I read with interest the article published on 16 July 2025 in Paperjam [a guest contribution by Mangrove Capital Partners’ CEO Mark Tluszcz, editor’s note] advocating for the establishment of a Bitcoin strategic reserve for Luxembourg. The piece was penned with conviction--but conviction, as ever, is no substitute for sound policy judgment.
I actually wrote an article rebutting that article point by point. It first swelled to 6,600 words which I then pared down to 4,400 words. It was and is a solid technical answer. Yet, the more I read and re-read it the more displeased I was. I was missing the point, by a mile.
Here is my second attempt at an answer, and I will not rebut each of the points raised in that 16 July article--ranging from a bitcoin strategic reserve is a hedge, geopolitically important, will attract innovation... The angle I am choosing is rather unconventional.
First, what is a strategic reserve?
A strategic reserve is not a bet. It’s not a “play.” It’s not a vanity asset. It is, by design and purpose, a state-controlled stockpile of vital resources--resources that are:
—Essential to economic and physical continuity (e.g. oil, gas, food, or gold);
—Liquid and universally accepted during crises;
—Non-speculative and stable in value; and
—Immediately accessible in times of geopolitical or systemic disruption.
The strategic reserve exists to provide resilience, not return. It is built not to win, but to withstand. It is the safety net that catches the nation when the market fails, not a moonshot portfolio hoping for the next bull cycle.
Bitcoin, despite the hype and headlines, fails every criteria above:
1. Not essential: It doesn’t power anything. It doesn’t feed anyone. It doesn’t settle real-world obligations.
2. Unreliable liquidity in crisis: Market depth evaporates under stress; large sales move price violently.
3. Volatile and speculative: It has repeatedly experienced drawdowns of 50-80%--the opposite of stable.
4. Operational fragility: Its utility depends on electricity, internet infrastructure, functioning exchanges and friendly jurisdictions. None of which are guaranteed in a crisis.
To put it bluntly: Bitcoin is not a strategic asset. Equating it with gold, oil or foreign reserves is not just mistaken--it’s a fundamental category error.
And what is Bitcoin’s practical utility? Beyond irrefutable proof that someone with a private key controls a cryptographic entry on a distributed ledger--and this in and of itself is crucial innovation? None, I dare say other that sheer speculation.
Second, what is Bitcoin?
If Bitcoin is not a reserve asset, then what is it?
To borrow from John Maynard Keynes, Bitcoin is the archetypal beauty contest asset. In such markets, investors do not choose what they personally find attractive. They attempt to predict what the average opinion believes the average opinion will be.
In this framework:
—Prices reflect reflexive expectations, not intrinsic value.
—Markets are dominated by second- and third-order speculation.
—Stability depends not on fundamentals, but on narrative momentum and social coordination.
Bitcoin, in this light, is a perfect specimen. It generates no yield, pays no interest and has no cash flow. Its price is determined by collective belief, attention cycles and perceived scarcity.
The result?
—No anchor of value: Unlike stocks (earnings), bonds (coupons) or real estate (rents), Bitcoin produces nothing.
—Returns are narrative-dependent: “Digital gold,” “inflation hedge,” “tech stock proxy,” “future of money”, “payment rail infrastructure”, “store of value”, “exchange mechanism”--take your pick.
—Psychological contagion is systemic: Fuelled by social media, influencer hype and leveraged speculation.
Even as institutional players dip their toes, they do so with eyes wide open: this is a game of future belief, not fundamentals. And while that may be acceptable for hedge funds and tech VCs (for full disclosure, I am a fintech VC) or or asset managers in reasonable quantities, it is a non-starter for sovereign balance sheets, which require decisions grounded in economic utility and risk-adjusted reality, not memetics and momentum.
Third, “who” wants us to own Bitcoin?
There is an obvious answer. Those who want to profit from Bitcoin. The next fool who purchases Bitcoin has made the previous wiseman rich. This statement is obviously true in the context of a beauty contest with rising price momentum. Absent rising momentum, as we noted above, liquidity evaporates, there are no new buyers and the last buyer is left holding the bag(s).
Is that answer complete? Could a sovereign want us to own bitcoin, instead of or in addition to current bag holders? For what purpose would a sovereign want us to own bitcoin? Other than to further its own designs and ensure its survival, a sovereign, if Bitcoin would be of use, would not care one way or the other if we were to own Bitcoin. In other words, an independent, distributed and decentralised Bitcoin is a threat to any sovereign and will not be allowed to exist as such.
Indeed, up until recently most, if not all, governments were against Bitcoin, and the more Bitcoin rose, the more they were against it. This is not necessarily the case anymore. First, because Bitcoin is actually extremely centralised. Second, because the financial services industry has figured out a way to profit from it--“there is old in them thar hills”. Third, because one of the mightiest sovereigns has plans of its own…
Fourth, why do “they” want us to own Bitcoin?
This is where my thinking starts to get a tad unconventional. Follow me down the yellow brick road, if you will.
The current situation stems from the GFC, which led us down the path of the great bailout and of near zero interest rates and major trade imbalances. Even though the era of near zero interest rates is behind us, we still live through its consequences. The main consequences are: a) global debt has ballooned and is out of control--over three times global GDP last I checked, b) we are still saddled with non performing assets (see Italian banks, most European banks, fragile US assets addicted to rising prices), c) growth that only benefitted the elites and thereby hollowed out the middle class and d) the current global trade wars.
In other words, we have arrived at a very important point in this century, one where we are forced to face pain, were tectonic plates are being rearranged, and where, amongst other things, we will have a new financial services architecture going forward.
My hypothesis is that two governments have understood the need for pain and rearchitecting and are actively leading with their own solutions. These are the USA and China. I will not dwell on China’s solutions (and predicaments). I will only state that Chinese solutions will be net/net negative for us Europeans.
As for the US, I encourage you to read the Genius Act, the Clarity Act and an anti-retail CBDC bill which were all passed recently in Congress. The Genius Act makes USD backed stablecoins legal and regulated onshore in the US--the act creates other things, all of which favour a tokenised world and a new era of financial services. The Clarity Act simplifies and clarifies the internecine wars between the CFTC and the SEC--what is a security and what is not a security is clear, yet another act favouring a tokenised world. Finally, the anti-retail CBDC bill makes sure stablecoins are the only game as far as financing the US federal government is concerned.
The Genius Act goes as far as stipulating that in the event a USD stablecoin issuer were to go bankrupt, holders of those USD stablecoins will be made whole--guaranteed by the US government. This clause is unprecedented as it goes against jurisprudence around bankruptcy law. The only reason being that the US government wants to show the world USD stablecoins will be the new safe assets standard.
Many are quick to criticise and ridicule the Trump administration. Although there is much to ridicule and criticise, I would take these new legislative acts very seriously. Not since the Dodd Frank Act of 2010 have there been acts of Congress with such momentous implications for our global financial system.
It is my belief that the Trump administration has figured out and decided that USD stablecoins will be the new technical and distribution conduit to finance the US federal budget and deficits AND also a means to rebase USD assets and reset our global debt conundrum. Brace yourselves for a USD dominance on steroids from here on out unless other countries figure out counter measures.
Stablecoins (with US government assurances) will be a safe asset, controlled by the US government, safely tucked in your digital wallets and providing yield to their holders by being invested in tokenised USD money market funds, amongst other things. That sound you are hearing is that of capital inflows to the US. As these stablecoins will be controlled by US issuers and ultimately the US government, they will be easily taxed or manipulated for the benefit of said US government--just enough to still be attractive and still finance the US.
Stablecoins will be the necessary step to a world of tokenised assets. Your digital wallets will be populated by stablecoins and also other assets you buy and sell, all of which in a tokenised form.
My hypothesis is that Bitcoin, as the leading crypto asset due to its market share dominance, is a convenient lightening rod to lead the great unwashed masses of investors to crypto and tokenised nirvana. In other words, Bitcoin is a convenient expedient, due to its history and timing, to the US government. Nothing more, nothing else. Squashing Bitcoin now risks derailing a world of stablecoins, and without a world of stablecoins, there will be no world of tokenised assets.
Fifth, what strategic reserve should Luxembourg build?
What asset was extremely strategic to Luxembourg from 2009 to 2020? I claim that strategic asset was the cluster of funds services created by timely laws, timely regulatory oversight and the accumulation of know how in the form of aggregate employment in that sector. That was holistically THE STRATEGIC ASSET of Luxembourg in the recent historical period.
My strong conviction is that Luxembourg needs to rethink and rebuild this legacy asset and repurpose it for the future of money and assets which the USA is actively enabling.
This means helping new champions to emerge around issuing tokenised assets, servicing tokenised assets, issuing stablecoins, servicing stablecoins.
This means helping reducing the cost of servicing funds and investors to remain competitive across Europe and around the world.
This means doubling down on digitising the entire Luxembourg financial centre.
This means doubling down on the legal blockchain arsenal, if needed expand and/or tweak, to attract foreign champions or facilitate native emergence.
This means unlocking Luxembourg private and public capital capital to fund innovation.
This means harnessing all the Luxembourg actors who can help with this new grand bargain.
Many will tell me much has been done already with the various blockchain laws voted and with the CSSF starting to hand out Mica licences. Some will tell me the Luxembourg government does invest in innovation--and rightly so.
All efforts need to be redoubled and much remains to be done. I will note that Luxembourg sits within the EU which, when it comes to financial services regulation, can be a disadvantage. US legislation and regulation tends to foster open markets that seek innovation. This leads to higher economic growth in general. EU legislation and regulation tends to foster closed markets that control innovation. This leads to lower economic growth in general. Luxembourg has been fortunate to carve a niche in alternative funds and funds services which has all the characteristics of an open market (attracting GPs and LPs from all over the world in a two-sided market) and therefore yielded above average growth for the country. Given the EU’s financial services regulatory’s burden, it behooves the country to carve another niche for the next 20 years, one which will also exhibit open market characteristics and will also yield above average economic growth.
Oh, and lest I forget, accumulating Bitcoin will only have us hold a highly speculative and highly risky bag. This could prove very lucrative assuming the country has tolerance for such high risk and wild market fluctuations and is willing to suffer losses. Believing holding Bitcoin will yield additional effects, some strategic, is potentially a grave mistake.
*Pascal Bouvier is managing partner & co-founder of the VC firm Middlegame Ventures.

