In two opinions issued on the Frieden government's reform of the pensions system - the first concerning draft law 8634 aimed at reforming the Luxembourg pensions system and the second dealing with the accompanying tax measures -, The Chamber of Employees is opposed to the compulsory extension of the insurance period required for access to early retirement, to the progressive pension scheme and to the increase in the deductibility ceiling for private pension provision, which it is calling for to be abolished. Unsurprisingly, it approves the increase in the contribution rate, the more flexible recognition of periods of study and the adjustment ensuring that the end-of-year allowance is maintained.
At the outset, the CSL is - again - severely critical of the way in which the consultation process was conducted, deploring a lack of respect for the tripartite model that reduced everyone to "stakeholders" and describing the government's approach as superficial.
A criticism of superficiality echoed by the employers' representatives, but on the substance of the reform, which they consider insufficient. A reform that has been repeatedly described as a "reformette", and of which the employers reject certain key aspects: the increase in the contribution rate, the more flexible recognition of periods of study and the adjustment ensuring that the end-of-year allowance is maintained. These are the only three points that the Chamber of Employees considers acceptable and which it calls for immediate adoption, while rejecting the rest of the bill in its current form.
For it, the increase in contributions does not constitute a major threat to competitiveness. The CSL also welcomes the removal of the age condition (between 18 and 27) for the recognition of periods of study, while maintaining the nine-year ceiling. "This is a real improvement for insured persons. It also welcomes the retention of the end-of-year allowance and calls for the condition linking this allowance to a contribution threshold to be removed entirely.
Firm opposition
The Council of State has the formal opposition. The SLC has "firm" opposition. It is therefore firmly opposed to the compulsory extension of the insurance period required for access to early retirement, deeming it socially unjust, inefficient and potentially confusing for insured persons. In the Chamber's view, the measure risks exacerbating the "waiting room" phenomenon, causing costs to be shifted to other branches of social security (sickness, invalidity, unemployment) rather than prolonging actual working activity.
It also criticises the introduction of a gradual pension scheme, deemed too complex, too administrative and non-binding, a measure likened to an employment management measure for senior citizens (early retirement) rather than a genuine partial pension falling under the Social Security Code, which weakens its scope.
The tax deduction for staying in work (AMVP)? The introduction of this allowance of €750 per month up to a maximum of €9,000 per year is mainly likely to result in a "pure windfall effect" for employees and self-employed people in high-paid sectors "who would probably have worked until the age of 65 anyway". The CSL is arguing for a refundable tax credit in place of the allowance, deeming this method fairer, as it would benefit all eligible taxpayers, including those on modest incomes.
Finally, the Chamber of Employees deplores the omission of a structural revaluation of the minimum pension, which is essential to combat the risk of poverty.



