“The word ‘transition’ means different things to different people,” points out one expert. “It will be very important for asset managers to be clear.” Photo: Shutterstock

“The word ‘transition’ means different things to different people,” points out one expert. “It will be very important for asset managers to be clear.” Photo: Shutterstock

The sustainable fund market, worth €2.3trn as of December 2023, is maturing: there are fewer new funds and higher standards to meet. Financial experts discussed the findings of the European Sustainable Investment Funds Survey at a recent Alfi webinar.

Nobody in the world is as taken with sustainable funds as Europeans are: some 85% of all sustainable funds are European, the next-most active region being North America, trailing distantly with 11%. The only other colour on the graph--shown during a presentation of the European Sustainable Investment Funds Study results--belonged to the Asia and Pacific region, with 3%.

Will those other regions ever catch up? North America currently faces what Anne Estoppey, data and market intelligence officer at Tameo Impact Fund Solutions, euphemised as “important challenges” during the Association of the Luxembourg Fund Industry’s webinar. Those in Asia and the Pacific, meanwhile, are getting more interested: their sustainable funds market grew by 26% in 2023, though it still makes up only 2% of their total investment fund market. (In Europe, that latter number is 19%).

Zooming in, the study found that the biggest hitters for sustainable funds without Europe are France (11% of Europe’s sustainable funds), the UK (11%), Ireland (16%) and--still on top of the list by a healthy margin--Luxembourg (34%).

By the numbers

What does the sustainable funds market look like in Europe? As of December 2023, it was worth €2.3trn (up from under €1trn in 2019) and made up 19% of the overall European funds market (up from 6% in 2019). And after a slowdown in growth in 2022 (7%) it rebounded in 2023 with growth of 20%. By comparison, conventional (non-sustainable) funds grew that year by a smaller, albeit similar, rate of 17%.

Estoppey also noted that certain countries had, within their own markets, a much higher share of sustainable funds than the European average, including Belgium, France and Austria (about 40% in each versus a European average of 19%). The data shows, she says, the strength of these regions’ regulatory frameworks.

In terms of strategy, passive investing--i.e., funds that try to replicate the performance of a specific index--has grown in popularity: in 2019, 20% of sustainable funds used a passive strategy versus 29% in 2023. (The trend is visible in conventional funds too, in which the share went from 21% to 26% over the same period.)

“What’s really interesting,” added Estoppey, “is that nearly all the net inflows in 2023 went into passive strategies--they grew by 39% in 2023.”

Asked about impact funds, i.e., those that integrate social and environmental factors into their strategies, Estoppey commented that they remain a “niche market.” The study defined them as a sub-segment of sustainable funds, and calculated that they valued €418bn at the end of 2023 and accounted for 18% of the sustainable fund market in Europe. “But it’s interesting that they’ve nearly tripled in size since 2019,” she added.

Inflows and slowdowns

In 2024, European ESG funds had their lowest inflows in seven years, reported Hortense Bioy of Morningstar, the webinar’s other speaker: just $53bn, down from $78bn the year before and far below a record-high $527bn in 2021. “What makes 2024 a disappointing year for ESG funds,” she said, “is the fact that the rest of the market enjoyed a boom.” To explain the drop, Bioy mentioned several factors: mixed performances, concerns over greenwashing, political and regulatory uncertainty and, in the US, growing anti-ESG sentiments.

But when looking at assets, the story is different: European ESG funds reached a new record of $2.7trn at the end of 2024, up 8% from a year earlier. “This level of assets reflects the continuous interest of European inventors in sustainability issues,” said Bioy, “especially climate change.”

The Morningstar expert also noted that, in Europe, fewer ESG funds were launched in 2024 than in the years prior, a trend she expects to continue. “This slowdown reflects the normalisation of the ESG product development activity, after three years of very high growth.” Regulatory uncertainty (e.g., around SFDR 2) and accusations of greenwashing have also made asset managers more cautious, she said.

In fact, more ESG funds were closed in 2024 (350) than were opened, “and this year we may actually see a decrease in the number of ESG funds offered in Europe,” said Bioy, attributing the trend to anti-greenwashing rules like those in the UK’s SDR and Esma’s funding guidelines.

Down the road

“I see two major trends playing out this year,” said Bioy. First, the way that those anti-greenwashing rules are going to affect the ESG fund market. And second--relatedly--there will be more “transition strategies” and better definitions of what “transition” really means.

To give a sense of the scale of the anti-greenwashing regulations, as of May 2024, some 4,300 EU funds were found to be potentially in scope of Esma’s new fund naming guidelines (i.e., those funds with ESG- or sustainability-related terms in their names). Bioy therefore anticipates that 30%-50% of European ESG funds, or between 1,200 and 2,200 of them, will change their names in the very near future.

Of course, the point of these naming regulations is ultimately to raise the standards of the funds that call themselves “sustainable,” and many funds will want to continue doing so, which will mean hitting the criteria set by Esma in the regulation. For example, to keep terms like “environmental,” “ESG,” “sustainable impact,” “SRI” or “green,” funds will have to apply the Paris-Aligned Benchmark and thus be essentially fossil-fuel free.

This links to Bioy’s other prediction about transitions. “The word ‘transition’ means different things to different people,” she commented. “It will be very important for asset managers to be clear.” Currently, she points out, the concept of a “transition strategy” encompasses the energy transition, transition enablers, transition leaders, transitioning companies or transitions that happen at the portfolio level (e.g. hitting decarbonisation targets via a trajectory).