For Gilles Roth, while strong financial supervision is necessary, it must not be at the expense of local expertise and market flexibility. Photo: Paperjam/archives

For Gilles Roth, while strong financial supervision is necessary, it must not be at the expense of local expertise and market flexibility. Photo: Paperjam/archives

The subject of financial supervision was on the agenda for the plenary session on Thursday 22 January. It was an opportunity for the Finance Minister to reiterate his opposition to extending the supervisory powers of the European Securities and Markets Authority and to announce a reform of the governance of the CSSF.

Questioned by André BaulerAndré Bauler (DP) and Laurent MosarLaurent Mosar (CSV) on the future of the Financial Centre in the face of supervisory reform at European level and in the context of the implementation of the Capital Union, the Minister of Finance, Gilles RothGilles Roth (CSV), announced to MPs that the governance of the Commission de surveillance du secteur financier (CSSF) will be strengthened. A bill is due to be tabled in February. Its primary objective will be to separate the investigative and decision-making functions and to strengthen the independence of the institution.

On 17 December last year, the House of Representatives approved Bill 8615, which set the annual budget allocated by the government to the CSSF at 20 million euros. This allocation represents around 11% of the institution's funding requirements, with the remainder coming from taxes levied on its members and the proceeds of fines imposed. A reform justified by the need to strengthen the independence of the CSSF.

The reform of Esma is counter-productive

The Minister also reaffirmed his opposition to the European Commission's plan to centralise financial supervision within the Union. The Finance Minister is concerned about the European Commission's market integration supervision package, which aims to extend the powers of the Paris-based European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA). Under this reform, Esma would be able to directly supervise market infrastructures (stock exchanges, clearing houses) and major asset managers, which are currently mainly under national control, and would be given direct supervision of the main providers of crypto-asset services (PSCAs) to ensure uniform application of the rules. In addition, a body within Esma made up of six independent members would be able to decide in certain cases in place of the 27 national supervisory authorities.

Gilles Roth considers these proposals counterproductive and believes they "miss the mark". He points out that the text of over 400 pages increases bureaucracy, complexity and costs, which is detrimental to the competitiveness of the European and Luxembourg financial sectors. He also criticises the phenomenon of "gold-plating" (national over-regulation when transposing directives), which hinders financial players.

National expertise and cost control

More than ever, he will be defending "national expertise and proximity" when it comes to supervision. "Centralism is no guarantee of efficiency when compared with local knowledge", he insisted. "Centralisation leads to a loss of national expertise, which is essential for understanding the specific needs of the market and adapting financial products. He pointed out that, according to the Commission, the supervision of an operator now requires 2.5 people per national authority, thus increasing costs without there being a shortfall in supervision or a major crisis as in 2008. Another example to illustrate the drift in these costs is that of banking supervision by the European Central Bank (ECB), whose supervisory fees have risen from €326 million in 2015 to €680 million in 2024.