Paperjam spoke with Christopher Colarik, head of US smaller companies, and Graham McCraw, senior equity investment specialist, both at Aberdeen, on 24 September 2025. Photo: Aberdeen

Paperjam spoke with Christopher Colarik, head of US smaller companies, and Graham McCraw, senior equity investment specialist, both at Aberdeen, on 24 September 2025. Photo: Aberdeen

In an interview with Paperjam, experts at Aberdeen argued that European small caps can thrive in low GDP growth, driven by stock-specific alpha. Rate cuts and diversification from US large caps provide tailwinds. They think that the US small caps are at a historic valuation discount and benefit from secular trends that may resume outperformance against large caps.  

“There’s a view that you buy small cap when the GDP is increasing and the macro looks good. We would actually strongly disagree with that,” said Graham McCraw, senior equity investment specialist at Aberdeen during an interview on 24 September 2025. He argued that European small caps can deliver strong returns even in a low GDP growth environment.

Aberdeen claims that its strategy has delivered an average five-year return of 14% per annum against 7.1% for the MSCI Europe and 10.6% for the MSCI All Country World Index. He thinks that it demonstrates that well-chosen companies with strong management and structural growth drivers can outperform regardless of the broader macro picture.

[We aim] to identify the large caps of tomorrow.

Graham McCraw, senior equity investment specialist, Aberdeen

Yet McCraw admitted that rate hikes in 2022 and 2023 hurt the small cap asset class. Positively, he observed that, “since the ECB cut on 6 June 2024, euro small caps have outperformed large caps… and investor confidence in US large cap is not what it was at the start of the year” as per discussions with clients. He believes that the asset class is for investors that “aren’t just driven by AI or are super expensive.”

Major performance contributors in Europe

McCraw assessed that about 70% of the outperformance of their strategy is attributed to stock-specific alpha, such as Germany’s Nemetschek, a vendor of software improving efficiencies for architects, engineers and the construction industry, as a major contributor of outperformance.

The portfolio is a focused selection of 40-50 stocks, chosen with a long-term perspective of three, five or even 10 years. Admitting that a gap with the benchmark build from time to time, McCraw stated that “we are not investing in companies that we hope beat next quarter earnings and we sell out.” He added: “what we’re looking for is companies that can grow earnings faster and for longer than the market expects… and aiming to identify the large caps of tomorrow.”

McCraw commented that their investment style is bottom-up stock picking with consistent style tilts towards quality, growth and momentum. To navigate the universe of roughly 1,000 European small-cap stocks, the team utilises a proprietary quant tool called “the matrix,” which screens companies based on 13 factors to identify promising candidates for fundamental analysis.

Looking ahead, McCraw sees interest rate cuts, increased German infrastructure and defence spending, and a growing demand for diversification away from US large caps as favourable trends for European small caps. Indeed, he also noted that international investors from the US, Australia and Singapore are showing increased interest in the asset class, as earnings are expected to grow faster for European small caps than European large caps from 2025 until 2027, according to Bloomberg. He also highlighted that small caps have outperformed large caps in 85% of rolling five-year periods since 2001, and he thinks that there is no reason to believe this long-term trend won’t continue.

US perspective: rate cuts may provide a boost

Restricted on naming stocks in the US strategy, Christopher Colarik, head of US smaller companies, identified defence spending, power grid modernisation (moving power lines underground) and the build-out of nuclear power facilities, in addition to solar and wind, as factors that will support AI-driven data centre growth as key secular trends driving investment.

Colarik also noted that the US energy sector has undergone a significant transformation, with drillers now showing financial discipline by aligning drilling programmes with cash flows, rewarding stakeholders with dividends and buybacks, and avoiding the previous boom-bust cycles. This discipline has made the sector attractive from a valuation and return-on-equity perspective, though stock prices have not fully reflected this.

Colarik commented that rate cuts are historically a strong tailwind for small caps due to their higher variable debt, which boosts profitability as interest expenses fall. He is constructive on financial (community banks) and industrial companies benefiting from reshoring and “consumers” but not any firms, as “there must be some separation between various income levels that seem to be being more impacted by the economic backdrop.”

The case for small caps vs. large caps

Both experts emphasised that despite recent underperformance of small caps driven by the AI hype in large caps, the former have historically outperformed over the long term.

—Valuation: US small caps are trading at a “40-year generation low” discount relative to large caps, a significant deviation from their historical premium.

—Performance: according to Aberdeen marketing material, high-quality US small caps (like the S&P 600) have significantly outperformed large caps S&P 500 over the last 25 years. Similarly, euro small caps have outperformed the S&P 500 for most of this century.

—Limited analyst coverage: on average three to six analysts would typically cover a small- or mid-cap company or would cover even “established, and profitable businesses,” according to McCraw. That compares to 25 to 28 on large caps. “We leverage analysts for their insight and their direct line of communication to these C suite companies,” said Colarik. He stressed that the lack of coverage does provide opportunities. “If you go out and spend time with these companies… the layer down below senior management who maybe aren’t investor trained… you can really discover things the market doesn’t know,” stated McCraw.

Investment strategies and offerings

The European team, based in Edinburgh, manages three flagship strategies: UK, euro and the global small-cap. The euro small-cap strategy has about €2.4bn in assets under management (AUM) which is, according to  McCraw, “one of the largest in its space.”

Colarik explained that Aberdeen’s US smaller company strategies amount to about $1bn in AUM. A key offering is an active ETF (ticker: AFSC), a focused portfolio of about 40 “standout” stocks derived from their broader flagship fund, which includes 40 to 60 stocks.

Unlike the US, McCraw indicated that Aberdeen has no immediate plans to launch an active euro small-cap ETF, citing a lack of investor demand in Europe.