The digital operational resilience act (Dora), which came into effect on 16 January 2023, aims to ensure that financial entities can maintain secure operations amid significant disruptions to information and communication technology (ICT). Entities within its scope have until 17 January 2025 to achieve full compliance. To assess preparedness, the Luxembourg Financial Sector Supervisory Commission (CSSF) conducted a survey in September 2024. The survey results, published on 7 October 2024, revealed that a diverse range of financial institutions in the grand duchy, including payment institutions, electronic money institutions, investment firms and payment service providers, had an overall perceived readiness score of 2.8. A score of 1 indicates full readiness and 4 indicates a lack of readiness.
In broader terms of self-assessment regarding readiness, 71% of the entities deemed themselves partially ready, 23% considered themselves mostly ready, 6% reported being not ready and only one entity claimed to be fully ready.
Resource shortage
Bénédicte d’Allard, senior manager at Arendt Regulatory & Consulting, and Faustine Cachera, counsel, intellectual property and communication and technology at Arendt & Medernach, found the overall Dora preparedness survey outcome satisfactory, stating, “the market appears to be progressing well.” However, d’Allard and Cachera were surprised that “while [financial institutions] have all known about the Dora implementation for quite some time, it is striking to see that the shortage of resources (technical, human resources, budget) was the most frequently raised priority.”
In the CSSF survey, ‘shortage of resources’ was one of the top three critical challenges for 40% of financial entities, with nearly one in four (23%) stating it as the most significant challenge.
Regulatory clarifications
The two experts said that while financial entities may have anticipated the journey towards implementing Dora, “there has been more gradual progress in terms of their understanding of the actual extent and workload required for implementation in most cases--as we have also seen from our experience.” They further agreed that the late clarifications resulting from the last regulatory technical standards (RTS) released in July 2024, in particular those specifying the elements that a financial entity needs to determine and assess when subcontracting ICT services supporting critical or important functions as mandated by article 30(5), have confirmed the high standards required by Dora.
This includes extensive requirements and contractual provisions when subcontracting ICT services supporting critical or important functions. Conversely, a lack of guidance on certain aspects, such as the criticality of business functions and ICT assets, along with several grey areas, including the qualification of business delegates providing a potential ICT service component as ICT third-party providers, have “probably caused additional internal discussions and slowed down the progress of certain Dora compliance projects.”
Reflecting on the other challenges identified in the CSSF survey, with contractual negotiations with ICT third-party service providers (54%) listed as one of the top challenges, d’Allard and Cachera argued that while some institutions have taken a proactive approach by providing tailor-made amendment agreements to ensure compliance with Dora contractual requirements (sometimes resulting in lengthy negotiations with providers), others have requested that their service providers amend their existing agreements, only to discover that most were not yet ready either.
Read also
Inter-group dependency
Another noteworthy outcome of the survey was that 42% of participants mentioned ‘dependence on group resulting in coordination efforts, which may muddle the compliance project and trigger some delays’ among their top three challenges. D’Allard and Cachera stated that Dora not only impacts a significant number of teams within the financial entity itself (including for example risk, compliance, ICT, ICT security and delegate oversight), but also requires coordination with other group entities when applicable. This necessary coordination may complicate the project due to sometimes contradictory interests. For example, the group’s willingness to standardise processes may hinder the local financial entity’s own Dora accountability or accurate allocation of critical business functions and ICT assets, which may require deviation from group standards. In addition, conflicts of interest may arise from the duty to assess and monitor ICT third-party providers, which may include a parent company, and subcontractors based on the Luxembourg entity’s own risk-based approach.
Understanding requirements
Among the other top challenges, the ‘understanding of Dora requirements’ was also raised by 17% of the entities as priority number one and selected by 23% of participants in their top three, “probably referring to the exhaustiveness of the regulation and all the complexity and high granularity of the associated commission delegated regulations and acts echoing, amongst others, the above-mentioned grey areas,” noted d’Allard and Cachera.
“With the deadline just a few months away, the financial sector is facing a critical period of adjustment,” said the experts, adding that Dora is expected to have a “transformative impact on the operational resilience of the financial sector across the EU. Luxembourg’s financial institutions must continue with their efforts to be compliant by 17 January 2025.” However, there remains a “need for clarification on certain key compliance aspects.”
The recent European Commission’s rejection of the draft implementing technical standards on the standard templates for the purposes of the register of information is “another illustration of a not completely set in stone Dora target.” D’Allard and Cachera added that “the commission indeed considered that the use of legal entity identifier (LEI) for ICT third-party service providers should not be imposed as it would complicate the identification of ICT third-party service providers and that in-scope entities should thus have the choice between such LEI and the European Unique Identifier (EUID), which, contrary to LEI, is attributed free of charge for the majority of EU companies.”
![“While [Luxembourg financial entities] have all known about the Dora implementation for quite some time, it is striking to see that the shortage of resources (technical, human resources, budget) was the most frequently raised priority,” said Bénédicte d’Allard and Faustine Cachera. They were commenting on the survey results regarding perceived Dora preparedness, conducted by Luxembourg’s financial regulator, the CSSF. Photos: Arendt & Medernach; Montage: Maison Moderne](https://assets.paperjam.lu/images/articles/underwhelming-resource-allocat/0.5/0.5/640/426/684696.png)


