Yuriko Backes presented her bill on Luxembourg's new military and defence satellite, GovSat-2, on Wednesday. Let's bet that it will no longer carry "third-party" technologies like Luxeosys this summer. (Photo: Paperjam / Archives)

Yuriko Backes presented her bill on Luxembourg's new military and defence satellite, GovSat-2, on Wednesday. Let's bet that it will no longer carry "third-party" technologies like Luxeosys this summer. (Photo: Paperjam / Archives)

At the end of July, the Defence Minister announced a €500m investment in a second GovSat and even sketched out a third military and defence satellite with SES. This Wednesday, Yuriko Backes presented her bill to MPs. In between, Luxeosys has taken off with Space X, packed with Israeli technology. To general indifference.

Promise, this time, Luxembourg's new satellite will be "sovereign", built notably on the French Spacebus 4000B2 platform at Thales Alenia Space, in Cannes Mandelieu. Times are changing and politics is adapting. "While satellites play a crucial role in military communications, navigation, command of operations and the transmission of strategic data, they have become priority targets in any strategy of destabilisation or asymmetric confrontation. GovSat-2 is a strategic response to these developments: it will be a sovereign, protected, higher-performance capability, incorporating hardening, encryption, flexible bandwidth and advanced anti-jamming technologies," says the press release issued on Wednesday evening by the Defence Directorate, just before 9pm, after Defence Minister Yuriko Backes presented the project to the Chamber of Deputies' Defence Committee.

"GovSat-2 is fully in line with the government's ambition to invest in strategic defence projects with significant economic benefits. It will strengthen Luxembourg's visibility and credibility in the defence and security space sector", says the minister in defence of this project, which in 2018 gave rise to a joint venture between the State and the world leader in satellites, SES. But without really noting that it also allows the country to spend the money it "must" spend to reach the level required at Nato by US President Donald Trump. For Luxembourg, a magnificent political-industrial win-win, to be sure.

Let's bet that the MPs will have challenged the minister on the amount of investment around this project more than they did, at the time, with the Luxeosys Earth observation satellite, set to music by Étienne Schneider and put back on the rails of financial reality by his successor François Bausch, after weeks of controversy. Even if LSAP would be quite entitled to demand today what it did not demand in 2018...

It is less certain that they will have challenged the technological dimension of the new GovSat. Take the other military satellite, for example. Launched this summer by Space X - instead of the European launcher Arianespace - to speed things up, Luxeosys is packed with Israeli technology, such as the camera from Elbit Systems, one of the companies targeted by the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Occupied Palestinian Territories, Francesca Albanese, or the platform from IAI, which is totally subservient to the Israeli government by design. For security reasons, the Luxembourg communication at the end of August makes no mention whatsoever of these industrial "partners", confining itself, in the fact sheet and the press release, to citing OHB and OHB-Italia as its referents.

"The public contract for the Naos / Luxeosys Earth observation system, was awarded in 2018 to OHB Italia S.p.A. without publication of the contract, in application of article 13 under the law of 26 December 2012 on public defence and security contracts. Thus, there is no official reference of the contract or a TED notice", the Defence Directorate states unsurprisingly. Unsurprisingly, because this kind of technology is not meant to be exposed in the public arena, and it only took a few articles in the Israeli media praising their companies for us to realise this.

"Since the contract with OHB Italia was signed in 2018, the Defence Directorate has been kept regularly informed by OHB Italia, through programme monitoring meetings. The contract also included key stages, such as the validation of sub-systems and the selection of suppliers. At each stage, the manufacturer provided the Defence Directorate with information about the subcontractors and the equipment used for the satellite", she adds. Without going into too many technical details, there were alternatives if we had really wanted to be independent of countries outside Europe.

Before specifying, again at our request, that in 2018 the geopolitical situation was very different from the one that has seen Israel massacre thousands of Palestinians for months, well beyond an "appropriate" response to the horrific massacre of 7 October 2023. This is entirely understandable, but it is a reminder that Luxembourg's storytelling about its sovereignty and role in this context must absolutely and uncompromisingly be accompanied by the use of technologies and launchers that are, if not Luxembourgish, at least European. All the more so since the erratic behaviour of the American genius, Elon Musk, with regard to communications cut off or restored, in Ukraine or elsewhere, according to political discussions, by Starlink, underlines that Europe needs 'ITS' totally independent solution. It has it thanks to the SES success story, and it needs to tell its strategic importance much better. Today, but above all tomorrow and the day after tomorrow.

This article was originally published in French.