From the exchanges between Claude Marx (CSSF) as keynote speaker, Mario Pirola (Bank Pictet & Cie Europe), Norbert Becker (Paypal), Françoise Thoma (Spuerkeess) and Hugo Banziger (ex-Deutsche Bank) could come new ideas, the organisers hope. Montage: Maison Moderne

From the exchanges between Claude Marx (CSSF) as keynote speaker, Mario Pirola (Bank Pictet & Cie Europe), Norbert Becker (Paypal), Françoise Thoma (Spuerkeess) and Hugo Banziger (ex-Deutsche Bank) could come new ideas, the organisers hope. Montage: Maison Moderne

With Claude Marx (CSSF) delivering a keynote and Françoise Thoma (Spuerkeess), Norbert Becker (Paypal), Mario Pirola (Bank Pictet & Cie Europe) and Hugo Banziger (ex-Deutsche Bank) speaking on 4 June at Mudam for the third edition of the Elvinger Hoss Annual Regulatory Forum, Pit Reckinger and Henri Wagner are hoping to shake the banking coconut tree in Luxembourg in a positive way.

The subject couldn’t have come at a better time: at a time when there seems to be no end to the controversy surrounding the opening of bank accounts and the emergence of new solutions such as Fundbank for the fund industry, when artificial intelligence and technology are enabling and will increasingly enable tasks to be automated and friction to be reduced, when neobanks are taking customers away from traditional players and when crypto is shaking things up, the future of the financial centre must be written in terms of profitability. This is what Pit Reckinger and Henri Wagner are repeating as they organise the third edition of Elvinger Hoss’ Annual Regulatory Forum.

Paperjam: You organise the Regulatory Forum every year. What’s the aim?

Pit ReckingerPit Reckinger (PR): The idea is to move away from a purely legal framework to tackle a subject of general interest to the financial centre. Last year it was ESG and artificial intelligence. This year, we’re looking at a very topical issue: bank profitability.

Henri WagnerHenri Wagner (HW): Today, the issue of profitability is critical. Interest rates, which have long been a stable source of income for banks, will no longer play this role in the future. So we need to reinvent business models.

Is this pressure also coming from regulators?

HW: Absolutely. The SREP reports [Supervisory Review and Evaluation Process, editor’s note] that regulators send to banks often contain this message: “Your governance is correct, your controls too, but your profitability raises questions.” This is both regulatory and competitive pressure.

PR: The reality is that the number of banks is shrinking. We’ve gone from 143 to around 116 institutions in ten years, or almost 20%. And they are under pressure not only because of regulation, but also because of new entrants from neobanks, fintechs, debt funds, and especially Big Tech like Amazon or Apple.

HW: These giants have unrivalled access to the customers they have acquired on their marketplaces and offer a much smoother user experience. It’s a godsend for them if they use both aspects and banks don’t have the answer to these behemoths.

What about fintechs?

HW: They have real potential, but remain limited by their access to resources and the difficulty of gaining the trust of customers. Big Tech, on the other hand, can really shake up the ecosystem.

And how can Luxembourg banks respond to these challenges?

HW: This is precisely one of the central questions of the forum: which models are sustainable in Luxembourg? Some banks are choosing to refocus on wealthy customers, who are more profitable. Others are seeking to automate as much as possible so that they can continue to serve customers with lower margins. But this requires major investment in digitalisation and AI.

PR: There is also a regulatory issue. Over-regulation is often criticised, but good supervision can also be a commercial advantage. For funds, this is what has made Luxembourg a global player. Why not consider the same thing for banks?

HW: And if banks want to focus more on wealthier clients, is that an advantage? Knowing that this clientele is very demanding and wants 24/7 access. This will require changes.

And in implementing these transformations, is the current regulation appropriate?

PR: There is still some vagueness. Solutions like iHub, which centralises customer identification, are promising, but they need to become market standards. Technological investment is essential, but costly. And some banks find themselves trapped with dozens of heterogeneous systems accumulated over time.

HW: Luxembourg could pool certain technological tools, as has been done in Switzerland. But for that to happen, we need courage, we need to move away from conservatism, and we need to overcome the obstacles linked, for example, to banking secrecy. There was solidarity from the Swiss financial community to achieve this.

PR: And we should also remember that Luxembourg has always moved forward by finding common solutions.

HW: It’s important that new generations arrive on boards to bring new ways of looking at things.

On the topic of cryptoassets, what is your position?

HW: The regulator is watching, but the banks are remaining cautious. And that’s understandable: a crypto scandal would do far more damage to a market like Luxembourg than to a major market like London or New York.

Institutionally, do you think banking, fund and crypto regulation should be separated?

HW: This is not on the agenda. The CSSF already operates through specialised departments, but could go further in terms of specialisation. The Autorité des Marchés Financiers in France is very advanced on crypto, for example. We also need specialised staff and dialogue with the market.

What are you trying to get out of this conference?

PR: We want to create a useful debate, with very different speakers: traditional banks, private banks, payment services players, etc. The idea is to bring out the sustainable models. What we already know is that we will need to invest in tech, review business models, and perhaps make Luxembourg not just a financial centre, but a financial industry.

HW: And we’re also hoping to shake things up a bit. Last year, Mark Tluszcz provoked people by saying that those who don’t invest in AI today will be held responsible tomorrow. This is the kind of electroshock we want to provoke: to make people think and move things forward.

Register for the conference here.

This article was originally published in French.