduciary duty, and/or mismanagement in the operation of the sub-fund,” stated a discovery filing on 22 July 2025 at the federal court in Delaware, US. Photo: Shutterstock](https://assets.paperjam.lu/images/articles/vatican-bank-prepares-to-sue-luxembourg-based-optimum-asset-management/0.5/0.5/640/426/738516.jpg)

