The European Central Bank announced the findings of its most recent bank lending survey on Tuesday, which comprised 157 euro area banks and was conducted from 8 December 2023 to 2 January 2024. Photo: Shutterstock

The European Central Bank announced the findings of its most recent bank lending survey on Tuesday, which comprised 157 euro area banks and was conducted from 8 December 2023 to 2 January 2024. Photo: Shutterstock

The European Central Bank’s recent survey indicates a steady tightening in credit standards for enterprises and households, alongside a marked decrease in loan demand, suggesting a cautious lending environment in the euro area as of the fourth quarter of 2023.

The European Central Bank reported a moderate tightening of credit standards by euro area banks for loans or credit lines to enterprises in the fourth quarter of 2023. This increase in tightening, amounting to 4%, adds to the substantial cumulative tightening observed since 2022, significantly impacting loan growth to firms. The results of the quarterly bank lending survey, released on Tuesday 23 January 2024, highlighted that banks’ risk perceptions concerning the economic outlook and the state of firms continued to influence this tightening trend. However, factors like banks’ cost of funds, balance sheet situations, competition and risk tolerance were largely neutral in their impact.

The report noted that while credit standards remained unchanged in three of the four largest euro area countries, there was a general perception of increased risk. The impact of past tightening is expected to continue suppressing loan growth in the upcoming quarters. Lending to firms is thus anticipated to remain subdued in 2024. The rate of tightening has moderated from 12% in the Q3 2023 to lower than the banks’ expectations of 7% and below the historical average of 9%. Banks also expect further tightening in the Q1 2024, estimated at 9%.

Credit standards

The survey also identified a further net tightening of credit standards for loans to households in the Q4 2023. This tightening was less pronounced for housing loans (2%) and more significant for consumer credit (11%). Major factors contributing to this tightening included banks’ lower risk tolerance, especially in the consumer credit sector, and heightened risk perceptions.

The tightening in consumer credit was notable across the four largest euro area economies, while the slight tightening in housing loans was more prominent in smaller euro area countries. Despite being lower than the previous quarter, the net tightening was in line with expectations. Banks predict a continued tightening in both housing loans and consumer credit.

Loan demand

The fourth quarter of 2023 saw a notable decrease in firms’ net demand for loans, with a net percentage of -20%. Higher interest rates and a reduction in fixed investment were primary drivers of this decline, particularly affecting the demand for long-term loans. Nevertheless, financing needs for inventories and working capital provided some positive impetus to loan demand. While the decrease was less severe than the all-time low in the Q2 2023 (-42%), it continued the trend of substantial net decreases over the previous four quarters. Banks are expecting a slight increase in demand for loans to firms in Q1 2024, marking the first such increase since Q2 2022.

Housing loans and consumer credit

There was a continued decline in net demand for housing loans (-26%) and consumer credit (-7%). Key drivers of this decline included general interest rates, consumer confidence and housing market prospects, particularly impacting housing loan demand. Although the net decrease was more moderate than in the previous quarter, it was unexpectedly substantial for housing loans. Banks anticipate an increase in housing loan demand in Q1 2024 but expect consumer credit demand to continue declining.