Katrien Veranneman, president of the Luxembourg Association for the Study of Competition Law, assures: even if the text on merger control is at a standstill, Luxembourg cannot remain the only EU Member State without one. (Photo: Paperjam/archives)

Katrien Veranneman, president of the Luxembourg Association for the Study of Competition Law, assures: even if the text on merger control is at a standstill, Luxembourg cannot remain the only EU Member State without one. (Photo: Paperjam/archives)

On the eve of the 7ᵉ Luxembourg Competition Law Day, on Thursday from 2pm to 6pm at the Chamber of Commerce, Luxembourg remains the only EU country without national merger control. The draft law intended to fill this gap has been blocked since the highly critical opinion of the Conseil d'État. Practitioners are getting impatient.

The 7ᵉ Journée luxembourgeoise du droit de la concurrence (Luxembourg Competition Law Day), organised this Thursday by the Association luxembourgeoise pour l'étude du droit de la concurrence (ALEDC) and the Chamber of Commerce, was supposed to focus on developments in a fast-moving legal sector. In the end, it opened against a backdrop of institutional deadlock that leaves Luxembourg in a unique position within the European Union: it is still the only Member State not to have a national merger control regime. A void that worries practitioners and which, in their view, is beginning to weigh on the legal certainty of the local market.

For Katrien VerannemanKatrien Veranneman, President of ALEDC, the assessment is bitter: "We are a year later and we find ourselves in the same situation, which is not necessarily good news, because nothing has moved forward. On the contrary, the Council of State has issued a fairly negative opinion. Last year, the bill was one of the major issues of the Day. This year, it is back for a very different reason: paralysis. Despite the former government's stated intention in August 2023 to equip the country with a scheme aligned with European standards, the text is now at a standstill, frozen since the publication, in June 2025, of a particularly severe opinion from the Council of State, tasked with examining its compliance and legal robustness.

The opinion contains a number of formal objections, preventing a final vote on the text without an in-depth rewrite. Criticism focuses on key points: the independence of the Competition Authority, threatened by the government's power of evocation; legal uncertainty arising from definitions deemed insufficiently precise; and powers of investigation or injunction considered too broad or poorly defined. Some of these criticisms are considered legitimate by the ALEDC. "As for the power of evocation, for example, I think that the Conseil d'État is right to question whether this does not call into question the independence of the authority," acknowledges its president.

"In other Member States, this has not acted as a brake"

But other criticisms leave specialists perplexed. One of these relates to the criterion of connection based on local turnover, which is used in the vast majority of European regimes. "The Conseil d'Etat says that this would bring into the scope of application transactions that are decided elsewhere. It's true, it's possible, but it's all a question of the impact on the local market. We were surprised by this comment", explains Katrien Veranneman. On this point, the association believes that the Conseil d'État has been "unnecessarily severe" and that, through an excess of legal caution, it risks delaying the introduction of a tool widely regarded as standard in the Union.

At the heart of the ALEDC, the position is firm: the absence of a national merger control law weakens Luxembourg. "In our view, it remains a question of legal certainty for the local market that there should be a local regime", says its president. The concern is all the more tangible because companies planning mergers or acquisitions do not always know how to proceed. They sometimes have to ask the Autorité de la concurrence without any real framework and wonder whether a referral to Brussels is justified. Representatives from the Authority will be speaking at the conference on the subject.

For practitioners, the argument that merger control would slow down transactions is not supported by European experience. "In other Member States, it has not acted as a brake. It simply allows an authority to intervene if necessary and not to be dependent on a possible review at European level", points out Ms Veranneman. The purpose of the tool is not to block, but to examine and, if necessary, regulate. Without it, the Luxembourg authorities are largely deprived of the means to act in situations where the competitive effect manifests itself exclusively on national territory.

Bringing the text into line now depends on further political arbitration. It would appear that work on a revised version is underway, but ALEDC has no knowledge of a timetable. The association is counting on the current legislature to get the text moving again. "We hope that there will still be the political courage to bring this exercise to a conclusion," sums up the President. It is an appeal designed to remind us that Luxembourg cannot remain on the fringes of standard European practice for long.

Cooperation for the environment, benefits and limits

The Competition Law Day will nevertheless go well beyond this issue. Two other themes will round off the debates. The first concerns sustainability agreements, cooperative ventures between competitors aimed at producing beneficial effects for the environment but which, depending on the case, may come into tension with the traditional rules of competition law. "The aim is to see how the authorities view these forms of cooperation between competitors that are considered to be beneficial from an environmental protection point of view", explains Ms Veranneman, stressing the sometimes difficult balance between innovation, ecological transition and respect for the principles of competition law. The second theme will be the development of European case law on powers of inspection and access to data during unannounced raids by competition authorities, a subject that touches on the sensitive boundary between economic investigations and fundamental rights.

But beyond these themes, the political and legal heart of the event remains the blocking of the merger control bill. For the players involved, the absence of a modern control tool is becoming difficult to justify. As the 7ᵉ Luxembourg Competition Law Day gets underway, for the ALEDC, the answer is no longer up for debate. "We don't want to give up on the issue," insists its president. The legislative process will now have to follow.