The challenge surrounding the law is to find a “good balance between the security of the state and also staying attractive as an investment hub,” said Mélody Brunot, counsel in charge of DLA Piper’s corporate law team. Photo: Studio Andrea

The challenge surrounding the law is to find a “good balance between the security of the state and also staying attractive as an investment hub,” said Mélody Brunot, counsel in charge of DLA Piper’s corporate law team. Photo: Studio Andrea

Legislation approved in parliament in June establishes a screening mechanism for foreign direct investment, with Luxembourg aiming to strike a balance between implementing EU rules and staying an attractive hub, says DLA Piper’s Mélody Brunot.

First submitted in September 2021 by Luxembourg’s foreign minister Jean AsselbornJean Asselborn (LSAP), bill 7885 aims to “establish a national screening mechanism for foreign direct investments (FDI) likely to affect security or public order,” says the Chamber of Deputies website. The legislation had been in the making years before the first draft.

“It’s actually the implementation of EU regulation that was adopted back in 2019, which tackled foreign direct investment,” explained Mélody Brunot, counsel in charge of DLA Piper’s corporate law team. This refers to investments made in EU member states by investors outside of the bloc in areas considered to be “critical” for security or public order.

The EU regulation invites member states to implement their own mechanisms to screen these foreign direct investments.

Law defines “critical” activities

“The law actually does several things,” said Brunot.  First, “it defines the activities which are considered as ‘critical’ for the state of Luxembourg.” Each member state can decide which activities are critical for security and public order.

In Luxembourg, these include the aerospace and defence sectors, the financial sector (payment infrastructure, for example), telecommunications, healthcare, energy production and distribution, data storage and data protection. Research and production activities directly linked to these sectors are also included in the law.

“Notion of control”

“Second, it also defines the notion of control,” she added. “Not every investment falls within the scope of the law. But only those that are made by foreign investors, and that would also give them the control over a Luxembourg entity which is active in the sectors which are considered as critical.”

Control, according to the bill, means having the majority of the voting rights of shareholders or partners of an entity governed by Luxembourg law, having the right to appoint or dismiss management members, being a shareholder or partner of a Luxembourg entity thanks to an agreement concluded with other shareholders or partners and controlling the majority of voting rights, or holding more than 25% of an entity’s capital.

The notion of control and critical activities are the key terms here.
Mélody Brunot

Mélody Brunot, corporate lawyer, DLA Piper

Luxembourg’s law also defines the procedures to follow when an investment falls within the criteria established by the law, as well as the sanctions that investors can incur should there be a breach of the law, explained Brunot.

Procedure to follow

Let’s say that a foreign company wants to invest in one of the critical sectors in Luxembourg. Does the law completely prohibit their investment?

They can still invest, said Brunot. But it means that they will have to go through a notification procedure with the ministry of the economy. “The ministry of economy has two months to decide whether or not the investment has to be screened, or whether there’s no need for a screening procedure to apply.”

Authorities can request additional information during a screening. “In any case, it has to be completed within 60 days. So all in all, it’s four months, approximately, of process,” said Brunot.

Exemption for portfolio investments

“There is an exemption for the application of this law to what they call ‘portfolio investments,’” she added. A portfolio investment, as defined in the bill, is “an acquisition of securities made with the intention of making a financial investment, without taking control of the entity governed by Luxembourg law.”

Under European regulation and this Luxembourg law, these are excluded from screening.

“It’s basically investment funds and holding companies that we want to target here, which, again, makes sense because they don’t have activity per se in Luxembourg,” said Brunot. “In investment funds, usually you don’t have someone holding more than 50% of the voting rights.”

Finding a “good balance”

“The whole challenge of this type of regulation at the EU level--and when they are implemented at the national level--is to find the good balance between the security of the state and also staying attractive as an investment hub,” said Brunot.

For Luxembourg, which is a financing, structuring and investment hub, it’s important not to discourage investment.

Screening procedures could have an impact on the timing of transactions and bring uncertainty as to whether the deal can be completed or not, Brunot added. That being said, “Luxembourg is a small country and there’s a very limited number of actors which are active in those sectors. So to me, this law is not necessarily something that would discourage anyone from investing in Luxembourg.”

As an EU-wide policy, the screening process could, however, also hit Luxembourg through outside paths.

The grand duchy is “used as a structuring jurisdiction. So a lot of companies or investment funds which are active in Luxembourg actually hold assets in another jurisdiction, which means that it’s not necessarily the Luxembourg law that will be applied, because the assets are not located in Luxembourg,” she said.

“Imagine that there’s a Luxembourg company that is willing to acquire an asset or participation in a company in Germany, which is active in an area which falls within the critical activities under German law,” she said, offering an example. “Then the screening procedure could apply to the Luxembourg company indirectly.”

Applicable in the coming days

“The notion of control and critical activities are the key terms here,” said Brunot. “I’m hopeful that it will not have a, let’s say, adverse impact on our jurisdiction.”

Parliament’s first vote, which took place on 13 June, saw the bill pass with 59 votes in favour (one person did not vote). Normally, bills go through two votes before a bill is published.

“But [parliament] asked for the waiver of the second vote, and it was obtained,” said Brunot. “It was confirmed today [20 June] that there would be no second vote, so it’s going to be published shortly. And once it’s published, it’s a matter of days until it’s applicable.”

This article was published for the Delano Finance newsletter, the weekly source for financial news in Luxembourg. Subscribe using this link.