European Union banks are breaching the European Banking Authority’s interest-rate shock outlier tests less often, but the watchdog says key weaknesses persist in how firms model risk, define credit-spread exposures and govern hedging.
The EBA on 26 January published a report setting out the medium to long-term objectives of its interest rate risk in the banking book heatmap, alongside observations and recommendations intended to guide supervisory dialogue and banks’ internal practices. The authority said the report does not introduce new regulatory requirements and that recommendations should be applied proportionately, reflecting each institution’s size, complexity, risk profile and business model.
The “heatmap” is the authority’s roadmap for monitoring interest rate risk in the banking book and follows an earlier phase of scrutiny that culminated in a short to medium-term implementation report in February 2025. The EBA said ongoing monitoring remains integral to its mandate to ensure consistent application of EU law and to promote common supervisory approaches and practices.
Outliers ease, but earnings shocks remain asymmetric
The EBA said banks have had time to adjust to a changed interest rate environment after a period in which rates rose rapidly and then moved to more stable levels. It said the supervisory outlier test results suggest a gradual adaptation in risk management practices, with improvements in the number of outliers under both of its headline measures.
Using December 2024 data, the authority reported one outlier under the economic value of equity metric, representing 0.66% of a sample of 152 banks. It said the number of outliers under the net interest income metric fell to 11 from 16 in 2023, with 11 out of 152 institutions, or 7.24% of the sample, breaching the threshold.
The report underscored that the two metrics behave differently under rate shocks. In 2024, the parallel up scenario drove the single economic value of equity outlier, while 10 of the 11 net interest income outliers were driven by the parallel down scenario, which the EBA said reflects the inherent asymmetry of the measures.
On aggregate sensitivity, the authority reported a weighted mean change in economic value of equity of -5.50% in 2024 compared with -9.27% in 2021, which it said indicates enhanced resilience and a narrowing dispersion in recent years. For net interest income, the weighted mean improved to -2.39% in 2024 from -2.80% in 2023, while the 5th percentile stood at -6.90%, which it said shows a small portion of banks remain highly sensitive to downward shocks.
The EBA also quantified the tail effects. It said the sole economic value of equity outlier exceeded the 15% threshold by €45m, while the combined exceedance for all net interest income outliers over the 5% threshold totalled €700m.
Five-year cap stays the default for deposits
A central medium-term focus remains how banks model non-maturity deposits, where behavioural assumptions can materially shape measured interest rate risk. The EBA said the five-year cap continues to operate as a harmonising benchmark and has had limited impact so far, though some institutions reported unintended consequences for risk management and hedging.
The authority recommended that supervisors maintain the five-year cap as the supervisory default and said any deviations should be approved by supervisors and disclosed under Pillar 3. Where banks seek a longer cap, the EBA said supervisors should expect early dialogue, robust evidence linked to business model and customer behaviour, back-tested data and consistency with internal measurement systems and hedging strategy. It added that any supervisor-approved cap above five years should be disclosed, including the quantitative impact on the change in economic value of equity and net interest income.
Margin modelling: keep flexibility narrow
The report reviewed how banks model commercial margins under the supervisory outlier test on net interest income and said constant-spread modelling remains widely used across most products. It said non-maturity deposits are an exception because behavioural features such as pass-through patterns can influence margins differently from contractually fixed cashflows.
The regulator recommended that guidance designed for non-maturity deposits should not be extended to other products, except where behavioural characteristics are material, warning that broader flexibility would weaken comparability across institutions.
Credit-spread risk perimeter remains uneven
The report highlighted continued heterogeneity in how banks define the “perimeter for credit spread risk” in the banking book. The EBA said institutions often restrict credit-spread analysis to fair value instruments, particularly debt securities, while amortised cost instruments are less consistently included, creating gaps in how spread sensitivity is captured.
It recommended that institutions work towards a consistent perimeter across both economic value of equity and net interest income metrics and avoid excluding instruments ex ante. The authority warned against perimeter choices driven purely by accounting classification, holding intention or the availability of market observations, and said firms should not narrow coverage to instruments with readily observable valuations while leaving out exposures where spread risk can still be material.
The EBA noted credit spread risk in the banking book should be included in the internal capital adequacy assessment process where material and urged supervisors to challenge gaps where instruments sensitive to market-wide or sectoral spreads are excluded.
Swaps dominate hedging and governance remains in focus
On hedging strategies, the authority said interest rate swaps remain the principal derivative instrument used by banks to mitigate interest rate risk in the banking book and that hedging materially changes the supervisory outlier picture.
It reported that when hedging is included, economic value of equity outliers fall to one institution, or 0.66% of the sample, compared with 55 institutions, or 36.18%, without hedging. For net interest income, outliers fall from 30 institutions, or 19.74%, without hedging to 11 institutions, or 7.24%, with hedging. This suggests banks place more emphasis on stabilising economic value than smoothing earnings volatility.
The report said micro-hedging is more common for debt securities and own issuances, while macro-hedging is more common for behavioural portfolios such as non-maturity deposits. It recommended that hedge designation align with product characteristics, that economic-hedging frameworks be well governed and that effectiveness be evidenced through regular back-testing and documentation.
The 27-page full length report is here.



